Traded Caleb Daniel - Traded to North Melb for pick 25

[Vindicater]

16 AFL games in 2024 - "most of the year"?

Half as sub.

 

[Freomaniac]

Overs

So dogs 2016 premiership player Caleb daniel contracted, who is 171 cm, played 175 games in 10 seasons from 2015-24 is overs?

But Liam Baker out of contract that is similar height and similar player is worth pick 14?

 

[Freomaniac]

Was always going to be 25

and Liam baker was traded for pick 14.

 

[THE_GUN]

and Liam baker was traded for pick 14.

Yep that was his value like we always said

 

[tiger_tough]

So dogs 2016 premiership player Caleb daniel contracted, who is 171 cm, played 175 games in 10 seasons from 2015-24 is overs?

But Liam Baker out of contract that is similar height and similar player is worth pick 14?

 

[THE_GUN]

Apparently, the height of the player makes them more valuable
We should put Mate' Colina up for trade next season

 

[tiger_tough]

Apparently, the height of the player makes them more valuable
We should put Mate' Colina up for trade next season

also age and being a fringe player at the current club is not relevant at all...

 

[ManOfClay]

felt like coming up against his old side first up painted a good picture of why him moving on was for the best for his future at afl level.

Joel Freijah was the one who realistically pushed him out of the dogs’ best 22 and he is much better suited to the open running style we try to play off half back. Daniel is too slow, doesn’t have the athleticism and while his kicking is great when he’s on (he had 6 turnovers on Saturday night so he was a bit off) it doesn’t open the game up to the level of Freijah and Dale who are our preferred running defenders.

He’s best 22 for north though so it was a good move for him.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Daniel is too slow, doesn’t have the athleticism and while his kicking is great when he’s on (he had 6 turnovers on Saturday night so he was a bit off) it doesn’t open the game up to the level of Freijah and Dale who are our preferred running defenders.

I guess the million dollar question is... how much of that was down to Daniel's ability, how much was down to his team-mates not making leads into space, and how much was normal game-one-in-a-new-team teething problems.

 

[ManOfClay]

I guess the million dollar question is... how much of that was down to Daniel's ability, how much was down to his team-mates not making leads into space, and how much was normal game-one-in-a-new-team teething problems.

They were probably all factors to some degree. He certainly can’t have rapidly lost his ability.

 

[Wild Bill]

Solid start.

BEST
Western Bulldogs: Dale, Richards, Naughton, Liberatore, Vandermeer, Darcy
North Melbourne: Simpkin, Powell, Larkey, Sheezel, Daniel

 

[Wild Bill]

Was awesome today. Just so clean by foot.

 

[TruRoo]

First half was shaky but he improved greatly in the second half. Jury is still out, I didn't have him in our best round one.

 

[Wild Bill]

First half was shaky but he improved greatly in the second half. Jury is still out, I didn't have him in our best round one.

He had nearly 800 meters gained.

 

[TruRoo]

I'm off him - he's the ultimate supercoach player. Stats look good on paper but if you watch him it's easy to see we've been sold a lemon.

Runs himself around in circles before duffing a 35 metre helicopter to a man under pressure, or handballs into traffic. Then is simply unable to fit into a defensive system because he's slow, short and more often than not is out of position because he's tried to be attacking.

He played a good second half against Melbourne, who are pathetic. His impact was oversold after round one when his disposal was shaky and his man kicked goals, then yesterday he played like a crab.

 

[Foxman98]

I'm off him - he's the ultimate supercoach player. Stats look good on paper but if you watch him it's easy to see we've been sold a lemon.

Runs himself around in circles before duffing a 35 metre helicopter to a man under pressure, or handballs into traffic. Then is simply unable to fit into a defensive system because he's slow, short and more often than not is out of position because he's tried to be attacking.

He played a good second half against Melbourne, who are pathetic. His impact was oversold after round one when his disposal was shaky and his man kicked goals, then yesterday he played like a crab.

Yep his kicking dropped off a lot of the last 2 years,

He is also a defensive liability

 

[Wild Bill]

I'm off him - he's the ultimate supercoach player. Stats look good on paper but if you watch him it's easy to see we've been sold a lemon.

Runs himself around in circles before duffing a 35 metre helicopter to a man under pressure, or handballs into traffic. Then is simply unable to fit into a defensive system because he's slow, short and more often than not is out of position because he's tried to be attacking.

He played a good second half against Melbourne, who are pathetic. His impact was oversold after round one when his disposal was shaky and his man kicked goals, then yesterday he played like a crab.

Named in our best players in all 3 games. Not sure what more you are looking for. Hs been great.

 

[GoRoos2023]

Yep his kicking dropped off a lot of the last 2 years,

He is also a defensive liability

Kicking has been poor.

 

[TruRoo]

Named in our best players in all 3 games. Not sure what more you are looking for. Hs been great.

Supercoach level analysis from the staff reporters on the AFL website.

Why don't you post in the North board thread on this? most of us who watch the team closely are seeing what he is.

 

[Freomaniac]

Yep that was his value like we always said

and is Oscar Allen worth more or less than Liam Baker? lol

 

[THE_GUN]

and is Oscar Allen worth more or less than Liam Baker? lol

Well based on what some eagles supporters are saying he is cooked and so far performing terribly
if that doesnt improve then i doubt clubs will be paying him $1 mil plus for 6-7 years

If he does improve and play well then he certainly is and why would the eagles not want to keep their captain
Personally i wouldnt want my team to be paying him a million dollars a year

 

[Wild Bill]

Supercoach level analysis from the staff reporters on the AFL website.

Why don't you post in the North board thread on this? most of us who watch the team closely are seeing what he is.

33 at 82% DE isn’t horrendous. What does it matter where I post this? Bizarre.

 

[TruRoo]

33 at 82% DE isn’t horrendous. What does it matter where I post this? Bizarre.

Did you actually watch? A scrubby kick to a contest or a panic handball into traffic that results in a teammate being beset and tackled for a stoppage counts as effective on paper but absolutely costs the team. And then you account for his poor defensive coverage. He's lost whatever he had that made him effective at the dogs (which might be a simple case of teammates that can work with his limitations).

You seem to camp on this board desperate to claim we win every deal we are part of. It is just a little weird your assertions often don't match reality of what those who view the games see.

 

[Wild Bill]

Did you actually watch? A scrubby kick to a contest or a panic handball into traffic that results in a teammate being beset and tackled for a stoppage counts as effective on paper but absolutely costs the team. And then you account for his poor defensive coverage. He's lost whatever he had that made him effective at the dogs (which might be a simple case of teammates that can work with his limitations).

You seem to camp on this board desperate to claim we win every deal we are part of. It is just a little weird your assertions often don't match reality of what those who view the games see.

Well I checked out our board and it’s not all doom and gloom. The sky isn’t falling chicken little.

Not sure how involved at AFL level you have been that your view should be regarded as the truth.

 

[ManOfClay]

Has landed himself in a terrible situation for where is career is at. North are unable to cover his weaknesses so his **** ups are even more glaring.

He’ll be out of the team before they come good enough to really use him.