Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion AFL 2025 Round 5 - Weekend Wrap & Liked, Learnt, Hated

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zevon
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Posts
16,504
Reaction score
44,120
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Royals FC, West Indies
Bravo to all involved for putting on another South Australia Round Gather Round. Apologies most of the visiting teams insulted your hospitality with some poor displays of Australian Rules football. Sigh. Let’s wrap it up…

Crows v Cats, Thursday night: Big admirer of the Crows, but they do seem a little easy to score against. The Cats piled on the goals late in the first half and again late in the second to come away with a fine win away from home. Proving the doubters wrong for the umpteenth time.

Pies v Swans, Friday night: I know you visit the Weekend Wrap for my astute football analysis, so it pains me to say I was wrong about the Pies. They’re considerably better than I thought and they could have won this by even more than they did. Despite a couple of brief purple patches you never got the sense the Swans were in the game. Midfielder Ned Long - surely not his real name?! - tore them to shreds all night.


1744535049881.jpeg

North v Suns, Saturday arvo: Did North spend the night before the game indulging in the local Barossa product or something? This can’t be the same side that won by 10 goals a few weeks ago. They’ve gone back to looking like they wouldn’t beat the Horsham reserves. Maybe I’m selling the Suns short though - they’re a ruthless winning machine this year. Who thought we’d ever say that??

Blues v Eagles, Saturday arvo: Congratulations Carlton. Now do that against something other than a WAFL side and we might be impressed. Don’t bother, we probably won’t actually.

Dogs v Brisbane, Saturday twilight: The Brisbane bus driver couldn’t find Norwood Oval so the Lions had given away a near-seven goal head start when they turned up to play. Lucky for them they’ve got an unfairly good higher gear when they need it. After a lazy 10 goal turnaround they’d won with room to spare. Too good.

Dees v Bombers, Saturday night: Did somebody actually sit through this from start to finish? Do us a favour and post the final score in the comments. I feel sorry for the big Adelaide crowd that turned up hoping to see a football match. They enjoyed an expensive slumber party instead.


1744535166733.jpeg

Tigers v Freo, Sunday arvo: Yeah another pulsating game. Thrilling football. The highlight was Treacy kicking 6 goals. Yes you read that right, the highlight was Josh Treacy. Says it all.

Saints v Giants, Sunday twilight: The Saints actually won the inside 50 count in this one. Comfortably. Yet they lost the game. Comfortably. The Giants defence was just far too good, and their attack led by Toby Greene made it look like they were going to score every time they had the ball. Gun footy side and they still play a brand that is very easy on the eye.


Port v Hawks, Sunday night: This can be the problem with early season byes… they completely halt momentum. The high flying Hawks copped a touch up from the preciously feeble Power. They were a mile down early, 10 goals down at half time and the game was over. Hawthorn will be fine but what on earth is the story with Port? This year’s Jekyll and Hyde. Could finish anywhere from 6th to 16th.

Don’t forget to post your Liked, Learnt, Hated below… along with any other thoughts you had about Round 5!
 
Liked:

7afl-1911368409616433227-gif.2282199


Well done to that man.

Learnt:

Melbourne have the most turgid list profile. Still playing a relatively old team. One paced midfield. Cannot score.
Utterly unwatchable team.

Hated:

Play on for 20m kicks. Someone at AFL HQ teach these umpires basic distances.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Liked: Kenny got himself another 10 year deal on the table taking out the premiership favourites

giphy.gif


JHF is the real deal

Learnt: Umpires will never get it right

Hated: BT still destroying commentary.


Port didn't beat Brisbane
 
Liked: Kenny got himself another 10 year deal on the table taking out the premiership favourites

giphy.gif


JHF is the real deal

Learnt: Umpires will never get it right

Hated: BT still destroying commentary.
Port only beat shit. Mid table shit.
 
Liked 9/9 for my tips and Port making me $500. The 2 games with SA teams the easiest games of the round to tip closely followed by Collingwood beating Sydney. Catching up with family and getting back to country SA.

Liked (more like reminded) definitely made the right decision leaving SA. What all my family tells me about free kick Hawthorn really is true.

Hated Having to spend more than one night in the dump of a hotel that is the Grosvenor.
 
Liked: Gather Round some cracking games high scoring.

Hated: The Melbourne/Essendon game...

Learnt: Hawthorn still not ready to take the extra step...lack a A-Grade mid and desperately need a KF with a presence.
 
Liked: Gather Round some cracking games high scoring.

Hated: The Melbourne/Essendon game...

Learnt: Hawthorn still not ready to take the extra step...lack a A-Grade mid and desperately need a KF with a presence.
You hated a game that didn't involve your team more than losing your first game to a team outside the 8?

Hot take.
 
Liked:
...

Learnt:
The Crows really haven't improved at all. Same old story of Nicks failing to have a plan B to stop the opposition when they have momentum (having no one with Bailey Smith is genius) and the players completely shitting the bed when faced with any form of pressure or expectation. Will likely miss the 8.

Rumours of Port's demise have been greatly exaggerated. That's the sort of win that can kick-start a season.

Dangerfield is an unstoppable force.

The Hawks still have some holes to fix before being a contender. Lack a genuinely good KPF and midfield depth. Calsher Dear could be that forward.

Hated:
Can next year be the last Gather Round? Port are 3/3 and we're 1/3.

34 degrees in April.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

What I’ve learnt and hated: this is still a biased VFl competition and VFL teams get the rub of the green all the time.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

The VFL just gave you a third free home game in 3 years.
Someone once told me that it’s not about where you play, it’s all about the supporter mix. Something something Grand Final something something Two supporter bases something something neutral game.

I think by that rationale, Gather Round is a neutral game for the SA clubs.
 
Liked- Hawks showing they are human.
Carlton getting a win, good for the fans.
Dogs losing. Good for me 😎
Never Surrender kit is always a win.

Learnt- there are some really great teams and some really poor teams. Not much in the middle.
- Never Surrender kit is a win, but don’t know why we used it as an away game against a club with the Wanderers fetish kit on. Only way it would be worse is if we played it as an away kit against Carlton.

Dislike- the Heat for the players on Sunday, hope it doesn’t come back to bite the Giants against the Crows.
 
Liked: Gather ground is a great idea and is working brilliantly, strong Cats win when it looked grim there for a while, Patrick Dangerfield is a monster on the field, anyone who dislikes this bloke knows absolutely nothing about football. Atkins!

Learnt:The Swans might be stuffed, the Demons are stuffed and don't get carried away with Port, they will find a way to be just as stuffed.

Hated: Ridiculous playing strips, someone at the AFL is having a laugh about all of this, only the Bombers guernsey was any good, the rest did not resemble an AFL team. Insane stuff!
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom