Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion AFL 2025 Round 3 - Weekend Wrap & Liked, Learnt, Hated

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zevon
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Posts
16,474
Reaction score
44,070
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Royals FC, West Indies
A round that saw some teams continue on an upward curve and some continue to nosedive. Let’s tie a bow around Round 3…

Bombers v Port, Thursday night: Bumper clash for a Thursday night, am I right?? An uninspiring Essendon against a flat Port Adelaide. Do yourself a favour and don’t bother watching this one on replay. The Dons had to chalk up a win eventually, even though some of their own supporters were laughing at you if you dared suggest they’d get home in this one. Reckon it would be rough supporting either of these clubs at the moment.

Blues v Dogs, Friday night: It was a case of old meets new for the Bulldogs as the veteran Libba and the rookie Davidson put on a show. Yet another game where the Blues were in it up to their eyeballs for a decent chunk but couldn’t make it count when it mattered. 0-3 now and playing a game style that is fully deserving of that record. Yikes.

Demons v Suns, Saturday arvo: If you’re new to AFL I apologise for getting too technical here: Melbourne suck. The senior players seem to have a care factor of precisely zero. The coach and football department need a clean out. Christian Petracca spent the whole game looking like he wished he was playing for literally any other team on the planet. But you know what, let’s make it about Gold Coast. That’s two massive away wins now, the latest against a side that had beaten them 12 times in a row going in. If you wanted any evidence of improvement from the 2024 Suns to the 2025 Suns, that’s it right there. I’m going early - they’re finals bound.


1743329466330.jpeg

Saints v Tigers, Saturday twilight: The worrying thing here is that there were times when the Tigers were clearly trying to slow things down and hold on to the ball, and yet they still lost control and got blown away. It’s starting to look like those pre season predictions about thumpings each week might come true after all; the Carlton game in round 1 was just an outlier. The Saints on the other hand did what they had to. Great result to be able to put a team to the sword when you’re nursing a long injury list and then your captain pulls out before the bounce.

Lions v Cats, Saturday night: The Cats were up against it when old mate Tom Stewart was a late scratching at the barriers, although knowing Geelong’s love of a late-withdrawal it wouldn’t surprise me if they knew he wasn’t playing all the way back on Monday. In any case, it didn’t trouble them early as they jumped the home side and looked well on the way to an upset win. The Lions always seem to have another level hidden away though, and when it was activated they came back and snuck over the line. Ominous.

Hawks v Giants, Saturday night: The faint Tassie breeze blowing towards one end of the ground made this a fascinating contest, especially in the first half when it turned out it was actually more of a howling gale. The Giants set up a big lead in the first quarter - partly wind-assisted, partly because the Hawks hadn’t quite found their feet yet - but everything changed in the second term. A dubious mark and goal to Weddle sparked a Hawthorn avalanche that the Giants looked incapable of stopping until a mini-revival late in the game. A really enjoyable tactical contest despite the conditions, and it’s a shame these sides don’t get another crack at each other before finals.


1743329590740.jpeg

Crows v North, Sunday arvo: I hate being one of those “plenty of positives!!” people, but there were plenty of positives for both sides in this one. For the Crows it was a professional performance, drawing away in the last quarter or two for a good win over an improving opponent. For the Roos it was a lively display, sticking with a very good team away from home for long periods of the game. Every chance they’d have lost this sort of assignment by 10+ goals in recent years. Trending upwards.

Eagles v Dockers, Sunday arvo: Wonder if a big win over a bitter hometown rival will prove to be just the spark the Dockers needed to ignite their season. They looked pretty good in the patches of this game I saw, albeit against a side that’s a fair way behind them in terms of development. A home game against the Doggies next week might tell us more, and they’ve got a couple of soft matchups after that. The Eagles fired off their best shot but never really threatened after a bright start. Big challenge against the Giants on the rebound next week.

Don’t forget to post your Liked, Learnt, Hated below… along with any other thoughts you had about Round 3!
 
Liked: The continued silence from my bluebagger relatives. Gave it large when they beat us by 10 goals last season. Barely a peep since.

Learnt: That the flag we won a couple years back has made me so much more mellow about footy. My own team and everyone else.

Adelaide's strong start has been good to watch. As has NM being more competitive and GCS finally looking like they can have a good season.

Hated: The AFL and their insistence on result over action. Mansell will get weeks for something that Luke McDonald will not because the outcome wasn't an injury.

P.S. Learnt doesn't apply to hokball. **** them, always.
 
Liked the win, and not having to watch the AFL franchise play as they had a bye.

Learnt that Christian is going to look like a huge hypocrit when he continues to ignore the staging from Daicos and the others that do it week after week.

Hated Lindsay going down.
 
Liked - The start of an 8 Game winning streak for Freo, Cats losing
Learnt - Bottom 4 will be Richmond, Carlton, Melbourne and West Coast
Hated - Crows 3-0, Dees yet to hit the mark in 2025.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

also was surprised to learn we're fielding a team atm with similar age, games experience and experience breakdown as that of NM. And were less experienced than the 'young hawks'.

Quite a surprise given the '22 GF side was the oldest in history.
 
also was surprised to learn we're fielding a team atm with similar age, games experience and experience breakdown as that of NM. And were less experienced than the 'young hawks'.

Quite a surprise given the '22 GF side was the oldest in history.

Our experience and age drops massively when Dear comes in for Gunston and McDonald returns and Breust is out.
 
Liked- Fagan adaptability and his sides to change the game style, I didn’t like the result but I was impressed.

Learnt- Gold Coast look a gear quicker this year.

Hated- The suspension all the Richmond player was trying to do was create separation between him and his opponent for when it became a ground ball.
 
Liked - Isaiah Dudley looking like a young Willie Rioli on debut
Learnt - Murphy Reid might be the most skilful and composed young player Freo has ever drafted
Hated - Derby’s have lost a lot of the colour and passion they used to have , probably no wonder when both clubs try and push the ‘just another game’ line …. why say shit like that ? Would it really kill them to fire things up with a bit of banter beforehand?
 
Learnt that the Dees window is well and truly shut (2023 was our best opportunity).

Liked that Lindsay’s injury not a serious knee.

Hated the 15m rule. Do they seriously think we all can’t see it when a defensive kick over 30m is called play on, yet a 10m kick in the forward line is paid? Typical AFL treating fans like mugs.
 
Liked: Not much

Learnt: Geelong are not good enough this year and my early call is they won't make the 8. Suns and Crows will definitely make the 8. So there really is only two spaces left open as i have Hawks. Lions, Giants and Pies making finals with Crows and Suns almost set. That leaves a battle for 7th and 8th among the rest.

Hated: Knowing Geelong will be battling all year, Mansell report and gets 3 weeks.
 
Liked : The Hawks fight, and a number of players stepping up in others' absence.
Learnt : Eagles taking our 1st rounder instead of Carlton's is causing a lot of angst for Eagles fans.
Hated : The fixturing of two games on Saturday night and then a game late Sunday night. Shithouse.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Liked: Our 3rd quarter against GWS kicking against cyclone tracey 2.0

Learnt: Can't see us saluting in September with Chol at FF.

Hated: Melbourne...absolute coach killings performance....
 
Liked: The young talent on display in Crows vs North. Quality Football.
Hated: The number of players who weren't in the contest rushng in to be "tough" after the event. Ginnivan's cowardly kidney punch on a GWS player who was beaten in a marking contest and was walking away. AFL needs to stamp down on it.

Learnt: Melbourne and Carlton's seasons are already in crisis mode.
 
Hated - Derby’s have lost a lot of the colour and passion they used to have , probably no wonder when both clubs try and push the ‘just another game’ line …. why say shit like that ? Would it really kill them to fire things up with a bit of banter beforehand?
It feels like a long time since both WA teams have been good at the same time. Probably more that than anything
 
It feels like a long time since both WA teams have been good at the same time. Probably more that than anything
To be fair, it's been ages since both SA teams were good at the same time and the Showdown still remains the most spiteful rivalry going around.
 
Liked:
Crows going 3-0. Dawson had a quiet game, but Peatling stood up and showed why we targeted him. Great to actually have decent midfield depth now.
North providing us a good contest and should finish in the upper half of the bottom 10. They just need a bit more polish.

Learnt:
Early in the season, sure, but Melbourne are in big strife. A big reset/rebuild is needed.

Hated:
Rachele's broken ribs that will see him out for a month and a bit, he was in ripping form to start the season too
Same as last week, the inconsistent interpretation of the 15m rule
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Liked - Saints swamp El Tigre

G Coast
Dr Davidson
Bris Lions v Geel - good game
Sinclair
Rowell
TDK

Disliked - GWS Giants losing
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom