Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Duckworthy]

Young ....but only just behind Daicos

Agreed

 

[TempletonTheRat]

I can fit three of Stewart, Dawson, Daicos, and Young into my backline. Who comes out?

Stewart - shit bye

 

[The Big Gruzewski]

I can fit three of Stewart, Dawson, Daicos, and Young into my backline. Who comes out?

Whoever you leave out most likely comes in later. Stewart, Young and Daicos all seem a little underpriced. Dawson may drop a little at some point. Depends a lot on your bye structure but I’d be leaving Dawson out to begin with.

 

[Flandersss]

Yeo v Bowes
Laird v Touk
Titch v Anderson
Rozee v D.Cameron

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yeo v Bowes
Laird v Touk
Titch v Anderson
Rozee v D.Cameron

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yeo v Bowes
Laird v Touk
Titch v Anderson
Rozee v D.Cameron

Ideally neither
Laird (tough call though)
Titch (just, I'll probably change my mind in 5 minutes)
Rozee

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Yeo v Bowes
Laird v Touk
Titch v Anderson
Rozee v D.Cameron

Yeo if his calves hold up and he makes it to rd 1

neither - Touk has a shit bye, Laird too expensive coming off a peak year

Titch - has the runs on the board

I'm starting Cameron at R2 and will take one of Butters or Rozee

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yeo if his calves hold up and he makes it to rd 1

neither - Touk has a s**t bye, Laird too expensive coming off a peak year

Titch - has the runs on the board

I'm starting Cameron at R2 and will take one of Butters or Rozee

By Hook or by Crook ....we'll get Yeo to R1

 

[Flandersss]

Laird & Cameron
V
Neale & Marshall

 

[Choppers]

Laird & Cameron
V
Neale & Marshall

As the 4 of them are keepers, you have 2 Rd12 bye v 2 Rd14 bye......for that reason alone I'd go Laird and Cameron.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Different lines, but same $$$

Steele vs Stewart

 

[kananooks]

Different lines, but same $$$

Steele vs Stewart

steele surely. proven 110+ premo sc midfielder. stewart trots around a 100avg.

i have the same dilemmas where id rather spend 600k on cripps rather than docherty for example.

 

[Flandersss]

Different lines, but same $$$

Steele vs Stewart

Steele

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Different lines, but same $$$

Steele vs Stewart

Definitely Steele

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Different lines, but same $$$

Steele vs Stewart

Sexy Tom Stewart, lots more options for points in midfield.

 

[JuddgementDay]

LDU vs Green

I can mount arguments for both, and going around in circles

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

LDU vs Green

I can mount arguments for both, and going around in circles

It's role with both. Need to watch closely in preseason to see how their new coaches use them.

I'd lean LDU currently, I like Noah Anderson too in that price range and he has no such questions.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

Reckon you could ask Laird v Piggy v Neale IMO

Laird apparently in superb condition ...despite some saying he'll have more midfield competition this season ....I doubt it, still #1 Crows Mid

Neale, traditionally starts seasons on fire

Piggy, well he's Piggy

All the top teams have diificult fixtures to start the season, first 3-4 rounds .....Adelaide being slightly easier

Toss of a coin job for me .....Piggy is a safe option

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

Both if you can but if only 1 then Laird

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

Tough choice but slightly lean towards laird as if the crows lose a lot of games teams may not bother tagging him where Oliver probably gets a tag more often as Melbourne the better side

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

you will want need both in your complete team, so which one is likely to fall in price the most?

the way I see it Piggy has more positives and less negatives than Laird at being able to maintain last years average.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

2-2 so far lol. It's a tough choice.

 

[buttox]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

Laird mate. Piggy can throw out stinker and drop in price. He has the last few years.
I expect Laird to continue his finish to last year and almost be a perma captain.

 

[Duckworthy]

Laird vs Piggy?

Assuming they both line up round one and we can only afford one, which is it?

Oliver