Best CHF

[crazyjohn_9]

WHo is the best CHF in the league at the moment?

I picked Pavlich, i think its between him and Brown.

 

[weagles_fan]

Pavlich

 

[Zeke]

Travis Cloke!?

 

[Leg_Spinning_Sensation]

i picked Jonathon Brown, y the hell is Brad Miller in there?
Brown, Riewoldt, Pavlich and Tredrea r the best 4 in that order in my mind

 

[weagles_fan]

Ashley Hansen > Brad Miller

 

[crazyjohn_9]

Cos i picked 8 for the poll so i had to full the places. He is a handy footballer anyway dont no what ur on abiut.

 

[mudgeathon]

Hansen should be in there, instead of Miller

 

[PAFC2004]

This thread is a joke.

 

[Thewlis Dish]

Was Tredrea, now Brown for mine.

Quite possibly the best player in the game, too.

 

[Knowledge]

haha at people rating Pavlich before Tredrea.

hahaha

Tredrea best CHF in the game.

 

[melbournemartin]

Tredrae is the best CHF over the last few years but Pavlich has been the standout this year

the thread should be clearer as to whether it is taking into account this year or many years

also y Hansen aint there i dunno but does it matter? he aint anywhere near the others and neither is Miller so anyone who votes for Miller or other just is plain wrong

oh and i forgot to mention lucas, great kick, one of the best in the game but no where near the others either

 

[Salopek31]

Tredrea > Daylight > Brown > Riewoldt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Wannabe CHF's from the other 13 clubs.

 

[masai]

Career or 2005?.

Which answer do you want?.

 

[Portia]

Its funny how these threads only seem to start after Tredrea has a quiet one.

 

[sabre_ac]

Its funny how these threads only seem to start after Tredrea has a quiet one.

Season form my old "no1 docker knocker mate" Pavlich is the clear leader...period.
Though I do like your avatar there, suggesting the loss of him is why Port are playing so poor?

 

[inferno66]

This poll is for best CHF in 2005....i picked Pav for that...

if it was for best chf in there whole career you cant look past Treadrea

 

[tigerT]

absolute fu.cking joke that richo isnt on that poll

idiots

 

[Portia]

Season form my old "no1 docker knocker mate" Pavlich is the clear leader...period.

While I'll agree that this has been Tredrea's worst season for about five years...

Pavlich
20 goals, 57% accuracy
188 disposals
103 marks

Tredrea
26 goals, 61% accuracy
150 disposals
86 marks

Given the complete, and documented, failure of the Port Adelaide midfield, you'd have to say that Pavlich is not exactly making the most of his opportunities.

Though I do like your avatar there, suggesting the loss of him is why Port are playing so poor?

See above comment re: midfield. Roger James has played bugger all football, Francou is still out of whack, Peter Burgoyne has been injured...a Josh Carr would be handy right now.

 

[sabre_ac]

While I'll agree that this has been Tredrea's worst season for about five years...

Pavlich
20 goals, 57% accuracy
188 disposals
103 marks

Tredrea
26 goals, 61% accuracy
150 disposals
86 marks

Given the complete, and documented, failure of the Port Adelaide midfield, you'd have to say that Pavlich is not exactly making the most of his opportunities.

Goals wise Pavlich has played alot further up the ground.
The biggest factor in my opinion of any key position foward is marks taken to assess their season.
Pavlich's figure is well above that of Tredrea's at this point in time, enough to suggest he has had the better season.
Midfield wise freo last season where again last place for centre breaks so their hardly firing either...

 

[Firrito24]

N.Thompson > S.Lucas

 

[weagles_fan]

Goals wise Pavlich has played alot further up the ground.
The biggest factor in my opinion of any key position foward is marks taken to assess their season.
Pavlich's figure is well above that of Tredrea's at this point in time, enough to suggest he has had the better season.
Midfield wise freo last season where again last place for centre breaks so their hardly firing either...

Errr so if Gehrig takes only 50 marks but kicks 100 goals that means Pavlich has had a better year if he's gotten like 200 marks and 30 goals?

 

[pav_is_god]

Errr so if Gehrig takes only 50 marks but kicks 100 goals that means Pavlich has had a better year if he's gotten like 200 marks and 30 goals?

Gehrig plays at FF, so his sole job is to kick goals. The role of a CHF is to be the link man in the attack towards goal as well as being a goal kicking target.


As for the thread question, Pavlich is the better CHF so far this season but career wise he'd be 4th behind Tredrea, Brown and Reiwoldt.

 

[Kenny_01]

Pavlich is averaging 2.0 goals a game this season... just for comparison, Jonathon Brown averaged 1.48 goals a game in the 4 seasons the Lions made the GF.

Tredrea plays closer to goal so he is obviously going to kick more goals.

Despite Pavlich playing around HF and using his pace to his advantage, he is still #2 for contested marks behind Richo.

 

[Smokin_Joe]

Pavlich is averaging 2.0 goals a game this season... just for comparison, Jonathon Brown averaged 1.48 goals a game in the 4 seasons the Lions made the GF.

Tredrea plays closer to goal so he is obviously going to kick more goals.

Despite Pavlich playing around HF and using his pace to his advantage, he is still #2 for contested marks behind Richo.

i thought mcphee was second for contested marks? anyway we can get the stats?

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

Was Tredrea, now Brown for mine.

Quite possibly the best player in the game, too.

I think Pavlich is having the best season of all CHF's

But I voted for Tredrea because at the end of the day he's the best player in the AFL and he will show that by the end of the season. He's a little down by his standards, but that just show how high his standards are