Opinion 2025 Player X v Y v Z

[PoopingHindi]

Sinclair and Henderson V Holmes and M.Reid

win/win
probably the first option if I have to choose but it’s just gut feel.

 

[Scythe]

Sinclair and Henderson V Holmes and M.Reid

First one

 

[Rickhead69]

Knevitt, Lashcroft & Lindsay competing for 2 spots on the field with no EMG loophole available.

Leaning Knevitt in the conditions as he seems to love a tackle and finding it hard to split Levi & X.

 

[Axly]

M.Reid v E.Hewett

 

[SC fish]

M.Reid v E.Hewett

I'm grappling with the same decision but am leaning Hewett due to DPP and cheaper.

 

[Axly]

I'm grappling with the same decision but am leaning Hewett due to DPP and cheaper.

Yeah I'm leaning away from him purely because he plays for WC

 

[SC fish]

Who to play onfield?

FOS or EHewett?

 

[TasSixer]

Probably doesn't matter but Stone v Hewett on field?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Probably doesn't matter but Stone v Hewett on field?

Hewett

 

[Cactus_]

Rowell $550K breakeven 50

Vs

Nacois $602K breakeven 134

 

[Borgan]

Rankine and Moraes +130k

vs

Baz and Humphrey/Maric +120k

 

[Jiska]

Rankine and Moraes +130k

vs

Baz and Humphrey/Maric +120k

TBH I think I’d rather Hump + Maric

But if I had to choose then I’d go the first. Rank will be a top 3 forward. Moraes will make good cash.

 

[Axly]

Hump v Maric

 

[Test Tickle]

Hump v Maric

Hump

 

[Scythe]

Hump v Maric

 

[Scythe]

But depends on what you want from the pick Axly. If it's a quick stepping stone, Humphrey due to BE and upcoming run. If you want F6 potential (at least until later in the year), Maric based on role.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Bice vs Moraes

Impacted by returning players
Bice - Mills & Cunners
Moraes - Butters & ???

 

[King Max]

Smith and Humphrey…
Or
Rankine and Moraes…

I swaying to the first one.

 

[Test Tickle]

Smith and Humphrey…
Or
Rankine and Moraes…

I swaying to the first one.

Smith and Humphrey…

Smith OR Humphrey?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Erasmus or Moraes

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Smith and Humphrey…

Smith OR Humphrey?

Smith and Humphrey…

 

[King Max]

Smith and Humphrey…

Smith OR Humphrey?

Both Smith and Humphrey getting traded in.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Bice vs Moraes

It's doing my head in

Moraes is better for my team structure - atm
But, having Bice will give me and extra defender; and therefore flexibility of who to trade out for upgrading season e.g. Short, SDK - without having to upgrade a defender (Holmes slots back from midfield)

So, it comes down to who has better JS?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Bice vs Moraes

It's doing my head in

Moraes is better for my team structure - atm
But, having Bice will give me and extra defender; and therefore flexibility of who to trade out for upgrading season e.g. Short, SDK - without having to upgrade a defender (Holmes slots back from midfield)

So, it comes down to who has better JS?

Both could be ****ed off quickly. I have both rn

 

[12Parks]

Is Bice a must have at the expense of other backline rookies, like Prior or Reid? Feel like Bice only one average game away from coming back to the pack. If he goes large again and one of the others are average, may look at a swap. Thoughts?