Remove this Banner Ad

After Three Rounds...

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

J

Just A Guess

Rookie
Oct 17, 2009
23
0
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Average score: 2000.3
Ranking:13783
Best pick: I'm going with Malceski and Maguire. I also have ROK, Barlow, Hodge etc but picking Malceski over other cheap backs was the best.
Worst pick: Clark and Tippet. Can't split em.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Probably Hall
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd. I went for Selwood instead, man that backfired.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Sandilands
Devastation: Rievoldt injury.
Dud Trade: I got in Seaby for Clark, and he gets a 30 first up. man i hate this game sometimes.

Season so far out of 10: 7/10
 
Average score: 2026.33
Ranking: 8115
Best pick: Would have to say Brad Ebert. Bought for $316K, is averaging over 100 after three rounds, and is that unique it makes me feel fuzzy.
Worst pick: Somewhere between Waite, Hille and Gia. Hille I'll have patience with, because he still made money, but Waite and Gia have been disappointing
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Medhurst
Player I considered, and should have picked: O'Keefe. Traded him for Roo on the last day before lockout. Oh well, win some lose some.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Brown. Completely missed that one.
Devastation: Roo I guess
Dud Trade: No trades made so far, though Roo changes that
Season so far out of 10: 8/10
 
Average score: mid 1900s
Ranking: LOL not going to bother!
Best pick: Boyd
Worst pick: Clark, Tippet, Warren, Wright
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Hargrave
Player I considered, and should have picked: ROK. Had him in my team all summer and went Pav instead for the extra 20 odd grand.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Sandilands, Ablett
Devastation: Riewoldt injury as Captain
Dud Trade: NONE! (Clark --> Sandi = not dud trade)

Season so far out of 10: 4/10[/quote]
 
Average Score: 2059
Ranking: 3,398
Best Pick: Malceski
Worst Pick: Hard to tell this early.
Player I considered, glad I left out: Tippett
Player I considered, and should have picked: Brad Ebert or Scotland
Can't believe I didn't consider: J Brown or Stanton
Devastation: Gia is such a tease, had him locked in after PS so didn't even consider someone like Higgins/Brown.
Dud trade: Haven't traded
Season out of 10: 7/10 - a few selection errors, but still well in contention for a top 1000 finish.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Average score: 2041.33
Ranking: 5622
Best pick: Malceski over Hunt, Ladson and Seaby over Hille/Naitanui, although after last weeks efforts this could backfire
Worst pick: Too early too tell, as for rookies probably Relton Roberts over Peterson
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Cox, Mitch Clark and Tippett
Player I considered, and should have picked:Boyd, Gilbert, ROK
Can't believe I didn't consider: Jonathon Brown
Devastation: Thats obvious, Riewoldt
Dud Trade: Only made 2, Robbie Gray out after round 1 for Buddy and Brown in for Riewoldt

Season so far out of 10: 7/10, no real complaints apart from Riewoldt going down as my skipper this week
 
Average score: 2043.33
Ranking: 5,351 of 276,713
Best pick: Hodge, Stanton, ROK
Worst pick: Tippett,Medhurst
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Clark
Player I considered, and should have picked: Sandy , Ebert(wce) , J.Brown
Can't believe I didn't consider: i think i had nearly everyone in at one stage over the per-season. Maybe Green
Devastation: Trading H.Shaw out for Sam Fisher only for Murgiure to score more then FISHER arhhh
Dud Trade: ^^^

Season so far out of 10 / 7
 
Average score:2010.33
Ranking:11440
Best pick: Bartel. Neva lets you down
Worst pick: Unfortunatly the way its looking probably Tippett. Wright is up there as well.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Clarke
Player I considered, and should have picked: Ballantyne
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd
Devastation: The Roo injury is pritty devastating yet will hit alot of teams. Probably Tippets performance so far has really thrown a spanner in the works! Picked him expecting to be a keeper but isnt looking anything like it atm. Watched the game on the weekend and he really didnt even look interested. Was hoping the melbourne game would kick start his season but didnt get anywhere near it.
Dud Trade: Havent traded yet.

Season so far out of 10: 5
 
Average score: 2005.33
Ranking: 12,580
Best pick: Stanton
Worst pick: Tippett
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Gray
Player I considered, and should have picked: Sandilands
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd & Ablett
Devastation: Tippett the Super Hack & Obviously Nick Reiwoldt
Dud Trade: Only Traded Reiwoldt to Goodes (Working on Kurt Spudette @ the moment)

Season so far out of 10: 5/10
 
how did you guys know to trade out riewoldt last week? I mean its only monday so surely nobody has traded yet.
 
Average score: 2053.6
Ranking:3,982
Best pick: Boyd - cannot believe only 6% of teams had him
Worst pick: Tippett - what a flop
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Gray
Player I considered, and should have picked: Bartel - although I guess if I had him I would've sacrificed Boyd or J Selwood and picked Dangerfield instead of Ziebell.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Peterson, Morabito, Rockliff, I guess it shows how happy I am with my current team that apart from a couple of rookies and Tippett I have no regrets.
Devastation: Riewoldt naturally
Dud Trade: n/a

Season so far out of 10: 8.5/10
 
Average score: 1995.00
Ranking: 15,227
Best pick: K.Cornes, Mitchell & Boak.
Worst pick: Clark, Hille, Sheuy (not performing as well as I hoped, could have got someone else with the same price but a better performer)
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Cox, Seaby
Player I considered, and should have picked: Malceski, Sandilands, Gram, Goodes, Chapman
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd, Ablett, Bastinac, Anthony
Devastation: Clark and Hille (have been my lowest scorers often), Riewoldt, Didak and Ladson
Dud Trade: Nothing yet, two trades in have produced (Hodge and J.Brown)

Season so far out of 10: 6/10
 
Average score: 2084
Ranking:1444
Best pick: Barlow
Worst pick: Tippett
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Mitch Clark
Player I considered, and should have picked: Rockliff over R.Tarrant
Can't believe I didn't consider: Bastinac
Devastation: Tippett and a few rookie selections. Obviously Riewoldt but that's a problem for practically everyone.
Dud Trade: None. Malceski in for Hurn and Seaby in for Tippett probably worked rather than failed.

Season so far out of 10: 8/10
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Average score: 2001.3
Ranking:13550
Best pick: Brown, Stanton, Sandilands
Worst pick: Hargrave, not much blame to lay on him for the Renouf bump though even if I'm upset :eek:
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Riewoldt
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd. I went for Selwood instead, man that backfired. (exactly the same for me) Same price and Boyd is getting scores that Selwood is not.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Goddard, was too expensive but can see it was justified as there just isn't enough premium backs.
Devastation: Hargrave :(
Dud Trade: None, I've still got 20 and will still have 20 at week 4 lockout.
Season so far out of 10: 9/10, I still feel I'm going strong if Hargrave doesn't miss a week.
 
Average score: Low 2000s
Ranking: ~9000
Best pick: Malceski over Kennelly, Ladson/Hunt over Farmer
Worst pick: Kurt Tippett, Robbie Gray, Brett Deledio, Daniel Giansiracusa.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Hargrave, Dangerfield(as trade LW)
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd, Higgins, Chapman and Gilbert. Perhaps Ottens also.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Brown.
Devastation: Riewoldt, Gia over Higgins.
Dud Trade: None. Tippett to Brown was brilliantly timed, Gray to Ballantyne made better by picking Ballantyne over Danger I guess...


Season so far out of 10: 6/10

Further off the top 1000 than I would like. Messed up with Deledio, badly. Riewoldt trade will make things interesting, hate the idea of burning 2 more trades, but seriously considering as Deledio is showing nothing and don't like the forward heavy role he is playing or seems to be trying to play.
 
Average score: 2050.67
Ranking:4381
Best pick: Bastinac, Sandilands, Higgins
Worst pick: Prismall
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Clark, Tippett
Player I considered, and should have picked: Kenelly, Malceski, Boyd/Stanton, Brown, Ballantyne, Maguire, Ablett.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Malceski (had him last year, awkward price)
Devastation: Prismall is a killer. To a lesser extent Roo, Dangerfield, Hall & Pendlebury
Dud Trade: Havent made one

Season so far out of 10: 6/10, 7 if Prismall plays this week
 
Average score: 2038.33
Ranking: 6,087
Best pick: Sandilands, Barlow, ROK. Very happy with Mayne who is reasonably unique as a forward mid pricer.
Worst pick:
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Hall, Tippett and Medhurst
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd. One of my favourite non-Carlton players. Absolutely love him. Went for Selwood instead.
Can't believe I didn't consider: Malceski. Wanted to stay away due to him being injury prone but I should've taken the risk. Went for Kennelly instead, who I am not unhappy with, but Malceski has been far superior.
Devastation: Riewoldt.
Dud Trade: Have not used any trades as of yet.
Season so far out of 10: 8/10. Have not really made any errors yet. Was happy with my rookies and cheap picks and think they all have significant money to make still. First real challenge comes now with Riewoldt and Dangerfield.
 
Average score: 2094.67
Ranking: 968
Best pick: Heath Grundy, been a great unique pick so far, also can't complain about Ballantyne
Worst pick: Joel Selwood (not a disaster but I had the cash to go for Boyd)
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Medhurst, Tippett
Player I considered, and should have picked: Malceski, Carrazzo, Scotland, Gilbert, Peterson
Can't believe I didn't consider: Malceski (picked Harbrow over him, could have saved 100k by picking Malceski)
Devastation: My bench picks, if i'd played the right rookie mids each week i'd have an extra 200 points
Dud Trade: Haven't made any yet (this week will make one for Roo)

Season so far out of 10: 9/10
 
Average score: 2058
Ranking: 3533
Best pick: Nick Malceski
Worst pick: Mitch Clark
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Tippett and Armitage were in my team 24 hours before lockout
Player I considered, and should have picked: And so was Sam Gilbert :(
Can't believe I didn't consider: Andrew Carrazzo ... I thought he was tagging
Devastation: Clark's shitness is threatening to derail my season
Dud Trade: Too early to say but Clark -> Seaby. Then again, I already had Sandi and there is nobody else doing any better (and I pocketed 200K).

Season so far out of 10: Means **** all
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Average score: 2121
Ranking: 322
Best pick: James Gwilt. 2 scores over 100
Worst pick: Sam Wright
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Riewoldt. Had him in my side until I read on Fanfooty website that he was carrying some injury.
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd. Had him last season but went for Bryce Gibbs.
Devastation: Touch wood, nothing major.
Dud Trade: Made 1 good trade. Wright -> Peterson.

Season so far out of 10: 8/10
 
Average score: 2121
Ranking: 313
Best pick: Brent Stanton
Worst pick: Too early
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Medhurst, Gray
Player I considered, and should have picked: Malceski, Chapman
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd
Devastation: Riewoldt injury
Dud Trade: No trades made

Season so far out of 10: Too early
 
Average Score: 1960
Ranking: 25,639 :eek:
Best pick: Malceski
Worst pick: Medhurst
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Roo
Player I considered, and should have picked: Rockliff
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd
Devastation: Danger injury.
Dud Trade: Got rid of Hall and put in Ballantyne before the round 3 lockout.

Season so far out of 10: 6
 
Average Score: 2142
Ranking: 106th
Best Pick: Malceski
Worst Pick: Hooker or Hall but not too bad.
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Gray
Player I considered, and should have picked: Rockliff
Can't believe I didn't consider: Boyd
Devastation: Riewoldt I guess but not too worried, being so early in the season.
Dud Trade: None made.

Season so far out of 10: 9.

First year of DT, always been in SC so very happy with the start.
 
Average score: 2054
Ranking: 2, 707
Best pick: Malceski
Worst pick: Gray
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Tippett
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd
Can't believe I didn't consider: Chapman
Devastation: Riewoldt doing his hammy or Prismall if he does not play for a few weeks that would be devastating.
Dud Trade: Mackay to McKenzie (not horrible but the worst out of 2)
Season so far out of 10: 8.5/10(My first year)
 
Average score: 2059.67
Ranking: 3,337
Best pick: Bartel
Worst pick: Tippet
Player I considered, but glad I left out: Medhurst
Player I considered, and should have picked: Boyd (Ball), Higgins (Gian), Seaby (Tippet), Malceski (Kennelly), Bastinac (Banner)
Can't believe I didn't consider: Brown
Devastation: Riewoldt, Tippet, Dangerfield and 1821 in Rnd 3. :(
Dud Trade: Haven't made any trades
Season so far out of 10: 9/10. I was so happy after Rnds 1 & 2, everything was going perfectly. Then everyone stuffs up and tippet continues to fail and then i cop a whole bunch of injuries. The only highlight out of Rnd 3 was that Shaw was out so i subbed in Maguire. Really really confussed about what to do with Dangerfield, Tippet and Riewoldt this week though. I think it will be an important decision that will define the rest of my season. I've turned my white board into one of those crazy lunatic disasters with arrows going everywhere in 6 different colours plotting out how all my different trade options could work out.... oh no.... not looking good. Might have to rock up to a psychologist about obsessing over DT too much.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

After Three Rounds...

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top