2015 SC NAB Challenge Thread

[rocker_oz33]

What sc did walters get?

 

[Jiska]

I agree but at 486k the upside is massive.

It is all a risk v reward scenario and i reckon he plays 20+ games.

Judd vs Joey vs Crouch - Same price point. Judd would be my third pick of that lot.

 

[Krujan]

Judd vs Joey vs Crouch - Same price point. Judd would be my third pick of that lot.

No way, Joey is finished & St's are way crappier than Carlton.

Same price point as all those guys, I'd take A Swallow, who's still in his prime & plays for a good team.

 

[Chism]

Judd vs Joey vs Crouch - Same price point. Judd would be my third pick of that lot.

Judd is more capable of a 150 game than any of those and if he plays all season will easily out score them.

It is a big IF though as he needs to stay on the park. He monstered a near full strength Pies team today with multiple opposition players having a go on him and looked as hungry as anything.

 

[Chism]

No way, Joey is finished & St's are way crappier than Carlton.

Same price point as all those guys, I'd take A Swallow, who's still in his prime & plays for a good team.

I already have A Swallow and he is a massive must have at 500k.

 

[Krujan]

Judd is more capable of a 150 game than any of those and if he plays all season will easily out score them.

It is a big IF though as he needs to stay on the park. He monstered a near full strength Pies team today with multiple opposition players having a go on him and looked as hungry as anything.

Collingwood's midfield aside from Pendles (& Sidey who didn't play) is pretty crap though.

 

[Chism]

Collingwood's midfield aside from Pendles is pretty crap though.

I am looking at our first 6 games and i reckon Juddy will monster all of them!

Goldsack had a go at him and is most likely their best stopper but he did not last long on him.

 

[TheOz]

I ****ing love Juddy!

 

[TheOz]

What sc did walters get?

The CD fellas have all headed out for a well deserved parma and pot, thus we haven't been provided with any scores yet.

 

[Krujan]

I am looking at our first 6 games and i reckon Juddy will monster all of them!

When it comes to SC it's best to take one's Carlton hat off. I always think the same thing when it comes to Murph, always talking myself into believing he will end up a top 8 SC mid no matter the circumstances. I'm going to pass for the 1st time ever this year, not just because of his interrupted pre-season, but because that there are simply better SC options at his price & even a few who's starting prices are less.

 

[TheOz]

When it comes to SC it's best to take one's Carlton hat off. I always think the same thing when it comes to Murph, always talking myself into believing he will end up a top 8 SC mid no matter the circumstances. I'm going to pass for the 1st time ever this year, not just because of his interrupted pre-season, but because that there are simply better SC options at his price & even a few who's starting prices are less.

blasphemy!

 

[Jiska]

No way, Joey is finished & St's are way crappier than Carlton.

Same price point as all those guys, I'd take A Swallow, who's still in his prime & plays for a good team.

GAJ lead the league in SC points when GC were bottom 2.
Pendles second last year playing in a bottom eight side.
Minson top ruckman two years ago in a bottom side
Griffen in top 6 mids a few years ago in a bottom 4 side

Plenty more examples. Don't think side you play for has a major impact on output.

 

[TheOz]

GAJ lead the league in SC points when GC were shit.
Pendles second last year playing in a bottom right side.
Minson top ruckman two years ago in a bottom side
Griffen in top 6 mids a few years ago in a top side

Plenty more examples. Don't think side you play for has a major impact on output.

Rockliff last season in a shite Brisbane.

 

[Flandersss]

Looks like I have to try & fit Cripps in.

JS also helps.

 

[Krujan]

GAJ lead the league in SC points when GC were bottom 2.
Pendles second last year playing in a bottom eight side.
Minson top ruckman two years ago in a bottom side
Griffen in top 6 mids a few years ago in a bottom 4 side

Plenty more examples. Don't think side you play for has a major impact on output.

Monty's the same age as Judd. He was terrible last year apart from a few early games.

 

[SnappyHappy]

No way, Joey is finished & St's are way crappier than Carlton.

Same price point as all those guys, I'd take A Swallow, who's still in his prime & plays for a good team.

Judd is more capable of a 150 game than any of those and if he plays all season will easily out score them.

It is a big IF though as he needs to stay on the park. He monstered a near full strength Pies team today with multiple opposition players having a go on him and looked as hungry as anything.

Not sure about this one. Joey had 3 weeks as recent as last year of 144, 174, 144. He'd be my pick of those 3.

 

[Krujan]

Rockliff last season in a shite Brisbane.

Didn't realise Rocky was 31 & a half years old.

 

[Jiska]

Judd is more capable of a 150 game than any of those and if he plays all season will easily out score them.

It is a big IF though as he needs to stay on the park. He monstered a near full strength Pies team today with multiple opposition players having a go on him and looked as hungry as anything.

I reckon you're looking through rose tinted glasses. He's one of the best players I've seen over the past 15 years but I feel he's SC days are behind him. You're just as likely to get a 60-70 out of him, or a week off here and there; you don't want that from a 500k mid for mine.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Carlton vs Collingwood

137 Chris Yarran

117 Simon White

110 Andrew Carrazzo

106 Patrick Cripps

104 Chris Judd

98 Kristian Jaksch

97 Nathan J. Brown

95 Andrejs Everitt

95 Levi Greenwood

90 Adam Oxley

89 Jack Crisp

86 Sam Docherty

86 Ed Curnow

85 Corey Gault

81 Zach Tuohy

81 Josh Thomas

80 Tom Bell

79 Tyson Goldsack

78 Kade Simpson

77 Jarryd Blair

77 Sam Rowe

76 Blaine Boekhorst

70 Scott Pendlebury

69 Tom Langdon

68 Jason Tutt

65 Ben Sinclair

64 Robert Warnock

64 Lachie Henderson

63 Dane Swan

62 Alan Toovey

62 Alex Fasolo

61 Levi Casboult

59 Ciaran Byrne

56 Michael Jamison

49 Ben Kennedy

47 Marley Williams

44 Liam Jones

44 Jordan de Goey

44 Patrick Karnezis

43 Brodie Grundy

41 Tim Broomhead

40 Travis Cloke

31 Troy Menzel

28 Travis Varcoe

28 Clem Smith

27 Sam Dwyer

27 Jackson Ramsay

18 Bryce Gibbs

3 Mason Cox

 

[TheOz]

Didn't realise Rocky was 31 & a half years old.

Who mentioned age? It was about scoring capability in crap teams, not age.

 

[Krujan]

Not sure about this one. Joey had 3 weeks as recent as last year of 144, 174, 144. He'd be my pick of those 3.

and then averaged 74 from the next 14 games to finish the year.

 

[Krujan]

Who mentioned age? It was about scoring capability in crap teams, not age.

I mentioned age as well as scoring capability in a crap team.

 

[rocker_oz33]

The CD fellas have all headed out for a well deserved parma and pot, thus we haven't been provided with any scores yet.

Thats nice of them half job Harrys.

 

[SnappyHappy]

and then averaged 74 from the next 14 games to finish the year.

Played with a fractured leg.

 

[Chism]

I reckon you're looking through rose tinted glasses. He's one of the best players I've seen over the past 15 years but I feel he's SC days are behind him. You're just as likely to get a 60-70 out of him, or a week off here and there; you don't want that from a 500k mid for mine.

I can see what you are saying but every player is capable of a 70 every now and then no matter what their value ( Besides Gazza!! ). If Judd remains injury free i cannot see a better 486k player with the upside he has.