List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Top 10 Candidates

[SMILLIE]

Sharp would be a trade down target, as good as he’s been I don’t think any in the top 5 take him. We will see though
He’s the A+++ of a dime a dozen midfield archetype

 

[tigs2010]

Sharp would be a trade down target, as good as he’s been I don’t think any in the top 5 take him. We will see though
He’s the A+++ of a dime a dozen midfield archetype

Reckon WC take him. They need that type.

 

[eaglevision]

I’ll probably cry if he goes to WC

We do love an athlete we can teach to football…

But I doubt we take Robey. Duursma a lock and one of Sharp/Cumming I’d say assuming we get band 1. CDT is our attempt at inception in the media.

 

[eaglevision]

Reckon WC take him. They need that type.

We need him more than any other player but by no means do I think our recruiting team realise this.

 

[tigs2010]

We need him more than any other player but by no means do I think our recruiting team realise this.

Matt Clarke is limited to ****ing up the trades isn't he? Otherwise enjoy your half back

 

[eaglevision]

Matt Clarke is limited to ****ing up the trades isn't he? Otherwise enjoy your half back

Yep, Lindsay and Farrow inbound at 1 and 2.

 

[SMILLIE]

Reckon WC take him. They need that type.

Who do you want at the moment? On the Robey train?
I keep flip flopping

 

[tigs2010]

Who do you want at the moment? On the Robey train?
I keep flip flopping

Assuming WC take Duursma, Robey and Grlj.

Not wed to Grlj, pretty all in on Sulley now.

 

[SMILLIE]

Assuming WC take Duursma, Robey and Grlj.

Not wed to Grlj, pretty all in on Sulley now.

Ditto.

 

[sregit]

I think Cumming is overrated and Greeves is underrated by most on this board.

Cumming is a very average kick with an awkward kicking style. Also, he does not get enough of the ball and has injury issues. I would not take him top 5.

Greeves has been a consistent top performer over the past 2 years. He knows how to get the ball and is an inside / outside mid who also performs well as a forward. I don't think pace is an issue for him and has improved his defensive game. I would not be disappointed if we took Greeves with one of our picks.

I agree. Greeves also is a better mark than all the midfielders mentioned here and also has been labelled as slow but this is not right. He has no problem breaking from a contest.

 

[Rich01]

We do love an athlete we can teach to football…

But I doubt we take Robey. Duursma a lock and one of Sharp/Cumming I’d say assuming we get band 1. CDT is our attempt at inception in the media.

If I were West Coast I’d do exactly that.

In saying that if you ended up with CDT and Duursma I think that would be a great result for your side as well. He’d be very good in the open spaces of Optus.

We wil pick up who you don’t I think.

Two of CDT, Sharp, Cumming, with Robey the flier if he puts in another stunner this weekend.

I don’t think either club tries to get cute with a downgrade and just picks best available.

 

[eaglevision]

If I were West Coast I’d do exactly that.

In saying that if you ended up with CDT and Duursma I think that would be a great result for your side as well. He’d be very good in the open spaces of Optus.

We wil pick up who you don’t I think.

Two of CDT, Sharp, Cumming, with Robey the flier if he puts in another stunner this weekend.

I don’t think either club tries to get cute with a downgrade and just picks best available.

Robey is a very Richmond pick I think he’ll be in the yellow and black. Get at least one more look at him this weekend and he’ll blitz the combine.

I think it would take a very good deal for us to part with either pick. Essendon are imploding and might end up with a better draft hand than yours last year, in which case a I can see them offering 5,6 for 1/2 and 19.

Interesting year with the first three clubs having a pair of selections. Great for list management.

 

[wormy]

The tigers interest in X. Taylor tells me we think Young might be out the door.

Robey seems like the most fitting player for our needs and our draft strategy, but depends on if it's too much of a reach to take him so high.

CDT, Duursma and potentially Sharp might be too good to pass on if any are still on the board.

 

[Rich01]

Robey is a very Richmond pick I think he’ll be in the yellow and black. Get at least one more look at him this weekend and he’ll blitz the combine.

I think it would take a very good deal for us to part with either pick. Essendon are imploding and might end up with a better draft hand than yours last year, in which case a I can see them offering 5,6 for 1/2 and 19.

Interesting year with the first three clubs having a pair of selections. Great for list management.

If that was the deal I’d do it if I were the Eagles and they are in the box seat over the Tigers to trade down. But if I were them I wouldn’t want to drop any further.

1. Duursma - ESS

2. CDT - West Coast - sorry i know you aren’t keen but until there’s a view Duursma and CDT aren’t the two most talented prospects he stays here.

3. Sharp - Rich
4. Robey - Rich
5. Cumming - West Coast
6. ???? - West Coast

The last pick there’s some great options for you. Do you go the next best tiered mid? Or a runner in Grjl which would suit minis game to a t? Or a half back in Lindsey who would cut open a ground like Optus? X Taylor as an intercept defender has the talent too but is he a real need? Or a tall like Marsh to complement Shanahan? Lots of good options. At those two Bomber picks you get the first of the next batch.

 

[eaglevision]

CDT, Duursma and potentially Sharp might be too good to pass on if any are still on the board.
[/QUOTE]

Surely one of them has to be considering you’ll have pick 3 at worst…

 

[eaglevision]

If that was the deal I’d do it if I were the Eagles and they are in the box seat over the Tigers to trade down. But if I were them I wouldn’t want to drop any further.

1. Duursma - ESS

2. CDT - West Coast - sorry i know you aren’t keen but until there’s a view Duursma and CDT aren’t the two most talented prospects he stays here.

3. Sharp - Rich
4. Robey - Rich
5. Cumming - West Coast
6. ???? - West Coast

The last pick there’s some great options for you. Do you go the next best tiered mid? Or a runner in Grjl which would suit minis game to a t? Or a half back in Lindsey who would cut open a ground like Optus? X Taylor as an intercept defender has the talent too but is he a real need? Or a tall like Marsh to complement Shanahan? Lots of good options. At those two Bomber picks you get the first of the next batch.

If we did the deal I think it would look like:

ESS-Duursma
WCE-Sharp
RICH-CDT
RICH-Robey
WCE-Cumming
WCE-Lindsay/Schubert

Schubert we’d start as a KPD.

It may be that we’re set on Duursma and would only trade 2 to Bombers so they can take CDT in which case do Richmond take Robey and Sharp?

 

[tigerfan1961]

If we did the deal I think it would look like:

ESS-Duursma
WCE-Sharp
RICH-CDT
RICH-Robey
WCE-Cumming
WCE-Lindsay/Schubert

Schubert we’d start as a KPD.

It may be that we’re set on Duursma and would only trade 2 to Bombers so they can take CDT in which case do Richmond take Robey and Sharp?

I’d be shocked if we take CDT. We’ve never taken talls that early with Blair in charge.
Wouldn’t surprise me who we end up with, but two mids/running players seem most likely. Still a lot to play out

 

[eaglevision]

I’d be shocked if we take CDT. We’ve never taken talls that early with Blair in charge.
Wouldn’t surprise me who we end up with, but two mids/running players seem most likely. Still a lot to play out

CDTs height and vertical leap at the combine will probably answer that question. Weak draft so most teams likely to go best available, even if they are a tall.
Having said that, I’m not going to pretend to know Richmond’s list needs better than their own supporters.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

Though I rate him, I'd be surprised if we take Robey that high. picking the guy that put in a handful of great games recently doesn't fit our recent mo. we're more likely to pick some kid that we loved a year ago thats been injured for 12 months, the exact opposite.

 

[wormy]

If we did the deal I think it would look like:

ESS-Duursma
WCE-Sharp
RICH-CDT
RICH-Robey
WCE-Cumming
WCE-Lindsay/Schubert

Schubert we’d start as a KPD.

It may be that we’re set on Duursma and would only trade 2 to Bombers so they can take CDT in which case do Richmond take Robey and Sharp?

I think if richmond were able to walk away with something like this where we get a combination of one certified mid Robey / Sharp/ Cumming / Grlj and one of the athletic freaks in CDT or Duursma, they'd be over the moon.

West Coast opening the draft with the two gun SA mids would also be a big win for you guys too

 

[tigerfan1961]

Though I rate him, I'd be surprised if we take Robey that high. picking the guy that put in a handful of great games recently doesn't fit our recent mo. we're more likely to pick some kid that we loved a year ago thats been injured for 12 months, the exact opposite.

FJ watches the futures market for us and would have kept a watch on him and may not be surprised by the recent form surge. Who knows
I’m sure we will know his potential from watching him as a junior.

 

[Rich01]

If we did the deal I think it would look like:

ESS-Duursma
WCE-Sharp
RICH-CDT
RICH-Robey
WCE-Cumming
WCE-Lindsay/Schubert

Schubert we’d start as a KPD.

It may be that we’re set on Duursma and would only trade 2 to Bombers so they can take CDT in which case do Richmond take Robey and Sharp?

Yeah i wouldn’t be unhappy with that either although a lot depends on Robey performing. I still think clubs have Cumming ahead.

I do think Duursma, CDT and Sharp are the top three.

 

[guruisatiger]

Okay so we know he is at least 20cm tall.

Im 172

 

[guruisatiger]

I’ll probably cry if he goes to WC

I'll move to Perth

 

[guruisatiger]

Cumming’s kicking style is awkward but I wouldn’t say he’s an inaccurate kick. Looks awful though.

Shits me as well when players constantly kick it on there teammates chest .