Collingwood and Richmond - who has the greater supporter base

[Craze]

Your not even close and our game against GWS in 2017 proved they are real people 90k+ nearly all in Yellow and Black.

Collingwood have never achieved something like that, in fact most of your record crowds are at away games, ours are at home games, people do like watching Collingwood lose.

Pies managed 51,000 against Port in 2013, which was a pretty good effort for them.

They're not on Richmond's scale TBH.

 

[Craze]

Yet at the same game only 6 weeks earlier only 35k turned up.

Irrelevant.

 

[gopies1981]

Roy Morgan is the core of the argument used by Collingwood supporters in this thread to claim they are bigger than us.

Plus social media we own Richmond

 

[chefmeister]

Irrelevant.

Please explain.

 

[Tiger2709]

How come Tuggers are so offended by being smaller than Collingwood?

Richmond 96k current members to Collingwood 76k do they stop education in Geelong at pre primary, or are you to busy selling meth to attend?

 

[Craze]

With both clubs at similar levels on the ladder Tiges are easily bigger. Easily.

 

[Tiger2709]

Plus social media we own Richmond

I can start as many social media accounts as I like, membership and attendance is the true judge of real supporters, even Collingwoods many many zero game members, i have heard from reliable sources its 60k zero gamer members at the Magpies, are more real than the social media numbers that can be bought for a few dollars, Roys survey is just an embarrassing joke.

 

[gopies1981]

Pies managed 51,000 against Port in 2013, which was a pretty good effort for them.

They're not on Richmond's scale TBH.

Yet has Richmond ever drawn over 1.2 million people during the home and away season? No

Collingwood have done this 5 times including in our premiership year 1,306,604.

Has Richmond ever drawn over 60,000 v interstate clubs in Melbourne during the home and away season ? No

Collingwood have drawn over 60,000 v interstate clubs during the home and away season? Yes

V Brisbane 61,000 2003
V Sydney 63,000 2007
V west Coast 63,000 2012
V Sydney 65,000 2013

Collingwood have drawn over 80,000 58 times during the home and away season compared to Richmond 24 times.

Collingwood are 9.2 million Ahead of Richmond during the home and away season. Richmond are not in our league one the field and certainly not off field.

Now walk along minnow

 

[gopies1981]

With both clubs at similar levels on the ladder Tiges are easily bigger. Easily.

Like in 2010 and 2011???

 

[Craze]

Yet has Richmond ever drawn over 1.2 million people during the home and away season? No

Collingwood have done this 5 times including in our premiership year 1,306,604.

Has Richmond ever drawn over 60,000 v interstate clubs in Melbourne during the home and away season ? No

Collingwood have drawn over 60,000 v interstate clubs during the home and away season? Yes

V Brisbane 61,000 2003
V Sydney 63,000 2007
V west Coast 63,000 2012
V Sydney 65,000 2013

Collingwood have drawn over 80,000 58 times during the home and away season compared to Richmond 24 times.

Collingwood are 9.2 million Ahead of Richmond during the home and away season. Richmond are not in our league one the field and certainly not off field.

Now walk along minnow

Nup, Richmond easily.

 

[gopies1981]

I can start as many social media accounts as I like, membership and attendance is the true judge of real supporters, even Collingwoods many many zero game members, i have heard from reliable sources its 60k zero gamer members at the Magpies, are more real than the social media numbers that can be bought for a few dollars, Roys survey is just an embarrassing joke.

Wait till Saturday night when 60,000 Collingwood fans are at the g!!

Now run along minnow Richmond are not in Collingwood’s leave

 

[Craze]

Like in 2010 and 2011???

In those years Pies won the flag and finished 1st H&A. Richmond finished 15th and 13th. Can't really compare.

 

[gopies1981]

Nup, Richmond easily.

You have no stats to prove it

 

[Craze]

You have no stats to prove it

Like 100,000 members compared to 80,000?

 

[Tiger2709]

Yet at the same game only 6 weeks earlier only 35k turned up.

One was a final
GWS average away attendance in 2017 was 26k that 35k is their 11 biggest away crowd ever.
Biggest crowd ever for GWS is versus Richmond 94258 nearly all Tiger supporters turned up, against Collingwood its only an avareage 72504, that is about the same difference as collingwood and Richmonds current memberships numbers

 

[Tiger2709]

You have no stats to prove it

I keep goving you stats you respond with Roy Morgan, joke is firmly on you.

 

[gopies1981]

In those years Pies won the flag and finished 1st H&A. Richmond finished 15th and 13th. Can't really compare.

Richmond have never drawn over 1.2 million people. Collingwood have done this 5 times. Collingwood will Be first in attendance’s this year! Cannot wait till richmonds membership drops next year. No fans jump of a sinking ship like Richmond fans. When will you start selling home games interstate again??

 

[chefmeister]

One was a final

Sounds convincing.

 

[gopies1981]

I keep goving you stats you respond with Roy Morgan, joke is firmly on you.

Oh and Collingwood holding the top 5 biggest home and away attendance’s of all time.

Or Collingwood holding 16 of the top 20 biggest crowds of all time

Or Collingwood being the biggest club on social media

Or Collingwood being 9.2 million in front of Richmond and 7 million in front of Carlton and Essendon

Mate the joke is firmly on you. Everyone except for a few Richmond supporters knows that Collingwood are the biggest club in Australia

 

[Craze]

Like I said, when you can draw 95,000 v.'s GWS then they'll speak about Collingwood being on Richmond's level. Until then, you're a big club yes, but not Richmond big

 

[Tiger2709]

Sounds convincing.

35k for GWS away is a big crowd.
You really should give your Tiger obsession a rest, your joining forces with pre pubescent Collingwood supporters to try and prove a point.

Enjoy Geelongs time at the top of the ladder while it lasts.

 

[Craze]

One was a final

And from memory it was pissing rain all day.

 

[gopies1981]

Like I said, when you can draw 95,000 v.'s GWS then they'll speak about Collingwood being on Richmond's level. Until then, you're a big club yes, but not Richmond big

Oh good to have those 60,000 sympathy supporters tho. Where were they on Thursday night?

 

[gopies1981]

35k for GWS away is a big crowd.
You really should give your Tiger obsession a rest, your joining forces with pre pubescent Collingwood supporters to try and prove a point.

Enjoy Geelongs time at the top of the ladder while it lasts.

We are bigger and better then Richmond on field and off field. Enjoy your 40 years outside the finals

 

[Tiger2709]

Richmond have never drawn over 1.2 million people. Collingwood have done this 5 times. Collingwood will Be first in attendance’s this year! Cannot wait till richmonds membership drops next year. No fans jump of a sinking ship like Richmond fans. When will you start selling home games interstate again??

We were the first club to draw a million in a season and first to have 100000 members Collingwood always following in our tracks.