Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Next Generation

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Problem for Aust cricket, there aren't many batsmen with FC averages in the 40's any more.....too many sorts in the 30's zone.....which traditionally hasn't been a good indicator for a killer test career.....
 
Freezin said:
Problem for Aust cricket, there aren't many batsmen with FC averages in the 40's any more.....too many sorts in the 30's zone.....which traditionally hasn't been a good indicator for a killer test career.....
Click to expand...
Marn averaged in the 30s. From memory he was selected because he scored close to his average more often than not. Maybe we need to find someone like that, get them into the national set up and pump resources into them
 
Snake Charmer said:
Marn averaged in the 30s. From memory he was selected because he scored close to his average more often than not. Maybe we need to find someone like that, get them into the national set up and pump resources into them
Click to expand...
Aren't we about to drop Marnus? It feels like he's been mediocre for longer than he ever was good.
 
Cat Pummins said:
Anyone else think Tim Ward is worth a look? I know he's been middling about in Shield cricket for awhile now, but he looks very compact with good a temperament.
Click to expand...

I've been a fan for a little while. If he was converting his 50's into 100's more often he'd likely already be in the conversation.

If we can have a strong back end of the Shield season and remain the leading run scorer you'd think we'd start hearing his name a little more often.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Freezin said:
Problem for Aust cricket, there aren't many batsmen with FC averages in the 40's any more.....too many sorts in the 30's zone.....which traditionally hasn't been a good indicator for a killer test career.....
Click to expand...
Because shield decks are woeful and have been for the best part of 12 or 13 years. This isn't the 90's and early 2000's when shield decks were highways anymore.
 
Snake Charmer said:
Marn averaged in the 30s. From memory he was selected because he scored close to his average more often than not. Maybe we need to find someone like that, get them into the national set up and pump resources into them
Click to expand...
But he has still made 11 test 100's despite his poor FC record

Travis Head averaged just under 34 when he was first selected...
 
toml said:
Because shield decks are woeful and have been for the best part of 12 or 13 years. This isn't the 90's and early 2000's when shield decks were highways anymore.
Click to expand...
No 1st innings points on offer anymore

Teams have to take 20 wickets to get anything from the matches at all which has encouraged states to juice up their pitches.

Has made for more entertaining matches and more results but whether it is producing better cricketers...?
 
Drugs Are Bad Mackay? said:
No 1st innings points on offer anymore

Teams have to take 20 wickets to get anything from the matches at all which has encouraged states to juice up their pitches.

Has made for more entertaining matches and more results but whether it is producing better cricketers...?
Click to expand...
A. It’s not
 
western royboy said:
A. It’s not
Click to expand...
Agreed.

It feeds into itself too.

If the batters feel like there'll be a ball that "has their name on it" at some stage, they figure they may as well play their shots. At least I'll get some runs on the board by the time my number comes up.

Given that Shield crowds average 50-100 people per day and there's no television coverage, I'm not sure where the push to jazz it up came from?

Especially given that they have the BBL up and going.
 
Drugs Are Bad Mackay? said:
Agreed.

It feeds into itself too.

If the batters feel like there'll be a ball that "has their name on it" at some stage, they figure they may as well play their shots. At least I'll get some runs on the board by the time my number comes up.

Given that Shield crowds average 50-100 people per day and there's no television coverage, I'm not sure where the push to jazz it up came from?

Especially given that they have the BBL up and going.
Click to expand...
It wasn’t broken…why fix it?
 
Another post... aesthetics has become a consideration for state bodies.

When there is an international match there is rarely a couple of old, scrappy, scuffed up used pitches alongside the centre wicket. The pitch squares look pristine. No bare, brown, worn eyesores. They want the surrounds looking green for the cameras.

This has meant fewer Shield games on the test venues. We even used to have State 2nd XI matches on Adelaide Oval. Now Karen Rolton Oval hosts the majority of our domestic matches. Traffic on test venues has been reduced.

To get pitches back quicker, they tend to leave more grass on. Those pitches can withstand more wear and tear without crumbling. It's not long that they spring back to life - a growth mat on top, watered for greenhouse conditions, some sun. Eye-pleasing greenery in no time.

The lack of harsh, abrasive used surfaces alongside means that cricket balls don't age as quickly. Seam movement lasts longer. Less need for spinners.
 
toml said:
But he has still made 11 test 100's despite his poor FC record

Travis Head averaged just under 34 when he was first selected...
Click to expand...
Lab has scored heavily in shield and county cricket since then.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Freezin said:
Problem for Aust cricket, there aren't many batsmen with FC averages in the 40's any more.....too many sorts in the 30's zone.....which traditionally hasn't been a good indicator for a killer test career.....
Click to expand...
Yes, we've come a long way since the days where Greg Chappell had to play 4 seasons of Sheffield Shield, average in the 50s, and make about 10 centuries before playing for Australia. In more recent times players such as Lehmann and Hayden making 1000 runs a year, for several years before being selected. Then again, we didn't have young careers being destroyed by T20 back then.
 
Adelaide Hawk said:
Yes, we've come a long way since the days where Greg Chappell had to play 4 seasons of Sheffield Shield, average in the 50s, and make about 10 centuries before playing for Australia. In more recent times players such as Lehmann and Hayden making 1000 runs a year, for several years before being selected. Then again, we didn't have young careers being destroyed by T20 back then.
Click to expand...
If you asked the old timers, we had careers being killed by pyjama cricket back then.

The issue is that first class and test level cricket offers very few incentives to methodically building an innings.

Issues with pitches and balls with much more significant seam is at least as big an issue as players learning to play aggressive T20 shot making.
 
western royboy said:
Oliver PEAKE.
Click to expand...
As I was watching I had a thought that "the Poms young prodigy" Bethell would win the game from here. Some players just have it. Big moment comes and they step up. Find a way to do what their team needs, whatever the format, whatever the situation. Immune to pressure.

Boom
 
western royboy said:
Oliver PEAKE.
Click to expand...
All aboard the Peake train.. He will get fast tracked into the team over the next 18 months. It will be nice for the Vics to have a homegrown hero too. I feel like our test team regeneration will be fun to watch with some good talent floating around.
 
Bucking Beads said:
All aboard the Peake train.. He will get fast tracked into the team over the next 18 months. It will be nice for the Vics to have a homegrown hero too. I feel like our test team regeneration will be fun to watch with some good talent floating around.
Click to expand...

I just looked at his stats and he's barely played first class and hasn't done anything yet
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Jack Mundy said:
I just looked at his stats and he's barely played first class and hasn't done anything yet
Click to expand...
Stats don't tell the full story. Won the game in Adelaide off his own bat in the first or second match of the year.
 
With Bethell doing well, do we perhaps go away from waiting for players to dominate Shield cricket with bumper seasons?

Pick a player or players who we just think have a test standard game that will translate?

Typically if Shield results are the defining criteria you end up with 30+ years olds debuting
 
Jack Mundy said:
10 fc matches averages 26 with bat. 22 this season
Click to expand...

I don't think anyone thinks he should be playing for the Aussie test team anytime soon. He lifts for the moment which is a great sign for a kid, Aussie A team he did well, big Bash, world cup the kid is a winner. Smith wants to retire at the USA world cup this kid will be ready to replace him at the end of 2027 fingers crossed
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom