List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - The Final Countdown

[Groupie_]

Rhy in his video certainly put to bed the weak draft suggestions. "It's strong" and there will be good talent still available at 38....

 

[59Stanley]

Getting major Sharp and Cumming vibes followed up with a pick swap to access Jevan and topped off with Sam Allen

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Should trade our future first and get Robey, Sharp and Cumming.

Dees do it all the time.
But be very hard sell trying too sell our 27 1st for a 26 1st.

 

[Peptide Pig]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

What's to say Robey wasn't at Punt Rd this week?

Dance hall been torn down

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

If it’s Melbourne who’s after Robey , they must trade. Otherwise loose to bombers.

They like Nairn as well which may help us too grab their f1(Which is Blair's price).
3 for 8 & f1
They get Robey & Nairn
We get Cumming & Grilj

 

[richolovesgoal]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

Robey for sure. I don’t like taking rucks that high (and is he even a ruck?).

People comparing him to Jackson but Jackson dominated his draft year with 30+ hitouts whereas I think CDT averaged 16.

He could be a gun - he’s obviously an athletic freak, but a bit of an unknown. Too speculative for me.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

I just see an absolute superstar with Robey.

Has the size, burst, skill to be one of the leagues elite. Kicks goals for fun and a good mark. Modern day midfield height and would be an unstoppable duo with Lalor. I can’t see how we overlook him. Has that real bullet pass in his disposal also.

Just turned 18, one of the youngest in the class. Plenty of scope for improvement.

Character is a big check too with huge leadership potential. Listen to his interviews, the blokes a 28yr old in an 18yr old body. Knows what to say, how to say it and is going to bring hordes of lasses to the club also.

I see a young Cotchin in him (personality wise and how he handles himself)

CDT, Sharp or Cumming. I don’t care which one is after aslong as we picked Sullivan.

I'm sure your son will do well.Just not in the yellow & black.

 

[THE_GUN]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

Can only speak for myself but im not a fan of taking a Ruck with a top 10 pick and rather get a Ruck thats had 3-4 years development already at another club and is an over rated position. Not sure what CDT becomes in the future but thinking his ceiling is a Blicavs type. if both available im taking Robey but i love big mids that are powerful and kick goals

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

What are some other combinations that we haven’t discussed yet

LOTW & THE_GUN

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

I have a feeling we might get an offer that is too good to refuse.

 

[prodigy]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

CDT.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

T minus 4 days till the Robey haters have a meltdown. They know who they are

 

[THE THIN MAN]

I fear we are in grave danger

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Robey haters have a meltdown. They know who they are

 

[OneEyedRichmond]

Cummings is a lock

 

[guruisatiger]

lol

Essendon pick 21 and 27 for Carlton pick 9 ?
Pick 9= 1355 points
Pick 21+27= 1254 points
Surely Essendon pick 30 also needs to be included

 

[THE_GUN]

Essendon pick 21 and 27 for Carlton pick 9 ?
Pick 9= 1355 points
Pick 21+27= 1254 points
Surely Essendon pick 30 also needs to be included

has to be more to it

why would Carlton trade for that

 

[RichmondEshays]

We need Sullivan Robey and Xavier Taylor. Sharp is too slow got bullied in the sanfl.

 

[Mr Magic]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

don't ask me, I have no idea what the club is thinking. Do you think others do? probably not

Some could most likely, shoot the breeze

consensus would suggest CDT, but there is enough content on the web to get this impression based on supposed ratings/mocks blah blah, is this what the club is thinking? no idea

 

[Mr Magic]

has to be more to it

why would Carlton trade for that

if they are using it for points, which is expected(otherwise why trade at all?), in terms of matching of course they are keeping it because they have more points regardless of position.

the only reason they would go back for less points would be if they wanted two players instead of one from the same pick which we think is not the case in this situation


if they wanted two instead of one they would not be matching for Dean as that defeats the purpose of needing extra picks for another player and they have 11 as well which would have to be traded otherwise why trade 9?

 

[tigerdan]

I come in peace etc

I’m a fan of Robey, to the point where I’m probably 50/50 between him and CDT at pick 2. The majority of the WC board have had a bizarre obsession with Sharp, even wanting him at pick 2, while Robey has barely rated a mention. Most have now conceded it will be CDT and have come around to the idea. I think it’s 80/20 in his favour on the night.

But I'm curious, who would you prefer out of Robey and CDT? One will be available, who do you hope it is?

Robey has been strongly linked to the Tigers, but I’m not sure if that’s just because CDT is assumed to be gone by picks 3 & 4.

The WC midfield is woeful while our KPF stocks are not bad (thinking CDT starts mostly forward until he puts on some ruck size). So on a needs basis we badly need mids and Robey fits the bill. But CDT is the likely selection, he has some unique athletic traits for his size and could potentially be anything.

12 months ago, CDT. Talls had been missing from our draft strategy and we were crying out for them.

But then we went and drafted a bunch of talls.

Robey works for me.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Robey, XT and Dovaston all going to the Druggies.

 

[Jozzy]

Cummings is a lock

Are these also you mate?

 

[4tune8]

has to be more to it

why would Carlton trade for that

Pick 9 will drop to 13 after bid matches =1080pts, not sure if the others will move much.