Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 9 - Blues v Demons Thurs May 9th 7:30pm AEST (MCG)
- Thread starter Wosh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Jul 16, 2013
- 13,757
- 17,706
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Fine them both.
melbourne our snowbunnies
wish we could play them more often
wish we could play them more often
Check out Professor Cake here.
We were 20 points up at the time. Let's assume they got the goal, it goes straight back to the middle. Who is to say Carlton won't win the clearance and kick a goal from it? You are assuming that all the events that happened after that point will happen exactly the same in the alternate universe where Melbourne kick a goal.
Much like your assumptions of branched timelines, the cake always crumbles.
Geelong beat Carlton
Melbourne beat Geelong
Carlton beat Melbourne
Yeah the formlines all coming together
Nah, you seem right at homeCarlton boys, time to universally declare this for what it is.
Arr0w come on I know you enjoy calling out a pathetic whinge.
Is Danster the new Plugger?
Nah, too inaccurate.
It was clearly wrong and it's 2 weeks in a row a Carlton player has milked a free like this.
Having said that the post game carry on from fans and media over 1 free or non free is getting boring. Rvery week it's the same now.
Unless it's the last kick of the game it's irrelevant to the result.
Having said that the post game carry on from fans and media over 1 free or non free is getting boring. Rvery week it's the same now.
Unless it's the last kick of the game it's irrelevant to the result.
Yeah as a Brisbane supporter I've seen us going into their shells and getting run down a few times in recent years, especially against Melbourne.
Like you mentioned Gawn is a big part of it. Apart from his dominance in the ruck, he's one of the best at putting himself in the perfect position to mark those hack clearances out of D50.
Once it goes back into the middle after a goal, the 6-6-6 rule brings their midfield back into play. Luckily for Carlton and the other teams at the moment, Oliver isn't at his best.
We saw that Melbourne were clearly outplaying Carlton in that time, so much so that they were scoring unanswered even when it was brought to the middle. Thereby, going on probabilities, it is more likely that the pattern would've continued, especially if it were following the momentum of a goal as opposed to the deflating nature of a disallowed one. We saw that Melbourne were tearing Carlton up each time it went to the 6-6-6 set up and it aided Melbourne in that the Carlton defence was less congested.
As for "crumbles", is that what happened to you when you got cocky in questioning my knowledge over my post about Melbourne not being that good in mid-2022 when they were on a 10-game winning streak? And then being proven wrong on them after they went out in straight sets two years in a row and on Carlton when they missed the finals in 2022 entirely after you were adamant they were going to make it? You'd think for someone who was directly schooled by me on two teams when you really thought you had something would be a little more humble. You were quiet as a mouse. Certainly didn't have anything to say then.
Like I said then, and I say now, it's all proven in hindsight.
"Your analysis means nothing."
Last edited:
I am impressed at his stamina. In the end the dees are our bunnies.Carlton boys, time to universally declare this for what it is.
Arr0w come on I know you enjoy calling out a pathetic whinge.
3 losses in a row danster. were the umps corrupt in the previous games too?
File it wherever you like
What is commonsense to some requires an advanced physics course for others. And even then, I doubt the reality of one event changing every single one after would be comprehensible.
It is one of the simplest ways to identify remaining the few remaining Homo Erectus creatures from the Home Sapien lineage.
I'm filing you under: related to Danster. Unwilling to change position based on pre-existing inaccurate and falsified claims. It is extremely undesirable to be grouped with such a specimen but I am an advocate for free will.
Your claims that I only target Carlton supporting whingers, meanwhile? It's starting to look a little false.
The way David King was talking this morning you would think it was the greatest Carlton performance of all time. It was far from that, in fact the scoreline was 11 - 10 to 7 - 5 after QTR time and they hung on by a point! It was definitely the Petracca show, the Dees were sluggish early after the 5 day break and did well to comeback, the Blues have more problems than some scribes are prepared to admit.
- Mar 16, 2024
- 194
- 172
- AFL Club
- Carlton
True - it wasn't perfect , having some of our players back helped. But still missing six of our preferred starting line-up. These guys need to play as much football together as possible not spectating from the stands.
ESKIE
Keeping it Cool.
- Feb 28, 2009
- 32,136
- 54,314
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Go Blues 
Elixuh
See you on the 9th green at 9
We got so far ahead of you our players got bored and didn’t want to play anymore. Carlton’s inept gameplan took away our will to go on.
Seems like a few clubs you have played have a similar plan
- Jun 12, 2018
- 4,429
- 8,433
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
‘Fine the fakes’: Calls for punishment as debate erupts over dubious free kick awarded to Blues defender
‘Fine the fakes’: Calls for punishment as debate erupts over ‘disgraceful’ free kick
www.foxsports.com.au
Two games for the umps
Geez it would be nice
Similar threads
- Poll
