2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[toxic]

Bennell.

Huge ceiling, as seen by his 6 goal performance against Geelong.

Can see him getting 30+ & kicking 3-4 goals in a game.

Interested in average only.

He'll never be a captain option

 

[Flandersss]

Interested in average only.

He'll never be a captain option

I can see Harley averaging 100+

 

[Kadog]

Zorko v harley

Why?

Bennell. Class, goalkicker maybe some midfield time.
Zorko has toooo much competition to share points with. Like him though.

Bennell 105-115 range
Zorko 95-105

 

[rocker_oz33]

All this bennell talk lol ok i'll play..>

Docherty/rampe & swan.
V's
KK & Bennell.

 

[pulpdriver]

All this bennell talk lol ok i'll play..>

Docherty/rampe & swan.
V's
KK & Bennell.

2nd option for me. I think Swan is great value though.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Cheers i have option 1 atm see how swanny goes before RD1.

 

[dewah07]

Kk vs langdon

 

[Flandersss]

Heater v Hurn

Choose a combo:

Gray & Minson

Or

Bennell & Goldstein

 

[Flandersss]

All this bennell talk lol ok i'll play..>

Docherty/rampe & swan.
V's
KK & Bennell.

Option 2 - KK & Bennell.

So much upside in that combo.

 

[Flandersss]

Kk vs langdon

I'd go KK.

Higher ceiling & should be playing a more sc friendly role.

 

[Kadog]

Heater v Hurn

Choose a combo:

Gray & Minson

Or

Bennell & Goldstein

Shaw Bennell Goldstein

 

[Flandersss]

Shaw Bennell Goldstein

Yeah history says Heater is always good for 92+

What's your main reason for Goldy & Harley?

 

[Kadog]

Yeah history says Heater is always good for 92+

What's your main reason for Goldy & Harley?

Bennell. Class, goalkicker maybe some midfield time.
Bennell 105-115 range

Goldy hitouts % to adv was top 5. Norf have solid midfield group to support. Clear no1 ruckman no competition = high TOG%. Durable.

 

[karaoke]

Simpson v Houli (+ 65k)

Both 2 of most durable defenders.

Simpson, priced at ~95, likely to play all games & average ~95.

Houli, priced at ~85, likely to play all games & I reckon can ave ~90 (2013 ave).

Thoughts?

 

[Goats]

Simpson v Houli (+ 65k)

Both 2 of most durable defenders.

Simpson, priced at ~95, likely to play all games & average ~95.

Houli, priced at ~85, likely to play all games & I reckon can ave ~90 (2013 ave).

Thoughts?

It really depends on what you can do with the extra $65k.

Although Simpson plays the occasional shocker he's reliable for 10-13 100+ games a season with a few 80's & 90's thrown in. Houli will give 6-8 100+ games and still play a few poor games.

Where do you see Houli's score improvement coming from?

 

[karaoke]

Where do you see Houli's score improvement coming from?

He's pretty consistent, probably from eliminating the few stinkers he had last year - 3x scores 50 or less.

Just thinking about a few different connotations with what I am trying to set up.

 

[Daniel McL]

Josh Kelly (59 yesterday) or Adam Tomlinson (100 yesterday)?

Just worried with all the GWS midfielders that means less midfield time for Kelly.

 

[Krujan]

Josh Kelly (59 yesterday) or Adam Tomlinson (100 yesterday)?

Just worried with all the GWS midfielders that means less midfield time for Kelly.

Of what relevance are yesterdays practice match SC scores?

 

[Daniel McL]

Of what relevance are yesterdays practice match SC scores?

Was simply stating.
Just wanted to know your thoughts?

 

[Krujan]

Was simply stating.
Just wanted to know your thoughts?

Kelly, purely because he's a M/F who should play the bulk of his TOG through the mids.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Josh Kelly (59 yesterday) or Adam Tomlinson (100 yesterday)?

Just worried with all the GWS midfielders that means less midfield time for Kelly.

JKelly is a fwd/mid in that price range i would get Walters from freo.

 

[Daniel McL]

Kelly, purely because he's a M/F who should play the bulk of his TOG through the mids.

Cheers. Now after that, what about Josh Kelly or Taylor Adams?
I feel like Adams will get more time in the midfield for the Magpies, but Adams can get suspended & give away a few frees so I'm not sure.

 

[toxic]

He's pretty consistent, probably from eliminating the few stinkers he had last year - 3x scores 50 or less.

Just thinking about a few different connotations with what I am trying to set up.

I read somewhere Houli has d/e issues and that's why his scores are 2nd level

 

[Krujan]

Cheers. Now after that, what about Josh Kelly or Taylor Adams?
I feel like Adams will get more time in the midfield for the Magpies, but Adams can get suspended & give away a few frees so I'm not sure.

I don't rate Adams at all for SC. Terrible disposal efficiency.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

I had GAJ captain on the day he scored 254 against the Swans.

lol like most people did, so no gain there.