2017 Planning thread

[Hairy Lager]

fair enough, you would know better

Bont and Libba as fwds.. YES PLEASE

This ^ Three 95+ SC points average Dogs in fwd line next year a possibility.

 

[gcsunsfc]

Never again:
Brodie Smith
Bartel
Deledio
Yeo
S.Mitchell
Westoff

Not starting with in round 1:
Cripps
Rockliff
Jelwood
M.Boyd
Wingard

Keen if there is a full preseason:
Stef Martin
Goldy
Pittard
Wines

Very keen:
Shuey
Treloar
Fyfe
Ryder (if DPP)
Lycett
Gawn
Doc
Shaw
Dusty
GC Lynch

If priced cheap enough:
Heppell
Hurley
Harley Bennell
GAJ
JOM
Beams

Half way between burn man and lock:
Everyone else

Wouldn't pick Harley unless 200k. Calf is useless.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Wouldn't pick Harley unless 200k. Calf is useless.

Nose is a bit out of order also.

 

[Super Hans]

What makes you so sure Dahl will keep his DP?

Bont and Libba probably have more chance.

I reckon Dahl will keep it. He seems like one of those players who will always have it no matter what his heat maps suggest.

He and Libba are both ridiculously underpriced. Dahlhaus was averaging 110 before he got injured this year, Libba 100 without his injury effected games this year.

Hopefully they both get DP. I'll pick Bont regardless .

 

[Super Hans]

Locks:
Laird
Beams
Bontempelli
Pendles (only bloke I start with every year)
Fyfe

High on list:
Williams
Vince (DP)
Cripps
Crouch
Libba (DP)
Dahlhaus (DP)
Sandilands

My never again list:
MacMillan
Brodie Smith
Steve Johnson
Higgins

 

[stevebbb]

If Fyfe has a full preseason, he'll be in 60% of teams

What will he be priced at? 105 average + a small discount for playing less than 6 games?

 

[Hairy Lager]

If Fyfe has a full preseason, he'll be in 60% of teams

What will he be priced at? 105 average + a small discount for playing less than 6 games?

Don't think I'll start with Fyfe has burn-a-trade written all over him.

 

[Super Hans]

If Fyfe has a full preseason, he'll be in 60% of teams

What will he be priced at? 105 average + a small discount for playing less than 6 games?

There's no point in guessing prices for him or Beams after the stupid shit SC pulled with Ablett's price this year.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Fyfe isn't a risk. Seriously unlucky getting hit on the plate. he's had most the year off resting it. Beams I don't know why everyone is so into. Massive risk, his knee is looking shot

 

[Hairy Lager]

Fyfe isn't a risk. Seriously unlucky getting hit on the plate. he's had most the year off resting it. Beams I don't know why everyone is so into. Massive risk, his knee is looking shot

Fyfe has a bulging disc, these things don't heal themselves.
He will carry that injury all his life, he is a MASSIVE risk.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Fyfe has a bulging disc, these things don't heal themselves.
He will carry that injury all his life, he is a MASSIVE risk.

Good, don't sign him.

 

[toxic]

Fyfe isn't a risk. Seriously unlucky getting hit on the plate. he's had most the year off resting it. Beams I don't know why everyone is so into. Massive risk, his knee is looking shot

how can you say he's not a risk

hasn't played a full season in 4 years

 

[Longbombswans]

Will definitely be keen to play JJ next year. Anybody hazard a guess at what price he will be? Backline of Doc, Laird, and JJ sign me up

 

[toxic]

Will definitely be keen to play JJ next year. Anybody hazard a guess at what price he will be? Backline of Doc, Laird, and JJ sign me up

Jj tick under 500k

Take his average and multiply by $5400

 

[Raveneyes]

Backs: Doch, Rance, Heater
Mids: Pendles, Danger, Hanners, Neale, SP Cropps
Rucks: Gawn
Forwards: Bont (surely DPP), Dusty, Zorko

Giddy up.

 

[Glenn Barclay]

Hopefully Roughead can get back to full health.
I would love to have him running around in my forward line next year.

 

[evo]

Backs: Doch, Rance, Heater
Mids: Pendles, Danger, Hanners, Neale, SP Cropps
Rucks: Gawn
Forwards: Bont (surely DPP), Dusty, Zorko

Giddy up.

yep. My start will look very similar to this too.

 

[clogwearer]

High on list:
Williams

Dunno. I've had him most of this year and he's been serviceable but goes sub-90 too often. Might be priced higher than I'd want him to be at the start.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Dylan ****ing Shiela. Got rid of him 10 weeks ago yet he still drives me mad. Never ever again. Misses easy goals, goes missing, spends half the game on the bench. He's more Jane than Tarzan. Never ever ever.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Cripps been on fire and can score really well when he gets he's shit together.
Bonts will be the biggest lock if gets DPP.Will have high ownership anyways.
I will go Sloane again,maybe not from the get go.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Dylan ******* Shiela. Got rid of him 10 weeks ago yet he still drives me mad. Never ever again. Misses easy goals, goes missing, spends half the game on the bench. He's more Jane than Tarzan. Never ever ever.

Sounds like a bad breakup.

 

[gcsunsfc]

Rookie - Brayden Fiorini. Racks it up big time.

Essentially played 6 games in 2 separate stints in the NEAFL due to knee injury

14 possessions, 4 marks, 1 tackle
19 possessions, 3 marks, 1 tackle
40 possessions, 14 marks, 7 tackle, 2 goals
30 possessions, 8 marks, 2 tackles, 2 goals
32 possessions, 6 marks, 5 tackles, 1 goal
31 possessions, 8 marks, 5 tackles, 4 goals

Kick:handball about 2:1

Rocket said would have played this year (every GC listed except him Jaeger and Swallow has) if not for injury. Looks our best player in the reserves in most games he has played.

Dammit! Say this 3 weeks ago and then he gets picked, makes his debut last week 17 possessions for 45 sc then goes massive 30 possessions 12 tackles 2 goals, 125 SuperCoach.

Couldn't you have waited till round 1 next year mate!

 

[Metapod]

how can you say he's not a risk

hasn't played a full season in 4 years

View attachment 281112

I know you're discussing risk, but also have to weigh up reward. No one can say he was a bad pick in 2014 + 15!

 

[Metapod]

Strategy for next year (and I tried this year but went against it).
-G+R starting team.
-Focus on cash gen early.
-Aim to have 1 mid who goes big against certain teams as M9. Thinking Jack Steven atm.
-No KPP.
-R/F link (hopefully Nic Nat / Gawn have this eligibility).
-If they won't be in the top %ile for their position come years end, don't pick them.
-Dont even consider: Yeo, Smith, Ward, Bartel, Hall

Starting team:
Back: Shaw, Docherty, Simpson, R, R, R, R, R
Mid: Danger, Hannes, Pendles, Fyfe, R, R, R, R, R, R, R
Ruck: Gawn, Goldstein, R
Fwd: Gray, Bont, Naitanui, Dahl, R, R, R, R (one can hope right)

 

[Hairy Lager]

Strategy for next year (and I tried this year but went against it).
-G+R starting team.
-Focus on cash gen early.
-Aim to have 1 mid who goes big against certain teams as M9. Thinking Jack Steven atm.
-No KPP.
-R/F link (hopefully Nic Nat / Gawn have this eligibility).

2018 maybe.