Scandal Tom Silvagni convicted of rape

[danster168]

Mate what are you talking about? It's the proper technical descriptor for this situation. Trust me, I heard it on youtube.

i thought they banned 16 and unders from it?

Anyway, mods are here so i'm leaving this thread. I wonder when Tom Silvagni's long sociopathic criminal history will come out. lol

 

[Munich]

View attachment 2501947

Don't bring Dex into this.

My fav psychopath though he has the ability to feel and give love so he's a bit of a unicorn.

 

[MisterMarcus]

Dan is the type of guy who's watched 2 clickbait "Cops interview malignant narcissist" videos and then thinks he's a forensic psychologist.

 

[Sentinel]

This is some on here's first Scandals and Rumours board thread, you can really tell the uninformed noobs

 

[phantom13]

This is some on here's first Scandals and Rumours board thread, you can really tell the uninformed noobs

To be fair it’s a bit past a rumor at this point.

 

[Sentinel]

To be fair it’s a bit past a rumor at this point.

We obviously need a separate Scandals only board, which the Rumours can graduate to

 

[Tandy]

I wonder what Tom had for Xmas lunch

 

[Aussie in exile]

I wonder what Tom had for Xmas lunch

Sausages perhaps

 

[Borussia Teeth]

Don't bring Dex into this.

My fav psychopath though he has the ability to feel and give love so he's a bit of a unicorn.

 

[Proper Gander]

You said you wouldn't know either way and then say 'it's equally incorrect to assert that he isn't'. sorry, but that's a contradiction and absolute hogwash.

And why are you using the term sociopathy and not psychopathy? Or just using the term interchangeably because most people that don't know just go with whatever.

And yeah it does. It precludes him. There is probably a 0.5% chance that he is a sociopath. That's a fairly accurate likelihood based on absolutely everything. Almost every single indictable crime includes deception, lying, lack of remorse, high levels of narcissism, impulsivity. But this absolutely does not make these people have a personality disorder. People just like labelling them because they try to make sense of the behaviour but in most cases, such as this, they're completely wrong.

The only thing embarrassing is the overused term 'sociopath' for literally anyone that commits a crime and lies.

If you actually had the vaguest notion of abnormal psychology you would know that neither are medical terms at all, and that you have basically been talking shit for pages now. Jesus wept

 

[Proper Gander]

Oh is 0.5% too high for you? That's as certain as anyone can be. i'm qualified. And clearly you have no idea what you're talking about on this topic. And sure, find any other expert and they'll say that he certainly is not a sociopath.

You’re not qualified. You’re not an expert. Give it a rest Dan. Go sit in the sun for a bit.

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

If you actually had the vaguest notion of abnormal psychology you would know that neither are medical terms at all, and that you have basically been talking shit for pages now. Jesus wept

Clearly the rest of us don’t follow enough true crime YouTube channels

 

[Beerfish]

Giving me Mr Bookman vibes from Seinfeld.

 

[danster168]

If you actually had the vaguest notion of abnormal psychology you would know that neither are medical terms at all, and that you have basically been talking shit for pages now. Jesus wept

why are you telling me things that I already know? Odd. But it absolutely used to be before it got compiled into a broader definition. But yes, to suggest that a persons upbringing is irrelevant with regards to a diagnosis of a personality disorder is completely wrong. In every sense.

Every expert in the field will tell you that Tom Silvagni would not be a sociopath or suffer from ASPD. Just a guy making horrible decisions. Don't disagree just to be argumentative. Everything that I've said is 100% spot on.

 

[thumbs_up]

why are you telling me things that I already know? Odd. But it absolutely used to be before it got compiled into a broader definition. But yes, to suggest that a persons upbringing is irrelevant with regards to a diagnosis of a personality disorder is completely wrong. In every sense.

Every expert in the field will tell you that Tom Silvagni would not be a sociopath or suffer from ASPD. Just a guy making horrible decisions. Don't disagree just to be argumentative. Everything that I've said is 100% spot on.

Many feminists would agree with you here. They've long argued that the men who rape women are not your stereotypical monsters but regular, everyday men.

Which in many ways is a much more frightening prospect.

 

[phantom13]

why are you telling me things that I already know? Odd. But it absolutely used to be before it got compiled into a broader definition. But yes, to suggest that a persons upbringing is irrelevant with regards to a diagnosis of a personality disorder is completely wrong. In every sense.

Every expert in the field will tell you that Tom Silvagni would not be a sociopath or suffer from ASPD. Just a guy making horrible decisions. Don't disagree just to be argumentative. Everything that I've said is 100% spot on.

Haven’t seen anyone suggest it’s irrelevant only that it’s not definitive.

Also I reckon every expert would correctly assert they don’t have enough data to make a determination either way.

They may assert it’s unlikely he is but if they’re genuinely experts they’d know not to make a diagnosis. Which is really the point you, a supposed (or at least self proclaimed) expert, seem to be completely missing.

 

[Munich]

I’ll sign up for the
Haven’t seen anyone suggest it’s irrelevant only that it’s not definitive.

Also I reckon every expert would correctly assert they don’t have enough data to make a determination either way.

They may assert it’s unlikely he is but if they’re genuinely experts they’d know not to make a diagnosis. Which is really the point you, a supposed (or at least self proclaimed) expert, seem to be completely missing.

Exactly, they'd say like with any criminal they need to test him to make their diagnosis or refer to people who have.

 

[cblues4864]

has anyone actually met tom before or had interactions like a family member played footy with him or against?

interesting what people thought of him

 

[Blackhawk42]

I’m still not getting why someone being a fan of a football player maybes them less able to discuss this case. One is a sport we love and the other well he’s a criminal. Sure Bailey might not be a Rhodes Scholar (name a footy player that is) but does it matter? Wouldn’t be the first supporter to like Bailey the footy player.

Josh Ward got a 99 atar and wants to be a supreme court judge when he retires from footy.


Hadn't plugged a Hawthorn player for no reason for a while, so thought it was time.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Josh Ward got a 99 atar and wants to be a supreme court judge when he retires from footy.


Hadn't plugged a Hawthorn player for no reason for a while, so thought it was time.

Happy to hear he has a backup plan never know what happens in footy. Met him once seemed very nice as a person

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

I’m still not getting why someone being a fan of a football player maybes them less able to discuss this case.

It doesn't.

I don't think I've read anyone on here say that it does?

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Josh Ward got a 99 atar and wants to be a supreme court judge when he retires from footy.


Hadn't plugged a Hawthorn player for no reason for a while, so thought it was time.

Just has to work as a paralegal for a month or two and he'll be put on the bench. Lots of AFL big wigs around

 

[Munich]

Josh Ward got a 99 atar and wants to be a supreme court judge when he retires from footy.


Hadn't plugged a Hawthorn player for no reason for a while, so thought it was time.

Doesn't it take decades of experience prior to selection. Might take him a while.

Not knocking him just interested in how he plans to do that while playing footy.

 

[Munich]

I wonder what Tom had for Xmas lunch

There was an article about it a few days before xmas, the "menu" that all corrections vic will be getting.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

How does digital rape put him at the bottom tier of rape crimes, whilst in Australia they do not differentiate between digital rape and any other form of rape?

I didn't say it did.
Its the rest of the stuff that did.
Dumb dumb.

The charges were category 3.

Go argue with the prosecutor if you disagree.