Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by jarman

  1. J

    Name the KPF/KPD you'd like us to get with our first pick

    My view to all this is that we will be top four again and do not need pick a KPF this year. Got Silvia and Gumbelton which gives us depth plus Keppler and Griffo coming back will also allow Clarke to play forward more. Our midfield and small backs are in good shape. KPB is the area we are...
  2. J

    Has Eade been there too long?

    Eade has had his time and does not have it. Tactically is years behind and showed it with todays performance. Doggies were playing three year old football against a team that is playing modern footy and Eade had no idea on how to change this. He is overrated.
  3. J

    Time up Tom Williams

    Totally agree. Soft and no idea on how to play AFL footy. Can't the coaching staff not see that he is useless.
  4. J

    Rookie Draft

    Watched a lot of Swans games over last couple of years and Hinkley is lucky to be in their best 22, let alone Freo's top 30. I have yet to see this blistering speed everyone talks and writes about. Can't kick and does not have natural footy nous. Should have been cut. As for Ruffles, O'Brien...
  5. J

    We want talls.

    IMO McPharlin is not a forward. Absolute "gun" in the backline and gives the team the necessary structure and stability. The team plays so much better when he is there. Rookie listing a fast, strong & tall player would be a good idea. There are still Gorilla forwards around - Cloke, Dawes...
  6. J

    Depth

    Whether Barlow, Pearce or Silvagni are any good, time will tell but all three have to be better than Hinkley. Does not impress me at all.
  7. J

    What we took out of tonights game.

    Watched the game and although NAB game and the first game of the season, without talls contesting in the foward line, you will be a bottom four club. If Hille and Laycock can play regularly then maybe Ryder up front will help. There is too many injury prone players in the squad with Gumbelton...
  8. J

    Tarrant to the Forward Line

    What I would like to see: Tarrant, Mcfarlane and Grover in the backline with Pav at FF and they stay there all season. The team is then built up around these guys. Tarrant acquitted himself well down back, Mcf plays best footy at CHB and Grover provides the hardness. They will make it...
  9. J

    Mark Nicoski

    Please I hope not. He is not the right fit for the club. Doggies were on kick off the GF so things must be right. Hall and Lake secured, keep Everittt as he will step up as will a couple of the others. Use draft picks to get young talent to the club. Trading for old hacks is not the way...
  10. J

    Welcome to Carlton: Brock Mclean

    Why would Carlton take Mclean at all, let alone pick 11. Waste, he is not worth it and the midfield is not the problem area. Would have thought a couple of KP backman was the priority and hoping that Warnock plays. Then you are really in the mix. Fev needs to stay.
  11. J

    Warnock

    What is the latest on Warnock? Will he play in 2010
  12. J

    Melbourne no longer to get pick #11 for McLean

    Why would Carlton want McLean? Another midfielder when they have enough. Need key backs first and then a forward. A ruckman too.
  13. J

    Fine for criticism of umpires

    I agree with you Hangzhou Dogs. Pick the obvious free kicks and let the game flow. Hense my frustration - we have no idea from game to game as the AFL umpires association has made it so complicated to umpire a game, who the hell would want too. This then adds to the frustration and people...
  14. J

    Fine for criticism of umpires

    AH you must be an umpire official or such of some type that derives an income and glory from being one of these. Can I assume you would be part of setting the direction of umpiring within the game as you believe that the general public and media are happy with what we have now. They have...
  15. J

    Fine for criticism of umpires

    Umpires are now coached to believe they are elite sportsmen entitled to their share of the limelight, bigger than the game, the kudos and even their own tribute sports cards. They have ruined the game with their inconsistency and free kicks at every contest. We should criticise them so...
See more

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top