List Mgmt. 2025 Premiership(s) List Making and Trading

[Mostyn]

Well, you'd trade any of them if it was a 1:1 swap. Saint's wouldn't do that though.

But I thought the proposition was one of those guys + first round picks and other stuff, in which case, it's a no from me.

My issue with Soligo and a first for NWM is not that it isn't a good deal - it's more that Soli seems to be a really valuable part of team chemistry and how the younger players connect with one another.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

My issue with Soligo and a first for NWM is not that it isn't a good deal - it's more that Soli seems to be a really valuable part of team chemistry and how the younger players connect with one another.

Sean Wellman probably was too

 

[latinoheat]

On the topic of NWM ... noticed this interaction (or lack of) in the lead up to the Hawks game.

Watch Hunter Clarke (#11) and NWM:

View attachment 2364790

Definitely something there, right?

Oooh good call!

He’s port bound, nothing surer

 

[George CantStandYa]

Are you really coming at me with this shit?

I've made my opinion on the Butts vs Borlase discussion very well known for years!!!

Apologies. I saw the M and thought it was Mostyn as he had been posting.

Whilst you’re here FR0GGY wants to know what you think ROB will be like in 3 years

 

[hugecannon]

Oof, there is obvious "Ah it's you, no thanks" vibes to that

We should start some Clark to Port rumours!!

 

[George CantStandYa]

On the topic of NWM ... noticed this interaction (or lack of) in the lead up to the Hawks game.

Watch Hunter Clarke (#11) and NWM:

View attachment 2364790

Definitely something there, right?

Mate, going to call you Columbo

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Oof, there is obvious "Ah it's you, no thanks" vibes to that

Maybe they'd already done their stupid hug thing and just didn't double up

 

[George CantStandYa]

I just don't get the bad vibes on Borlase. Almost every time he has come in, he has been ok and done his job. I like him as a player ad i'd trust him to play FB or CHB for us. Maybe the only real knock is his height as he is shorter than the others, but he can play.

I don’t mind Borlase as depth, but Butts is by far the better player and no way should Borlase have played ahead of Butts.

Playing Butts has allowed Keane to flourish to what he’s suited now he no longer is taking the oppositions best forward.

I had to argue that point with some at the time, no hindsight bullshit.

 

[Mutineer]

Apologies. I saw the M and thought it was Mostyn as he had been posting.

Whilst you’re here FR0GGY wants to know what you think ROB will be like in 3 years

Given ROB's professionalism with his training and preparation along with his outstanding durability to this point every chance he doesn't fall off a cliff I would think. Happy now?

 

[George CantStandYa]

Given ROB's professionalism with his training and preparation along with his outstanding durability to this point every chance he doesn't fall off a cliff I would think. Happy now?

Happy you’ve given an opinion, yes.

Given the lack of consistency in his performance over recent years, you’re not worried he’s playing his best footy in years in his contract year and he won’t resort to his comfortable complacent norm?

 

[skam85]

Happy you’ve given an opinion, yes.

Given the lack of consistency in his performance over recent years, you’re not worried he’s playing his best footy in years in his contract year and he won’t resort to his comfortable complacent norm?

I'm hopeful but not optimistic

 

[skam85]

yes I know I'm not Mutineer - he has a few years on me

 

[Mutineer]

Happy you’ve given an opinion, yes.

Given the lack of consistency in his performance over recent years, you’re not worried he’s playing his best footy in years in his contract year and he won’t resort to his comfortable complacent norm?

I'm really starting to wonder why I took you off of ignore.

 

[FR0GGY]

Given ROB's professionalism with his training and preparation along with his outstanding durability to this point every chance he doesn't fall off a cliff I would think. Happy now?

How does he get the answer to my statement

 

[Mutineer]

How does he get the answer to my statement

Because he's more annoying but you're heading that way in leaps and bounds.

 

[skam85]

How does he get the answer to my statement

George just knows how to find the spot

 

[skam85]

you're heading that way in leaps and bounds.

I see what you did there

 

[FR0GGY]

Because he's more annoying but you're heading that way in leaps and bounds.

Right so you acknowledge that you actually gave the answer to George that relates to what I said yesterday?
Yet I’m the dick?
You could have written that yesterday instead of going on a tangent with Marshall.

 

[spenze]

Right so you acknowledge that you actually gave the answer to George that relates to what I said yesterday?
Yet I’m the dick?
You could have written that yesterday instead of going on a tangent with Marshall.

Talking about Marshall, that guy's injury plagued.

Missed 2 matches in 4 years, I prefer my first choice ruckmaan to be missing games for inconsistent effort

 

[George CantStandYa]

I'm really starting to wonder why I took you off of ignore.

That’s harsh. It’s a football forum. You dance around giving an opinion, case in point yesterday.

Today you finally give your opinion, I offer an opposing view and you’re considering putting me on ignore again?

By the way that’s no skin off my nose but you really need to consider the purpose of the forum, provide opinions, discuss your opinions. It’s more than just somewhere to put up club and player socials.

 

[WeeBlake]

I just don't get the bad vibes on Borlase. Almost every time he has come in, he has been ok and done his job. I like him as a player ad i'd trust him to play FB or CHB for us. Maybe the only real knock is his height as he is shorter than the others, but he can play.

Agree, he’s reliable, cheap depth

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Would you be prepared to part with any of these young Vics as part of a trade for NWM?

Jake Soligo
Josh Rachele
Josh Worrell
Nick Murray

Murray only

 

[baldandbroke]

Maybe they'd already done their stupid hug thing and just didn't double up

I thought that too - but they clearly miss one and then continue on "connecting" with other players.

No biggy - lots of players I'm sure don't get along in a team (McLeod and Edwards anyone?) ... but it takes a proper rift to not go through the motions of this pre-match bonding exercise and just not mean it

 

[Mutineer]

Happy you’ve given an opinion, yes.

Given the lack of consistency in his performance over recent years, you’re not worried he’s playing his best footy in years in his contract year and he won’t resort to his comfortable complacent norm?

 

[George CantStandYa]

Spam

How about actually answer the context of the post.