2020 Draft and Trades Thread

[kreglze]

Bad decision imo. They’ll end up in a cycle of being too young all the time like GC and Carlton have been locked in for too long. Needed to maintain a few, even if they are just considered reserves players for next season.

Depends how they play it, they might be relying on picking up delistings from better clubs to beef up the experience. Will be in interesting off season for the AFL.

 

[Jen2310]

Its been coming for a couple years now, unfortunately.

Better to rip the bandaid off than prolong the unevitable.

 

[kreglze]

Pittard as a cheap HB cover wouldn't be the worst.

Had some good games this year.

 

[Jen2310]

For someone that was picked up as a rookie in 2012, Marley has lasted longer than most. 125 games.

 

[Jen2310]

 

[Supersuns]

yeah, that's pretty well known. Whether or not that changed when he went to norf, no idea.

Once a dickhead always a dickhead for me Jen

 

[Jen2310]

Once a dickhead always a dickhead for me Jen

That's a fair call.

 

[NOBBYS]

No for me.
Would be close to turnover king of the AFL.
No upside.

 

[Choppers]

No for me.
Would be close to turnover king of the AFL.
No upside.

+1

 

[Peel67skin]

Clayton on

 

[Deleted member 2402071]

Not difficult to put a few names together:

Trade:
2MP
Brodie

Retire:
Hanley
Harbrow

Pay out:
Schoenfeld
Corey Ellis
Joyce
Horlin-Smith
Murdoch
Heron?
Dawson?

Delist:
Holman
Murtagh

maybe more I have missed?

 

[Peel67skin]

Not difficult to put a few names together:

Trade:
2MP
Brodie

Retire:
Hanley
Harbrow

Pay out:
Schoenfeld
Corey Ellis
Joyce
Horlin-Smith
Murdoch
Heron?
Dawson?

Delist:
Holman
Murtagh

maybe more I have missed?

Payout apart from Murdoch all our of contract just said good bye no need to paid them .

 

[RowellAnderson12]

Good to see North openly tank. Out of all those i would only take Jamie Macmillan as he would fill the experienced back pocket type operator for cheap. 188cm 82kg Bowes size and would add experience and leadership.

Openly known Harbrow Hanley Thompson 30+ all cooked, then it goes down to Collins 26 who played 40 games. Need more 25year olds +

 

[Supersuns]

Good to see North openly tank. Out of all those i would only take Jamie Macmillan as he would fill the experienced back pocket type operator for cheap. 188cm 82kg Bowes size and would add experience and leadership.

Openly known Harbrow Hanley Thompson 30+ all cooked, then it goes down to Collins 26 who played 40 games. Need more 25year olds +

Nathan broad

 

[CommittedSuns]

Tom Browne reporting Ben Brown now leaving Kangas too

 

[Supersuns]

Tom Browne reporting Ben Brown now leaving Kangas too

Geelong i reckon or the pies

 

[eppo67]

Not difficult to put a few names together:

Trade:
2MP
Brodie

Retire:
Hanley
Harbrow

Pay out:
Schoenfeld
Corey Ellis
Joyce
Horlin-Smith
Murdoch
Heron?
Dawson?

Delist:
Holman
Murtagh

maybe more I have missed?

North Melbourne going full scorched Earth.

How the hell did Hall escape that cull. I'm flabbergasted.

 

[Big Red Machine]

How the hell did Hall escape that cull. I'm flabbergasted.

... Oh crap you're right!

How... Unless those 9 Brownlow votes from 3 years ago really mean that much to North?

I mean don't get me wrong Aaron's a nice bloke with a lovely family but he'd do much better from the top of Thredbo than the middle of the MCG.

 

[Jen2310]

How the hell did Hall escape that cull. I'm flabbergasted.

Contracted til 2021?

 

[OB11]

How the hell did Hall escape that cull. I'm flabbergasted.

Doesn't mean they won't try and trade him while he's contracted.

They've told Polec to go out and find a trade suitor to get him off their books, and he's just a better version of Hall and more coin.

 

[Deleted member 2402071]

Doesn't mean they won't try and trade him while he's contracted.

They've told Polec to go out and find a trade suitor to get him off their books, and he's just a better version of Hall and more coin.

Hall is worse now than he was with us.
Imagine he’d be untradable. Just lucky he has 1yr left on his contract.

 

[Young_Guns]

... Oh crap you're right!

How... Unless those 9 Brownlow votes from 3 years ago really mean that much to North?

I mean don't get me wrong Aaron's a nice bloke with a lovely family but he'd do much better from the top of Thredbo than the middle of the MCG.

To be fair if we brought him back for next year he would probably win the Brownlow taking advantage of Rowell feeding him.
Wouldn’t have to go near a contest all season.

 

[Peel67skin]

How the hell did Hall escape that cull. I'm flabbergasted.

Clayton connection

 

[eppo67]

I don't watch a lot of other teams.
Would Pittard be OK for a couple of years off HB.
To replace Harbrow Hanley our back 6 is extremely young.

 

[NOBBYS]

I don't watch a lot of other teams.
Would Pittard be OK for a couple of years off HB.
To replace Harbrow Hanley our back 6 is extremely young.

Definite no from me--turnover king