- Joined
- Jul 5, 2013
- Posts
- 10,933
- Reaction score
- 20,227
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Since it's the bye will put Young on the bench for now. Re-assess next week what to do.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Will have they ease Rankine in though? Not sure they’ll just throw him peak cba’s straight away.Thoughts on Gulden to Rankine?
Rankine only in 1.5% of teams... If he wasn't suspended I believe would have been in between 20-30% to start
Don’t see why not.. he hasn’t been injured, and assuming he has been full training?All they ease Rankine in though? Not sure they’ll just throw him peak cba’s straight away.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
No no you're supposed to make the decision for me so I don't have to blame myself when it doesn't work out!either or...go with your gut
I'm thinking Gulden to either Jackson or Xerri - who would everyone go with there? Jackson seems more reliable but Xerri's fixture is very tempting.
Good points. I think the reliability thing is just me being nervous about him getting suspended like last year but you're right that he's got a much longer history than that.Both guns obviously. Not sure what makes you think Jackson is more reliable?
Xerri has averaged 120+ for 2 seasons straight prior to this year (127 last season). He will play as No 1/sole ruck all year.
Jackson is a great player and has more avenues to score but scores much better when he is sole ruck and Sean Darcy (even Mason Cox when Darcy is injured) may not see him consistently get the scores he got last year as the sole man. He averaged 113 and never over 100 prior. He's now effectively playing midfield though.
Essentially, you have a sure thing in Xerri but who is priced accordingly. You have a slightly bigger risk as Jackson plays midfield/hybrid role consistently for the first time but is a bit cheaper. The new rules will effect him less.
My preference is a no risk approach in the rucks as there is so little flexibility/options on that line but you can't really go wrong with either choice IMO.
I'm thinking Gulden to either Jackson or Xerri - who would everyone go with there? Jackson seems more reliable but Xerri's fixture is very tempting.
What do you think Fonti avg from here?Probably Young > Fonti. Fonti looks decent, will make cash & firms up my defence a bit which is nice. Leaves me $348.4k in the bank too which is lovely. Windsor > Houston a decent shout next round if Windsor doesnt do great.
Yes thats exactly my intentionNice team. Probably better to wait until after St Kilda's bye to get NWM. And possibly wait until his form turns.
Nice, sounds like a good plan.Yes thats exactly my intention
I will look at his BE and when it gets to an acceptable level i will trade him into my team as i see NAS in my best team and if he gets DP then he is a must have.
Sellwood to Houston
and maybe Pou to Cook are the trades im looking at next week with perhaps a boost to get a premo for an under performing mid pricer
I have more trades than BOMBERBLITZ2 trades already down the drain, but at least I don't have to death-ride THE BONT anymore!
View attachment 2555283
Like everyone, I also need to trade Gulden. Already have Serong and can't afford Bont.
Thinking:
A: Anderson @ $620K - Gun in a good side. Set and forget. Doesn't miss games. Has some yo-yo scores though and is 'peak price'.
B: Holmes @ 600K - Best mid in a competitive side. 23 years old. Average has gone up a jump every year. 66-80-99-111. Could it rise further? Will Geelong remain competitive or Holmes get more attention?
C: Sicily @ 483K - May seem a bit left field but it's a 'buy low' approach, with his price set to go up whilst the other two will remain at that 600K mark and can be future upgrades. Thinking on Sicily is he is priced at an 89 average after an injury affected season last year, including a 37 when he did his shoulder. Prior to that, his averages were 113, 114 and 99 and looks back to his old self this season after 2 good games/scores (pretty common for him to miss a couple of games through a suspension or niggle)
D: Edit, I suppose Merrett @ 583K is also a good option. Priced at a 108 average but has gone between 112-116 for 6 years straight prior to last year! Super consistent scorer. My only worry in not picking him is Brad Scott put him back and forward last year and he only excels in the middle. Do we have any word on if he will be moved around again? Given they want to sign him up again/want him to stay, will they let him play midfield all season as they should?
What would you do?
Anderson feels like a very safe pick this year but he does have a bye next week. I’d throw Callaghan in the mid as well but same bye issue.Like everyone, I also need to trade Gulden. Already have Serong and can't afford Bont.
Thinking:
A: Anderson @ $620K - Gun in a good side. Set and forget. Doesn't miss games. Has some yo-yo scores though and is 'peak price'.
B: Holmes @ 600K - Best mid in a competitive side. 23 years old. Average has gone up a jump every year. 66-80-99-111. Could it rise further? Will Geelong remain competitive or Holmes get more attention?
C: Sicily @ 483K - May seem a bit left field but it's a 'buy low' approach, with his price set to go up whilst the other two will remain at that 600K mark and can be future upgrades. Thinking on Sicily is he is priced at an 89 average after an injury affected season last year, including a 37 when he did his shoulder. Prior to that, his averages were 113, 114 and 99 and looks back to his old self this season after 2 good games/scores (pretty common for him to miss a couple of games through a suspension or niggle)
D: Edit, I suppose Merrett @ 583K is also a good option. Priced at a 108 average but has gone between 112-116 for 6 years straight prior to last year! Super consistent scorer. My only worry in not picking him is Brad Scott put him back and forward last year and he only excels in the middle. Do we have any word on if he will be moved around again? Given they want to sign him up again/want him to stay, will they let him play midfield all season as they should?
What would you do?
85 ish. Not enough to be a keeper but will likely make substantial cash. I’m happy to jump on.What do you think Fonti avg from here?