- Jul 13, 2012
- 44,122
- 21,991
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Charlotte Hornets, Chelsea, Striker
- Remove the requirement for a Player to start in the Goal Square at each centre ball-up - GOOD
- Introduce a Free Kick for the last disposal Out of Bounds in between the 50m arcs - QUESTION MARK
- At all centre ball-ups, a competing Ruck cannot cross the Centre Circle line and engage with the opposition Ruck, prior to contesting the football - GOOD
- Around the ground, the Umpire may restart play without a nominated Ruck being present - GOOD
- A shrug (in a tackle) will be deemed Prior Opportunity (i.e., as an attempt to evade or fend an opponent) - GOOD
- A Player must stand if they are within the Protected Area (i.e., within five metres) when a Mark or Free Kick occurs - BAD
- Align the interpretation of ‘reasonable time’ for a Player to bring the football back into play from a Behind being scored and the time allowed for a set Kick around the ground. Currently, reasonable time for kick-ins is 12 seconds, whereas around the ground is eight (8) seconds. Players will now be allowed eight (8) seconds in both instances - GOOD
Overall I think they're mostly improvements. I'll hold judgement on the last possession rule. Works well in SANFL but feel like its just a different interpretation problem than the one we already had with insufficient intent (ie if it touches someone's leg on the way out it sometimes counts and sometimes doesnt).
Ill add - Getting rid of the centre bounce - GOOD - Taking away barriers to entry to umpiring is important if we want the best decision makers and that is what the umpires are there for.
Just my opinion.




