AA side

[demon21]

What do other melb supportes think of the AA side was it just me or was we ripped. Brown had to be a shoe in and Yze, Bruce they had to be very close. It just seems that our players are underated by everyone. It took Yze a while to make his first AA selection but people like C.Johnson make it with out doing much.well at least White made it.

 

[leonmagic]

It just seems that our players are underated by everyone.

Is it possible that you all overrate them?

Serious question.

 

[Supermercado]

You could make a case for Brown or Yze but they definately weren't criminal omissions from the side.

 

[StingaArmstrong]

I would have thought Brown in place of Lappin was a reasonable start, but other than that they got it pretty close. Its hard to fit everyone in.

 

[DemonDoob]

Don't be stupid peoplez. Brown didn't deserve to get in the side. He has done well in some games, but with players such as Yze, and Green running it off half back flank, its not hard to see why brown found space. Yze had some good games, but i think his on field leadership skills may be lacking. for instance his tackling and hard ball gets could incline.

 

[demon21]

orginally posted by leon magic
Is it possible that you all overrate them?

Serious question.

No I don't overate our players i know stats aren't everythink but Brown AVG 20 touches and players like Barry 13, C.Johnson,15,Clement 14, so Brown did deserve to make it.

 

[BT]

orginally posted by leon magic
Is it possible that you all overrate them?

Serious question.

No I don't overate our players i know stats aren't everythink but Brown AVG 20 touches and players like Barry 13, C.Johnson,15,Clement 14, so Brown did deserve to make it.

Good point, your move Leon!

 

[Supermercado]

Bit ironic a Collingwood fan talking about people overrating their players. Probably thinks Matthew Lokan should have won the Brownlow.

 

[melbournemartin]

nathan brown definatly deserved a spot
green and yze and bruce wernt consistant enough 2 definatly have a spot but yze was close
white ofcourse was easily number 1 ruckman so he earned his spot