Review Good, Acceptable, and Putrid vs Kitty Kats

[Bicks]

So pretty much everyone bar Murphy?

Lol - righto

So you class him as a senior player after 14 games? Righto

 

[Tex200]

So you class him as a senior player after 14 games? Righto

Well he was as ordinary as anyone last Thursday.

Shouldn’t get a pass imo.

They’ve all got to do more

 

[Bicks]

Well he was as ordinary as anyone last Thursday.

Shouldn’t get a pass imo.

They’ve all got to do more

Fine but I did stipulate senior players and I don't consider Murphy as that after only 14 games in the 2 year's he's been on our list

 

[Tex200]

Fine but I did stipulate senior players and I don't consider Murphy as that after only 14 games in the 2 year's he's been on our list

Fair enough - I don’t think anyone gets a pass, senior or not.

Jones and Murphy are both part of a misfiring forward line. They both need to be contributing more.

Rozee’s played 3 games and kicking 5.

 

[Billy Bob65]

Commiserations on the loss.

Here are the midfield frequency stats from the match. In case you missed one of these posts from the 2nd half of last season, this is an overall summary of how often players started as one of the 5 mids at centre bounces.

Overall Summary - 27 Bounces

Sloane 22
M.Crouch 22
B.Crouch 21
Atkins 19 (18w, 1i)
Mackay 19 wing
Seedsman 13 wing
Gibbs 9 (1w)
Milera 7
Knight 3 wing

Rucks:

O'Brien 24
Jenkins 3

1st Half - 14

Sloane 13
Atkins 11 (10w, 1i)
M.Crouch 10
B.Crouch 10
Mackay 10 wing
Seedsman 8 wing
Gibbs 8

O'Brien 12
Jenkins 2

2nd Half - 13

M.Crouch 12
B.Crouch 11
Sloane 9
Mackay 9 wing
Atkins 8 wing
Milera 7
Seedsman 5 wing
Knight 3 wing
Gibbs 1 wing

O'Brien 12
Jenkins 1

Notes:

- Gibbs and Milera swapped roles for the 2nd half; only the 2nd game (from those analysed) where Milera has recorded an inside starts - the other being Rd 16, 2017. This was also the most inside starts recorded for him.
- Seedsman was axed from the rotation for the entire 3rd term - forward or bench for every bounce; Knight received all the relief wing stints for that term.
- Pyke was seemingly happy with Mackay's work as when Seedsman returned to the rotation for the 4th, Atkins was the one demoted to forward/relief wing.

 

[Elite Crow]

Commiserations on the loss.

Here are the midfield frequency stats from the match. In case you missed one of these posts from the 2nd half of last season, this is an overall summary of how often players started as one of the 5 mids at centre bounces.

Overall Summary - 27 Bounces

Sloane 22
M.Crouch 22
B.Crouch 21
Atkins 19 (18w, 1i)
Mackay 19 wing
Seedsman 13 wing
Gibbs 9 (1w)
Milera 7
Knight 3 wing

Rucks:

O'Brien 24
Jenkins 3

1st Half - 14

Sloane 13
Atkins 11 (10w, 1i)
M.Crouch 10
B.Crouch 10
Mackay 10 wing
Seedsman 8 wing
Gibbs 8

O'Brien 12
Jenkins 2

2nd Half - 13

M.Crouch 12
B.Crouch 11
Sloane 9
Mackay 9 wing
Atkins 8 wing
Milera 7
Seedsman 5 wing
Knight 3 wing
Gibbs 1 wing

O'Brien 12
Jenkins 1

Notes:

- Gibbs and Milera swapped roles for the 2nd half; only the 2nd game (from those analysed) where Milera has recorded an inside starts - the other being Rd 16, 2017. This was also the most inside starts recorded for him.
- Seedsman was axed from the rotation for the entire 3rd term - forward or bench for every bounce; Knight received all the relief wing stints for that term.
- Pyke was seemingly happy with Mackay's work as when Seedsman returned to the rotation for the 4th, Atkins was the one demoted to forward/relief wing.

Thanks.

This shows how dumb our coaches can be, instead of selecting a forward, we’ve used our spare wingers to play up forward. Whose bright idea was that? Here’s a tip, play one less winger and play a forward who can kick goals.