Remove this Banner Ad

APSS Top 60

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

AFLprospectss

AFLprospectss

Senior List
Joined
Jun 27, 2016
Posts
151
Reaction score
185
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Updated 17/10/16, happy with this listing and updated it now all the footy has been played! this is my final big board before the Big Footy Phantom Draft where i will control St Kilda and before my own phantom draft. this is a big board not a mock draft, keep that in mind but all comments are accepted. 60 goes as follows:

1- Andrew McGrath
2- Hugh McCluggage
3- Jack Bowes
4- Will Brodie
5- Ben Ainsworth
6- Tim Taranto
7- Sam Petrevski-Seaton
8- Will Setterfeild
9- Griffen Logue
10- Tim English
11- Oliver Florent
12- Todd Marshall
13- Jack Scrimshaw
14- Harry Perryman
15- Daniel Venables
16- Jordan Gallucci
17- Josh Rotham
18- Cedric Cox
19- Jarrod Berry
20- Josh Battle
21- Shai Bolton
22- Will Hayward
23- Jonty Scharenberg
24- Jy Simpkin
25- Will Drew
26- Kobe Mutch
27- Alex Witherden
28- Luke Ryan
29- Harrison Macreadie
30- Alex Villis
31- Brennan Cox
32- Brad Scheer
33- Sam Powell-Pepper
34- Myles Poholke
35- Jack Graham
36- Jake Waterman
37- Jacob Allison
38- Zach Sproule
39- Callum Brown
40- Pat Kerr
41- Matt Guelfi
42- Zac Fisher
43- Brandan Parfitt
44- Hamish Brayshaw
45- Dylan Clarke
46- Oscar Junker
47- Ben Jarman
48- Isaac Cumming
49- Jack Maibaum
50- Sam Walker
51- Tom Williamson
52- Liam Mackie
53- Jordan Ridley
54- Josh Begley
55- Josh Williams
56- Joe Atley
57- Tyson Stengle
58- Mitch Hinge
59- Ryan Garthwaite
60- Ben Long
 
Last edited:
why is rotham so low? for a guy predicted to go in the top 20, 57 seems way too low. Also Waterman didn't have a great carnival either.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Drew only just makes your list. He's meant to be going Pick 25 - 35 isn't he?
 
avishka5 said:
why is rotham so low? for a guy predicted to go in the top 20, 57 seems way too low. Also Waterman didn't have a great carnival either.
Click to expand...
Rotham isn't the best defender in the draft, don't see him in front of the people in front of him at this stage. In a draft were there is not many key forwards i see AFL traits in Waterman, that's why hes at 26.

DHepp21 said:
Drew only just makes your list. He's meant to be going Pick 25 - 35 isn't he?
Click to expand...
Drew suffers from having a poor carnival in a poor performing Vic Country team, that's why others jumped ahead of him
 
AFLprospectss said:
Drew suffers from having a poor carnival in a poor performing Vic Country team, that's why others jumped ahead of him
Click to expand...
Not sure Drew was poor at all, given he was barely played in the midfield as a predominantly inside mid. Besides, he showed some good signs with his run and goal sense.
 
Gollo said:
Not sure Drew was poor at all, given he was barely played in the midfield as a predominantly inside mid. Besides, he showed some good signs with his run and goal sense.
Click to expand...
ill be honest in saying Drew may have suffered due to me not seeing him in the flesh (saw every other state live).

if you look at the people in front of him they have shown under the pressure of the champs that they can dominate patches in games or games themselves, i do not believe i saw Drew do so.
 
Have you seen Rotham play? Really surprised you rate him so low... At 192cm he is just about as fast as anyone in this draft and probably one of the better/more penetrating kicks.
 
AFLprospectss said:
Rotham isn't the best defender in the draft, don't see him in front of the people in front of him at this stage. In a draft were there is not many key forwards i see AFL traits in Waterman, that's why hes at 26.


Drew suffers from having a poor carnival in a poor performing Vic Country team, that's why others jumped ahead of him
Click to expand...
Waterman was awful in Carnival, throw in traits like being very selfish, it's all about him. Don't think for a minute this will have gone unnoticed
 

Remove this Banner Ad

footywatcher3 said:
Have you seen Rotham play? Really surprised you rate him so low... At 192cm he is just about as fast as anyone in this draft and probably one of the better/more penetrating kicks.
Click to expand...
i watched him against SA in Adelaide and his televised game, he was down one end struggling to handle to handle the SA forwards while players like Brennan Cox was down the other end showing why he is one of the best key defenders in the draft. have not seen Rotham in the WAFL tho.

CrusaderAussie1 said:
Waterman was awful in Carnival, throw in traits like being very selfish, it's all about him. Don't think for a minute this will have gone unnoticed
Click to expand...
oh don't get me wrong, those traits do not go unnoticed, but he has shown that he has the athletic build to hold his own at AFL level and is still a top 30 footballer in this draft.

borderbarry said:
Romensky leading the TAC Cup coaches votes after 11 rounds and is'nt in the top 60? Come on.
Click to expand...
Tell me who you would take out? then i will tell you why hes in front of Romensky on my top 60
 
AFLprospectss said:
i watched him against SA in Adelaide and his televised game, he was down one end struggling to handle to handle the SA forwards while players like Brennan Cox was down the other end showing why he is one of the best key defenders in the draft. have not seen Rotham in the WAFL tho.


oh don't get me wrong, those traits do not go unnoticed, but he has shown that he has the athletic build to hold his own at AFL level and is still a top 30 footballer in this draft.


Tell me who you would take out? then i will tell you why hes in front of Romensky on my top 60
Click to expand...
Waterman looked slow to me! But if you have the right last name..half the battles won
 
ringo1 said:
Waterman looked slow to me! But if you have the right last name..half the battles won
Click to expand...
never said he was quick! he has good strength, hes pretty agilie and is working on his engine this year. although i do agree his last name helps him and it will on draft night. other clubs will make the eagles pay for him by bidding on him earlier then they should, just because he is a FS key forward!
 
AFLprospectss said:
never said he was quick! he has good strength, hes pretty agilie and is working on his engine this year. although i do agree his last name helps him and it will on draft night. other clubs will make the eagles pay for him by bidding on him earlier then they should, just because he is a FS key forward!
Click to expand...

From what iam hearing if a club bids on Waterman they will get him WCE are prepared to let him go.
 
What about tiziani.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Brock Mcfarlane from Norwood, SANFL. Extremely unlucky to be overlooked for the State u18 squad. You heard of/or know any news on his chances? 190cm, 80kg, Mid/Back. Needs serious consideration when looking into the 3rd round and/or rookie side of things. He will be a bolter, a lot like George Norlin-Smith's situation, not much SANFL u18 footy or Rep. Plays likes a Patrick Cripps.
 
Hutchy Jnr said:
Brock Mcfarlane from Norwood, SANFL. Extremely unlucky to be overlooked for the State u18 squad. You heard of/or know any news on his chances? 190cm, 80kg, Mid/Back. Needs serious consideration when looking into the 3rd round and/or rookie side of things. He will be a bolter, a lot like George Norlin-Smith's situation, not much SANFL u18 footy or Rep. Plays likes a Patrick Cripps.
Click to expand...
as far as state selection is concerned, i believe there was multiple players infront of him who didnt get picked themsleves. from a draft point of view, he may be a shot at rookie selection if clubs saw something in him during his 1 game of SANFL u18s in round 6. having not played SANFL since and being hidden away in the school system in 2015 it will make it tough for him to sneak his way through. i understand he played in the country carnival 2 weeks ago which is impressive by an u18, it may be a Justin Clarke situation from a couple years ago but i highly doubt that unless he returns to the SANFL before the year is out.
 
Scrimshaw at 40 is way too deep, one of the best ball carriers and users in the draft with a good scope for development, deserves to be anywhere from 6-12. Rotham is also a consistently valuable player, way too deep, should be on the first round fringe. Brodie is my number 1, and Bowes should slip into 3 or 4 with GC ACAD. McGrath looks to got from 7-9 and Marshall should go deeper. They're my thoughts.
 
AFLprospectss said:
as far as state selection is concerned, i believe there was multiple players infront of him who didnt get picked themsleves. from a draft point of view, he may be a shot at rookie selection if clubs saw something in him during his 1 game of SANFL u18s in round 6. having not played SANFL since and being hidden away in the school system in 2015 it will make it tough for him to sneak his way through. i understand he played in the country carnival 2 weeks ago which is impressive by an u18, it may be a Justin Clarke situation from a couple years ago but i highly doubt that unless he returns to the SANFL before the year is out.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the response, appreciate it! Tough to be locked away in the school system, hopefully Norwood give him a shot. Heard the back 6 are all over age players too, as Norwood play him out the back line. Only u18 in the country carnival too, in a strong zone, hopefully recruiters heard that. Thanks again mate! Loving your work
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

Cleric
    • Like
Prediction Your top 5 phantom draft.
2 3 4 5
Replies
112
Views
11K
Del203211
D

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom