Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[Chrissybabes]

I had Hurn last year, he was good but @ $520k he's almost max price, can easily get him later on.

Lloyd will be harder to upgrade to.

Lloyd will also cost you 2 trades and you risk Heeney burning you with that trade

 

[stevebbb]

What would you do?

Mills to Worpel (Moore to Def)

Then what?

Heeney to Lloyd (Moore back to Fwd)?
Or
Rookie to rookie?
Or
Nothing?

 

[Blackhawk42]

So after more deliberation, i'm currently sitting with Dusty to Rocky and Walters to Boak. I'm essentially looking at these as being sideways corrective trades but they have also created $171k in the bank. Certainly didn't want to take such drastic action after a really good round 1, but being ranked 61k after a horror round 2 has forced the hand a bit.
The worry is too many Port players, but 3 of the rookies will be used soon enough that i'm not too stressed in the short term.

 

[Requiem]

Lloyd will also cost you 2 trades and you risk Heeney burning you with that trade

Yeah kinda thinking along the same lines, might just go option B.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

View attachment 646304View attachment 646303

What would you do?

Mills to Worpel (Moore to Def)

Then what?

Heeney to Lloyd (Moore back to Fwd)?
Or
Rookie to rookie?
Or
Nothing?

Mills to Lloyd and Heeney to Worpel looks great to me

 

[ClintonKing]

View attachment 646304View attachment 646303

What would you do?

Mills to Worpel (Moore to Def)

Then what?

Heeney to Lloyd (Moore back to Fwd)?
Or
Rookie to rookie?
Or
Nothing?

Mills out for a back rookie (Collins).
Valente to Butters.

gotta structure the team correctly around the rookies. Field Duursma

 

[pincrusher]

Just listened to the Horse presser. Sounds like Grundy unlikely to be back this weekend= Mills playing tall defender again. TRADE

 

[CrowEater888]

Balta, Wagner out. Replaced by similarly priced on the bubble rookies.

I'll back my Premos in, for now.

 

[Requiem]

Just listened to the Horse presser. Sounds like Grundy unlikely to be back this weekend= Mills playing tall defender again. TRADE

Horse is driving that team into the SC graveyard...except Lloyd.

 

[Goats]

View attachment 646299

Not sexy enough?

Here2tellyouwhy

 

[Goats]

View attachment 646304View attachment 646303

What would you do?

Mills to Worpel (Moore to Def)

Then what?

Heeney to Lloyd (Moore back to Fwd)?
Or
Rookie to rookie?
Or
Nothing?

Are you using Velente as a loophole doughnut? If not Velente to Butters.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Horse is driving that team into the SC graveyard...except Lloyd.

Speaking of Horse, would love to see Newman pump out a 130+ this week to stick it up his former coach who didn't appreciate what he had.

 

[John450]

What should I do?

Heeney to:
Boak
Worpel
Dahlhaus

 

[Requiem]

Speaking of Horse, would love to see Newman pump out a 130+ this week to stick it up his former coach who didn't appreciate what he had.

Did the same thing with Tom Mitchell.

 

[PowerForGood]

Lloyd will also cost you 2 trades and you risk Heeney burning you with that trade

Could upgrade Heeney to Lloyd through DP if you have Burgess and/or Moore and cash.

Then you could get Heeney later when he drops in price and If you think he'll come good.

 

[Jars458]

I don't have Duursma, really only rookie I want but can't do it without two trades so will have to miss out. Unless I trade Collins.

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

So many issues to be dealt with including Dusty, Goldy and Weeney. Basically i'm looking to try and do the following over the next few weeks...

Dusty > Rockpig
Atkins > LDU (I like what i am seeing!)
Goldy > Gawn
Heeney > Kiera
Zac W > Seagull

Thoughts?

The two I would look to do this week are
Dusty > Rocky
Heeney > Kiera

These 2 should be your first priorities... as both Heeney & Dusty look off the pace and Rocky & Moore both will grow substantially in cash...

Goldy and Gawn both gonna drop coin this week, just as Atkins & LDU will both go up so they sort of offset each others differentials for the week...

Williams is going well and Lloyd although at his chip scabbing best, only has so far he can actually increase in cash.

This is the most logical path to take

 

[ClintonKing]

I don't have Duursma, really only rookie I want but can't do it without two trades so will have to miss out. Unless I trade Collins.

post team

 

[Marlowe]

Is Worpedo a must? I need help cause I am bad at this game.

I had Danger/Heeney/TKelly/Robbie Gray/Dunkley pencilled as F1 to F5.

No, he's not a must have.

And that's too many forwards.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Heeney and Dunkley for Boak and Kelly looking likely for me should Balta return to Richmond's side

Trading Heeney could be a waste, but meh, Billings burnt me last year, don't want another scenario like that to happen, happy to trade him back in later on if he looks like coming good. Made the right move dumping Hibberd to Simmo at this time last year, hopefully these moves gain an extra 50 points a week or so.


Darling my pod F4 still, he's warming up, one of these days he'll smash 140 out

What's your reasoning for ditching Dunkley mate being a Doggies supporter and all?

You would know best about Dunkley...

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

I have two players I want to trade, only one can be traded. I used my first trade on Parker for Balta.

Now my headache starts. Who do I keep out of Heeney or Martin?

Martin is a proven beast, but on the decline.

Heeney has so much upside, but playing like a busted arse.


I will trade Heeney to Kelly

Dusty will need to pick between Brayshaw, Bontempelli, Pendlebury and Rory Sloane.

Thanks guys!

Why not hold Balta & go
Heeney > Parker
Dusty > MID/FWD of choice

Then next week if Balta is still out next week trade him for any one of the others.

 

[Judd_Magic]

No, he's not a must have.

And that's too many forwards.

Think he means that's what he wants to end up with not what he currently has.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Tossing up with going Collins\Rozee for Hore if he doesn't get selected and Balta > Miers if he doesn't get selected either.

If they both get picked then looking at 2 premo correction trades -

Heeney > Lloyd\Whitfield

Dunkley > T.Kelly

I have $109,600 in the kitty.

If I go with option 2 is it worth spending the extra on Lloyd over Whitfield hence wiping out most of my kitty.

Thoughts kents?

 

[Gavin Excell]

I don't have Duursma, really only rookie I want but can't do it without two trades so will have to miss out. Unless I trade Collins.

Same scenario

Thinking its not worth the trade. Sticking with Collins

 

[SterlingArcher]

I can get in Constable for Atkins, and afford Collins to Scrimshaw or Moore. [emoji848]


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yes to the first. Atkins not bad but Constable a must have top 5 rookie. If Scott gets dropped for Ahern though then go woth him out.

Don't think the gap for Collins is big enough as he started to show signs of intercepting v Freo to warrant a trade. But I`d choose Moore if so.

I reckon just get Constable in and hold, your team looks very well placed and I don't think any of the proposed 2nd trades hold any significant value long term.