List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - The Final Countdown

[beema limapep]

Confirmed Smillie injured. 12 weeks.

 

[Toadvine]

Confirmed Smillie injured. 12 weeks.

Is it that he's just still restricted to running? "Ruled him out of the start of pre season" seems click bait phrasing when it could just mean he's not doing the full program?

 

[THE_GUN]

Is it that he's just still restricted to running? "Ruled him out of the start of pre season" seems click bait phrasing when it could just mean he's not doing the full program?

I think that would be the case
Most likely Smillie just doing light work and they asked why he is not involved and got told has a slight calf then Mr X jnr dresses it up to get clicks

 

[T4P]

Is it that he's just still restricted to running? "Ruled him out of the start of pre season" seems click bait phrasing when it could just mean he's not doing the full program?

This is exactly what this sounds like

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

lizard man highlights

Chief would need to buy more data.

 

[THE_GUN]

Is it that he's just still restricted to running? "Ruled him out of the start of pre season" seems click bait phrasing when it could just mean he's not doing the full program?

Just heard him report these words exactly: ".....young gun Josh Smillie was missing however, with his off-season cruelled by soft tissue concerns once again...."

In other words, Smills did not train and did not injure himself on day 1. Still an in-house issue and it's only November, so keep working on it Josh.

from Pre

 

[Karp3_dm]

Just heard him report these words exactly: ".....young gun Josh Smillie was missing however, with his off-season cruelled by soft tissue concerns once again...."

In other words, Smills did not train and did not injure himself on day 1. Still an in-house issue and it's only November, so keep working on it Josh.

from Pre

Think we should delist him and hang Blair Hartley publicly

Am I doing it right?

 

[THE_GUN]

Think we should delist him and hang Blair Hartley publicly

Am I doing it right?

Ask the flogs on this board

 

[hammer180]

Whats peoples thoughts on this hypothetical trade

Richmond - In 9 and 16.
Out 4 and 38
Carlton In - F1 (Adl) and 38.
Out 9
Adelaide - In 4.
Out F1 and 16

Would you rather pick 9 in this yrs draft or GC f1 and Crows f1?

 

[Buddy Tambling]

Think we all just need to take breath.
“Start of preseason” is not the end of the world. Long way to go.

But yeah, I would 100% be taking robey/sharp/cunming…

Let’s get that midfield sorted and if Smillie comes on, it’s a bonus.

 

[jthanos]

Club is set up to fail if we don't draft Robey or Sharp.

They need both Sharp & Robey/Cummings

 

[THE_GUN]

Would you rather pick 9 in this yrs draft or GC f1 and Crows f1?

Pick #9 this draft

 

[Rubber Hips]

Club is set up to fail if we don't draft Robey or Sharp.

Just take both…it’ll sort out the mid situation for the next decade

 

[THE_GUN]

Maybe Oliver G now ? Definitely Sulli Robey now.

Just take Robey & Sharp and give Smillie all the time needed

 

[dean33]

Is it that he's just still restricted to running? "Ruled him out of the start of pre season" seems click bait phrasing when it could just mean he's not doing the full program?

Start of preseason is today, so in essence he might be missing today or this week or just delayed start which has been planned all along. Definite click bait.

 

[Wacky Tiger]

lizard man highlights

POTY

 

[Damo80]

Pick #9 this draft

Can’t imagine the club would agree with you. Have made it pretty clear we don’t love this years draft crop. In fact, I’d suspect a “head turning offer” for pick 3/4 is far more likely to need to involve a future pick, than a split within the 2025 draft.

 

[THE_GUN]

Can’t imagine the club would agree with you. Have made it pretty clear we don’t love this years draft crop. In fact, I’d suspect a “head turning offer” for pick 3/4 is far more likely to need to involve a future pick, than a split within the 2025 draft.

Crows & Suns could both be top 4 teams next year and picks around 20
Armstrong , Daffy , Leys all in the pipe line

 

[Drunken Wookie]

View attachment 2473831

dont remember his vampire sidekick

 

[beema limapep]

After the latest Smillie injury news I've adjusted my picks. We have to get the midfield right. Smillie is a bonus if he ever comes good.

Grlj is out. We can draft his type down the track or use a later pick this year (e.g.Le Ray).

2 of the following 3 are absolutely necessary, but in order of personal preference:-

Robey
Sharp
Cumming

CDT is still a hard no and I'll flipping loose it if we take him. Taylor - it's just the wrong player type too.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

After the latest Smillie injury news I've adjusted my picks. We have to get the midfield right. Smillie is a bonus if he ever comes good.

Grlj is out. We can draft his type down the track or use a later pick this year (e.g.Le Ray).

2 of the following 3 are absolutely necessary, but in order of personal preference:-

Robey
Sharp
Cumming

CDT is still a hard no and I'll flipping loose it if we take him. Taylor - it's just the wrong player type too.

yeah any of those 3 makes sense, we'd be silly to think we've solved the midfield problem in 1 draft. my call is if tarranto doesnt get cap'n soon he'll explore his options, likely hopper as well. they'll chase success at some point. need to draft like those 2 dont exist.

 

[tigerfan1961]

After the latest Smillie injury news I've adjusted my picks. We have to get the midfield right. Smillie is a bonus if he ever comes good.

Grlj is out. We can draft his type down the track or use a later pick this year (e.g.Le Ray).

2 of the following 3 are absolutely necessary, but in order of personal preference:-

Robey
Sharp
Cumming

CDT is still a hard no and I'll flipping loose it if we take him. Taylor - it's just the wrong player type too.

So you know better than our list manager or recruiters. Get real

 

[beema limapep]

So you know better than our list manager or recruiters. Get real

Offended by opinions. Get real yourself.

 

[beema limapep]

dont remember his vampire sidekick

Think it was either Potsy or Ralphmalph

 

[tigerfan1961]

Offended by opinions. Get real yourself.

No Mate, apologies, you’re entitled to your opinion for sure. Just need draft night to arrive asap.
Just makes me laugh that so many think we are going to car crash this draft if we don’t do what they want/expect