Round 5 Trades

[Hamez]

Dusty > Whitfield (via Burgess to fwds and Drew to mids)
Parker > Stack (via Drew to fwds)

Don’t mind that.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Not me. I purchased expecting a D5/D6 keeper.
His career has gone 59, 65, 69, 88, 94, before a year off with injury. If he was a mid I'd agree but as a def I was assuming a cheap set and forget hopefully 95 avge.
So far 82, 95, 101, 60. (One crap game in 4).
What did we expect him to do ? Tons every week the moment he got back ? Probably still regaining a bit of confidence.
He's way way down on my worry list. Was avging 90+ till this week. I'll back him in to get better and finish with a 95-100 avge. He's in a mob that wins which doesn't hurt either. Just a thought.

i was expecting him to do exactly what he is doing. its good for the price but it doesnt make him a keeper...even in defence.
im not ready to trade him out either but that doesnt mean its the wrong thing to do if a good opportunity presents itself.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Looks great mate.

Dunkley needs to go though imo.

Dunkley will go next week to Kelly most likely as I wanted to get a rookie off the field this week. Cheers mate

 

[hsaklag]

I swear all you bandwagon campaigners are going to curse Marshall

**** off, if you didn't believe in him last week you don't deserve him

 

[Bollox]

i was expecting him to do exactly what he is doing. its good for the price but it doesnt make him a keeper...even in defence.
im not ready to trade him out either but that doesnt mean its the wrong thing to do if a good opportunity presents itself.

Fair enuff.
Would u be saying that though if he got just 5 more quality disposals and a tkle and scored 95 this week ?
Its early.
Who apart from maybe Lloyd/Whitfield/Laird do you expect to be running at a 105-110 avge this year making it worth swapping out Williams ? Guys like Hurn Stewart Sissyly and Ryan ? Sure its possible, but also just as likely Williams might. I'd be happy If any of those guys went 95-100.
Just don't see the point killing a likely keeper in Rnd 4 after a 60pt away game. Surely there's more trashy types with less potential you can deal with.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Should I do these 2 trades? Is it worth it?

Goldy & Parker -> Mummy & Marshall

Alternatively, just do Goldy to Mummy and pocket the $200k difference to put towards future upgrades...etc

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Should I do these 2 trades? Is it worth it?

Goldy & Parker -> Mummy & Marshall

Alternatively, just do Goldy to Mummy and pocket the $200k difference to put towards future upgrades...etc

Do neither of those options .....hold Goldstein ! at the moment

Yes Parker to Marshall ....but not at Goldy's expense

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[PoopingHindi]

Fair enuff.
Would u be saying that though if he got just 5 more quality disposals and a tkle and scored 95 this week ?
Its early.
Who apart from maybe Lloyd/Whitfield/Laird do you expect to be running at a 105-110 avge this year making it worth swapping out Williams ? Guys like Hurn Stewart Sissyly and Ryan ? Sure its possible, but also just as likely Williams might. I'd be happy If any of those guys went 95-100.
Just don't see the point killing a likely keeper in Rnd 4 after a 60pt away game. Surely there's more trashy types with less potential you can deal with.

what about if he had 5 less disposals and a tackle the week prior? you can bend and twist hypotheticals any way you like.
i dont know who the other premo defenders will be after only 4 rounds but im fairly certain high 80's wont cut it.
on the flip side Williams to Rocky is a 20 point scoring increase and you get a premo mid for $450k...you wont get too many opportunities like that.

like i said, he's in my side for the foreseeable future but i'm open to flipping him in the right circumstances.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Anyone gonna bit the bullet this week?

 

[Bollox]

what about if he had 5 less disposals and a tackle the week prior? you can bend and twist hypotheticals any way you like.
i dont know who the other premo defenders will be after only 4 rounds but im fairly certain high 80's wont cut it.
on the flip side Williams to Rocky is a 20 point scoring increase and you get a premo mid for $450k...you wont get too many opportunities like that.

like i said, he's in my side for the foreseeable future but i'm open to flipping him in the right circumstances.

furrymuff, i'm just being argumentative I guess.

 

[mochacinolatte]

Anyone gonna bit the bullet this week?

What bullet are we biting

 

[Blackhawk42]

Anyone gonna bit the bullet this week?

Yep. Walsh to Macrae.












Not really.

 

[Suma Magic]

Got $132,400 in the bank and an itchy trading figure. Thoughts on these options?


Option 1

Setterfield -> Stack
Balta -> Mummy (via Lycett)

Leaves me with:

Macrae, Cripps, M. Crouch, Sheed, Libba, Walsh, Constable, Butters, Stack, Atkins, Scott

Gawn, Mummy, Bines

Danger, Heeney, Kelly, Worpel, Lycett, Moore, Drew, Parker


Option 2

Setterfield -> Stack
Butters -> Rockliff

Leaves me with:

Macrae, Cripps, M. Crouch, Rockliff, Sheed, Libba, Walsh, Constable, Stack, Atkins, Scott

Gawn, Lycett, Bines

Danger, Heeney, Kelly, Worpel, Moore, Drew, Parker, Balta

 

[Gene Simmons]

Hey guys,

Currently only have $20k in the kitty...

Ideally want to trade Parker -> Marshall but will need to downgrade elsewhere to find the funds... Not sure what to do??

 

[Suma Magic]

Hey guys,

Currently only have $20k in the kitty...

Ideally want to trade Parker -> Marshall but will need to downgrade elsewhere to find the funds... Not sure what to do??

View attachment 655693

No obvious options. Best I can think of is Goldstein to Mummy. Which probably isn't a good move.

 

[Gene Simmons]

No obvious options. Best I can think of is Goldstein to Mummy. Which probably isn't a good move.

Yeah that's the only move I can see that will net me $200k instantly... As good as value as Mummy is, you just know that he's prone to a brain fade and the odd suspension will occur which would leave me with Z.Clarke as my R2

Another trade option purely for cash generation is Constable to Stack or J.Ross...? Or Clark to Rotham.... ?

 

[ubeaut]

Got $132,400 in the bank and an itchy trading figure. Thoughts on these options?


Option 1

Setterfield -> Stack
Balta -> Mummy (via Lycett)

Leaves me with:

Macrae, Cripps, M. Crouch, Sheed, Libba, Walsh, Constable, Butters, Stack, Atkins, Scott

Gawn, Mummy, Bines

Danger, Heeney, Kelly, Worpel, Lycett, Moore, Drew, Parker


Option 2

Setterfield -> Stack
Butters -> Rockliff

Leaves me with:

Macrae, Cripps, M. Crouch, Rockliff, Sheed, Libba, Walsh, Constable, Stack, Atkins, Scott

Gawn, Lycett, Bines

Danger, Heeney, Kelly, Worpel, Moore, Drew, Parker, Balta

Option 1. Gets rid of Balta and fwd rookies off the field. Mummy a great POD, and u have Lycett backup.
Too early to trade Butters imo.

 

[Red Syrah]

Have been lucky so far with H2H and neither of my opponents hav had Grundy - but think it will start to really stuff me up.

So, need to trade out $800k to bring in Grundy and Stack.

Players up for consideration:
Darling - keep waiting for the big scores nut just not happening
Lycett - OK and provides ruck cover and was aiming for a F6/7 avg 90
Williams - OK but prob not a keeper
Brouch - OK but prob not a keeper
Moore - OK and DPP and not worth as much

The only one I am happy to trade out is Darling, but just think Grundy is back up on the rise and it hurt if I dont have him.

So who to choose??

#the most annoying thing is I was 50/50 bn Gawn and Grundy - went the wrong way of course! If I started Grundy not Gawn, I'd be happy to hold....

Who is more important to bring in this week:
Grundy , marshall or stack?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Balta is going to rot on my bench the entire season, stupid dopey campaigner.

 

[stevebbb]

Balta is going to rot on my bench the entire season, stupid dopey campaigner.

Yep! Best case scenario we somehow flukes a couple of 50-70 scores and crawls to ~$170k and makes us $50k profit on a rookie downgrade

 

[Juzzomac]

Yeah that's the only move I can see that will net me $200k instantly... As good as value as Mummy is, you just know that he's prone to a brain fade and the odd suspension will occur which would leave me with Z.Clarke as my R2

Another trade option purely for cash generation is Constable to Stack or J.Ross...? Or Clark to Rotham.... ?

Constable still has a lot of mooing to do, more than capable of pulling out another 90/100 in the next couple of weeks. There's no rookie downgrade you can make to bring Marshall in. It would have to be a sideways swap or Mummy for Goldy.

 

[rocker_oz33]

With setterfeield out for 2 weeks.

I might go .

Scott to stack.
Setters to Mummy.

Licehead moves forward.

 

[Changa10]

Howdy All,

I just can't make up my mind what to do with this lot this week! They were travelling along so well until Saturday....

Do I sacrifice a Rozee or Dunkley for a Marshall or Boak etc?

At this stage I am thinking I will just dial 1800HORE, and get rid of either Faulta Balta or Setterspud. Thoughts?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Yep! Best case scenario we somehow flukes a couple of 50-70 scores and crawls to ~$170k and makes us $50k profit on a rookie downgrade

Should have corrected the worhtless shit truck to Miers before round 3



Already made 103K+ still has a negative break even, and only in 5% of teams