- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,256
- 12,353
- AFL Club
- Carlton
That’s not really helpful for now. We should be doing that anyway.Why's that?
Draft someone & develop them.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
That’s not really helpful for now. We should be doing that anyway.Why's that?
Draft someone & develop them.
Sure but we're not really using Young now anyway. At least a developing prospect may have some long term viability.That’s not really helpful for now. We should be doing that anyway.
Perhaps even, Lions, North
Cam Zurhaar = Aaron Hamill.
I’d be all for bringing him in as a Free Agent.
Watching tonight’s game and the Swans got a bargain with Jordan, they really know how to identify players that can play a role
They will get pick 19 anyway and he isn’t worth much more in a trade. Unless they try and make a point they probably will just take it.Cook the books to get North band 1, or they will match for sure.
They will get pick 19 anyway and he isn’t worth much more in a trade. Unless they try and make a point they probably will just take it.
I’m not a fan of pitto being in the side tbhWhat would get for TDK in a trade?
It’s clear to me he is a valuable player and clubs would rush to sign him but he just doesn’t fit our current set up.
With JSOS to return in 2025. Pitto signed on for a few more years to come and TDK a pre agent before demanding much more dollars, I think the time has come.
He’s not dominant as a ruck and certainly not much of a threat up forward, I just see too many positives (unfortunately) in trading him this year to free up cash and bring in some really good picks. He just hasn’t found his position imo after 7 years and maybe it’s time we really look to add in other areas of need either via the draft, trade or FA.
Pitto is taking on some unbelievable players and holding his own imo and it’s clear he is viewed as our #1 ruck.I’m not a fan of pitto being in the side tbh
Does some great things at the bounce of the ball but, but on the whole, that’s about it. Though we are carrying too many injuries to have the luxury of really playing with structure but we’d be just about the only team playing two rucks wouldn’t we? Pitto in = Tdk contesting an already poor set up forward line
They won’t go back to TDK solo rucking, but he was doing fine
Not sure we would accept that as a step forward.I’m not too stressed
We will still make the 8 and win a final
Wont win the flag cause of pace but they are certain to address that issue in the offseason
Progression is never linear. If the swans win a flag, they've gone from a grand final, to 8th, to a flag. Pies made a granny in '18, couple of years of finals, bottom 2, prelim, flag. Tigers had 3 years of elimination final losses, down to 13th, to 3 flags in 4 years. It's a journey, we need to stop worrying this "it's a failure if we dont achieve x result" as a fanbaseNot sure we would accept that as a step forward.
l think the list needs a refresh & reset to win a premiership.
No…Do we have a list balance right?
He was their worst player. Didn't exactly give us the best audition eitherAfter last night’s effort I think we can safely assume that Will Hayward ain’t coming.
So it’ll be at least 43 years before we win another flag then? I may as well throw out my membership!I would love to end up with egg on my face but I am confident our streak between cups will exceed Swans before 2005 and Melbourne before 2021. That’s the reality of where this club is at.
l think the concern for us we have quite a number of players now close to 30, combined with the fact we clearly have gaps in our list in term of a more rounded front half instead of a one dimensional Curnow & Mckay set up, combined with the fact we lack speed in the middle if we don’t win the stoppages, not sure Cripps & Kennedy and Hewett is sustainable particularly against a quick mid field.Progression is never linear. If the swans win a flag, they've gone from a grand final, to 8th, to a flag. Pies made a granny in '18, couple of years of finals, bottom 2, prelim, flag. Tigers had 3 years of elimination final losses, down to 13th, to 3 flags in 4 years. It's a journey, we need to stop worrying this "it's a failure if we dont achieve x result" as a fanbase
Let's see how Sydney go without:It’s quite simple. We lack speed and our culture is soft. Playing Sydney shows a club with culture. We had it once and it is long gone. I would love to end up with egg on my face but I am confident our streak between cups will exceed Swans before 2005 and Melbourne before 2021. That’s the reality of where this club is at.
No current season stats available