2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y (Part 2)

[thedaz47]

Anyone? Dead set struggling with this decision ...

Probably Boyd by the slightest of margins due to his proven record.

 

[frozensage]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Ryder should feature in you considerations. Cant ignore his form this year.

I think his price is getting too expensive now for him to be worthwhile, maybe a couple of weeks ago but now there's more chance of him putting in a bad game and losing value than gaining. With goldstein out and North's easy draw you definitely should consider Hmac before he goes into the high 400s.

 

[timbo3195]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

L.Dahlhaus v J.Lewis v K.Tippett

What you guys think?

 

[toxic]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

L.Dahlhaus v J.Lewis v K.Tippett

What you guys think?

Lewis or Stevie J (seems to be the forgotten forward who surely will turn it around very shortly - could be a great POD later on when the cats actually start trying)

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

duffman v m johnson.
Zarharakis v s johnson v chappy v jbrown.

 

[Daniels]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

duffman v m johnson.
Zarharakis v s johnson v chappy v jbrown.

M. Johnson

Stevie J


Johnson looks like will avg more for year. Stevie J will probably be the big improver out of those 4 down the track

 

[McBurg]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Couch or Kerridge? > Treloar or McDonald?

2 Blokes who are chance to not get game > 2 similar cash cows but cloudy future game gaurentees.

1st Question is: Who is more likely to get a game?

2nd Question is: Who is more likely to score well in the immediate future?

Cheers

 

[RWnBluey]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Ha, my question too. I'm thinking Nic Nat if I feel I have to trade.



Useful answer there. Like who?

I just dont think either can dominate on a consistent basis while both are in the team. If i had to choose one I would prob for Nic Nat as he is clearly spending more time in the ruck than cox this year

 

[RWnBluey]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Lewis or Stevie J (seems to be the forgotten forward who surely will turn it around very shortly - could be a great POD later on when the cats actually start trying)

At his (soon to be) price theres no way Stevie J will be a POD if he turns it around everyone man and his dog will pick him up

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Couch or Kerridge? > Treloar or McDonald?

2 Blokes who are chance to not get game > 2 similar cash cows but cloudy future game gaurentees.

1st Question is: Who is more likely to get a game?

2nd Question is: Who is more likely to score well in the immediate future?

Cheers

I dont much about the first 2 even though they were in my team before round one.Oldman jmac has scored quiet constant while at times doing tagging roles.I dont know much about Treloar he seems to be the flavor of the week but is a mpp.

 

[silent butcher]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Rockcliff or Kennedy(SYD)??

 

[McBurg]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

I dont much about the first 2 even though they were in my team before round one.Oldman jmac has scored quiet constant while at times doing tagging roles.I dont know much about Treloar he seems to be the flavor of the week but is a mpp.

Anyone know why Treloar missed the first few games? Injury? Fitness? Form?

Im nervous McDonald will play limited games but im planning on sacking them in 4-5 weeks anyway.

Leaning towards Couch>McDonald at this stage still but im still showing time for Treloar if he will hold....

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Is couch even playing? you mean the demon couch.Where jmac and Treloar will go up in price this week and both should play in the next 4 weeks Treloar scored 73 in both games and jmac scored 100 and 78 thats money in the piggy bank.Not sure why Treloar missed the first few games go to the GWS board every board has a sc/dt thread ask there I dont know anymore others might help.

 

[RWnBluey]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Is couch even playing? you mean the demon couch.Where jmac and Treloar will go up in price this week and both should play in the next 4 weeks Treloar scored 73 in both games and jmac scored 100 and 78 thats money in the piggy bank.Not sure why Treloar missed the first few games go to the GWS board every board has a sc/dt thread ask there I dont know anymore others might help.

Nope and only god knows why. baffling. Why would you elevate someone and then not even play them ESPECIALLY considering that you are getting flogged every week.

 

[McBurg]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Is couch even playing? you mean the demon couch.Where jmac and Treloar will go up in price this week and both should play in the next 4 weeks Treloar scored 73 in both games and jmac scored 100 and 78 thats money in the piggy bank.Not sure why Treloar missed the first few games go to the GWS board every board has a sc/dt thread ask there I dont know anymore others might help.

Couch isn't getting a game. And i agree with above. A few BOGs in magoos and he still isn't getting a game. Crazy

I know both Jmac and Treloar will go up but i can't get both.

The question is do i drop Couch or Kerridge, for either JMac or Treloar.

1 has to go and 1 has to come in. Not both. (this week anyway)

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Ok I see forest from the trees now.Kerridge has played one game as a sub I think and is on the clubs main list and couch has played none and is on rookie list.I thought couch would have played by now.But both have dodgey job security I prob would keep kerridge hard call take my thoughts with a gain of salt if you like good luck.

 

[Gotta LOVETT]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Trade Fyfe for Barlow make some cash and have a midfield of -

Ablett, Murphy, Rockliff, Swan, Barlow and Magner/Shiel

or

Trade Fyfe for Pendlebury have him instead of Barlow

or

Keep Fyfe and find another way to get Pendles in there

 

[Jbomb967]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

I'd definitely be leaning towards fyfe > Pendles...

 

[Bristol]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Adam Treloar vs. James McDonald

 

[dlanod]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Anyone know why Treloar missed the first few games? Injury? Fitness? Form?

Im nervous McDonald will play limited games but im planning on sacking them in 4-5 weeks anyway.

Leaning towards Couch>McDonald at this stage still but im still showing time for Treloar if he will hold....

Treloar was out because of a pre-season injury. On par with Shiel in terms of rated youngsters at GWS.

 

[Pedsy]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

I've got to play 2 out of 4 of my GWS boys.
Smith, Shiel, Coniglio and Treloar.
Which 2? Feel like I could just pick names out of a hat tbh.

 

[toxic]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

I've got to play 2 out of 4 of my GWS boys.
Smith, Shiel, Coniglio and Treloar.
Which 2? Feel like I could just pick names out of a hat tbh.

do the hat, do the hat! or shiel and treloar, but do the hat!

 

[Zim^zuM]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

M.Murhpy or Pendlebury?

 

[V23]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

M.Murhpy or Pendlebury?

Both eventually, Pendlebury now as he's cheaper and a better scorer.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Re: 2012 Player/s X v Player/s Y

Both eventually, Pendlebury now as he's cheaper and a better scorer.

That's the plan. Just figuring out who first.

I could probably get both if I sacrifice Magner a few weeks early and complete my midfield. But it will leave other areas Vulnerable.

Was more thinking to bring Pendlebury in and sure up the DEF by bringing in Scotland for Ellis or in the FWDS sidebottom for kennedy. Pendlebury is replacing D.Smith