AFC board draft game 2010

[Mego Red]

IMO

Too High

Mitch Clark, Tippett, Roughead, Koschitzke, Montagna, Dangerfield

Too Low

Rutten, Rioli, Bradshaw

Thats just my opinion though, you should be happy to back yourself if you picked one of the players I had as too high

Wait - Leigh Montagna, who was one of the favorites for the Brownlow and was in Sheehan and many other's top ten lists?

But fair enough - all opinion. I wouldn't have Rutts in the AFL top 50. Probably top 100. He wouldn't be a top five full back for me any more. And I'm in two minds about Bradshaw. Worried about his age now.

 

[WALL-e]

Consider Rutten with my last.

On Koschitzke... had to pull the trigger on a solid forward who can provide good ruck back up.

 

[Alex99]

FF: XXXXX ~ Tippett ~ XXXXX
HF: XXXXX ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
C: XXXXX ~ Porplyzia ~ Boak
HB: XXXXX ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
FB: XXXXX ~ Scarlett ~ XXXXX
Ruck: XXXXX ~ Kerr ~ XXXXX


My squad so far.

Pick 64 –Travis Boak

i think he is ready to have a massive breakout year in 2010, add him to the experienced pair of Kerr and Porplyzia and my midfield is coming along nicely.

Cannot believe he lasted this long. Even tho he plays for the Power, he will be a future star.

 

[cammo84]

#65: Chris Knights - He was THE in-form small/medium forward for a chunk of last season and he adds some genuine goal scoring ability to my forward line. He also gives me an extra midfield option.

#66: John Anthony - He's one of the better young key forwards going around and I think he's capable of 50+ goals in 2010.


Cammo's team so far: Bock, Roughead, Burgoyne, Kreuzer, Knights, Anthony

 

[ringo200]

Wait - Leigh Montagna, who was one of the favorites for the Brownlow and was in Sheehan and many other's top ten lists?

But fair enough - all opinion. I wouldn't have Rutts in the AFL top 50. Probably top 100. He wouldn't be a top five full back for me any more. And I'm in two minds about Bradshaw. Worried about his age now.

Yeah but he has only really stepped up this year. If he backs it up then he is worth that pick, although personally I think Dal Santo was a better option but as you said it is all opinion. I think a lot St. Kilda players have been overrated after the year they had and right now is the highest that a lot of those players will ever be rated in their career if that makes sense.

 

[Alex99]

FF: XXXXX ~ Tippett ~ XXXXX
HF: XXXXX ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
C: XXXXX ~ Porplyzia ~ Boak
HB: Mackie ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
FB: XXXXX ~ Scarlett ~ XXXXX
Ruck: XXXXX ~ Kerr ~ XXXXX


Pick 66

All Australian Half back flakers in who can move across into the key position of centre half back, at pick 66 this is a bargain selection

I select Andrew Mackie

 

[BACCS]

FF: XXXXX ~ Tippett ~ XXXXX
HF: XXXXX ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
C: XXXXX ~ Porplyzia ~ Boak
HB: Mackie ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
FB: XXXXX ~ Scarlett ~ XXXXX
Ruck: XXXXX ~ Kerr ~ XXXXX


Pick 66

All Australian Half back flakers in who can move across into the key position of centre half back, at pick 66 this is a bargain selection

I select Andrew Mackie

Shit, my plan B better not go.

 

[crowsarethebest]

Argh, lots of players I wanted with my next 2 picks have been taken. There's still one or two very very underrated players still available though. I need a few KPP backman now, they're drying up fast.

 

[KUNG FU]

SAM GILBERT


LORD 194cm AA squad 23yo gun utility CHB or flanker

 

[Riggy1]

I know I took Dangerfield high but I do consider him one of the 3 premier inside mids in the league (well, by the end of 2010), and with Judd already taken it was him or Watson. I thought I would be nice and leave the Bomber for Collin D'Cops.

 

[Mego Red]

There are All-Australian inside mids still on the board ...

 

[Mego Red]

FF: XXXXX ~ Tippett ~ XXXXX
HF: XXXXX ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
C: XXXXX ~ Porplyzia ~ Boak
HB: Mackie ~ XXXXX ~ XXXXX
FB: XXXXX ~ Scarlett ~ XXXXX
Ruck: XXXXX ~ Kerr ~ XXXXX


Pick 66

All Australian Half back flakers in who can move across into the key position of centre half back, at pick 66 this is a bargain selection

I select Andrew Mackie

I love this pick - but do you think Porps can actually play as a midfielder for you?

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Need a defensive rock...can't really go past him...

Simon Prestigiacomo

 

[BACCS]

There are All-Australian inside mids still on the board ...

I seriously hope we aren't thinking the same player mate! Your pick is before mine.

 

[BACCS]

I know I took Dangerfield high but I do consider him one of the 3 premier inside mids in the league (well, by the end of 2010), and with Judd already taken it was him or Watson. I thought I would be nice and leave the Bomber for Collin D'Cops.

There are a lot more inside premier midfielders outside of these 3, and besides Judd, I rate them ahead of them other two by a fair way.

 

[crowsarethebest]

There are still 2/3 elite midfielders that still haven't been picked...

 

[ringo200]

Pick 70 - Aaron Davey

Outside midfielder with precision kicking and blistering speed. Would be a much better player in a better team.

 

[Colin D'Cops]

Have looked through the entire thread, and haven't found C.Cornes taken which has surprised me. If I have missed someone that has taken him, I apologise. But if it's all good, sweet. I pick Chad Cornes (PTA). Might chuck him at CHF with his big dukes and vertical leap. No stranger to hurting the opposition on the scoreboard.

Colin D'Cops: Dean Cox, Brendon Fevola, Darren Glass, Joel Corey, Jarrad Waite, Chad Cornes.

B: - D. Glass -
HB: - J. Waite -
C: - J. Corey -
HF: - C. Cornes -
F: - B. Fevola -
R: D. Cox -
I/C:

 

[Mego Red]

Colin D'Cops: Dean Cox, Brendon Fevola, Darren Glass, Joel Corey, Jarrad Waite, Chad Cornes.

B: - D. Glass -
HB: - J. Waite -
C: - J. Corey -
HF: - C. Cornes -
F: - B. Fevola -
R: D. Cox -
I/C:

Welcome to the Crows board; most here would focus optimistically on Chadley's mediocre '09. Great pick - you're probably the front runner at the moment.

 

[BACCS]

Welcome to the Crows board; most here would focus optimistically on Chadley's mediocre '09. Great pick - you're probably the front runner at the moment.

Was my plan B after Mackie went, ****.

 

[WALL-e]

I must say watching all your desired players go after you pick.... good comp this year.

 

[ams4crows]

Mathew Boyd (WB)

 

[BACCS]

Mathew Boyd (WB)

Shit! My two top ranked midfielders in Davey and Boyd, gone.

 

[WALL-e]

Boyd's a quality pick, great worker.

 

[Mego Red]

Mathew Boyd (WB)

There he is. Good pick - top ten midfielder.