Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by Enforcer25

  1. E

    Rumour Best football related rumour you have heard from someone you trust

    Nothing to do with Hill’s missus. Kelly’s missus apparently has... history... with Brad Hill. Kelly has previously refused to consider Freo as an option because of this history.
  2. E

    Colin Sylvia Now A Docker

    Sylvia is NOT a mid. Not great at winning his own footy, or consistently hitting targets. Lays tackles, but usually because he doesn't read the ball well and gets there 2nd. High HFF is his position. Good kick for goal, strong body. I think he'll be really good at Freo - eventually. I...
  3. E

    Pick 2

    I get the feeling the Dees have had fruitful discussions with other clubs over players, such as Rockliff and Shuey, being given the impression that something WILL be worked out for pick 2... until coaches have been put into place at those clubs and have had / will have the final say. That being...
  4. E

    Melbourne Offseason 2013 - Players Needed, Enquire Within

    Rockliff............
  5. E

    Melbourne Offseason 2013 - Players Needed, Enquire Within

    So Josh Mahoney, in an article on the MFC website today, has said again that we will be offering pick 2 for trade, but that we know the value of pick 2, and as such we have a very specific short list of 3 or 4 midfielders across all teams that we would consider in such a trade. Any guesses who...
  6. E

    ilikepotatoes 2012 Phantom Draft

    Uh, yeah genius, pick 26 would be their second round pick...
  7. E

    Stefan Martin

    Any suggestions that MFC would want Neeld gone come from a position of pure ignorance. He's one of the best things to happen to the club in a long time. I think a proposal bordering on fairness would be: Stef Martin + pick 13 to Collingwood Wellingham + pick 21-ish to Melbourne This deal...
  8. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    Not sure why MELB would prefer scenario 2 to 3? Surely they'd want to get Viney with a second round pick more than anything?
  9. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    Rubbish. If MELB have picks 3&4, and Viney is bidder upon by either GC or GWS, it's essentially Viney or pick 2. Since if they pass on Viney, GC or GWS must then take him. That way either their pick 2 gets used up, or pick 2 gets bumped to pick 1, and MELB's picks get bumped up to 2 & 3.
  10. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    CAN do that, provided it is not done publicly. It's only negotiated, not signed off. Only draft tampering if you get caught. Sheedy mouthing off in the media is meaningless. In the end, GWS will do what is best for GWS, and it's unlikely they'd get a much better offer than pick 3 for one of the...
  11. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    In regards to "draft tampering", it's all about what you can prove beyond a shadow of a doubt, and that includes very little. You can't prove a player's "real" rating. You can't prove a team doesn't want a player more than any other at that pick. You CAN prove that 2 teams have made a deal for q...
  12. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    It would be hilarious, but how would that happen, genius? With the assumption the demons will finish with pick 3&4, Viney will be at either the demons, GC or GWS. He won't go anywhere else. Can't.
  13. E

    Melbourne vs The World: The Jack Viney Story

    If Melbourne have picks 3&4, it's really a decision between Viney and pick 2. Because if they relinquish Viney to GC or GWS, they forfeit their top 2 pick for him, meaning 1 of Whitfield or Grundy (or whoever you rate as top 2) will still be on the table. In any case, I think MFC will...
  14. E

    ilikepotatoes 2012 Phantom Draft

    In case BigSexC's post wasn't clear enough, the dees either take Viney with their first pick (3 in this example) or with their second round pick. I'm sure we'll see this mistake made a lot more in the lead up to the draft, though.
  15. E

    What would Melbourne want for Colin Sylvia?

    Not really. The post didn't say BEST 2 or 3. In terms of talent, he really is way up there. He just doesn't know how to apply himself to maximise it, and I'm not sure he's smart enough to even figure it out.
See more

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top