Who do people consider to be the better defenders in the APS?
Add your nominations and I will make them into a poll.
Add your nominations and I will make them into a poll.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Best Defenders?
- Thread starter Couch Potato
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Kennedy #9
Draftee
I would say Dan Noonan hands down!
back2back4dacat
Senior List
Jack Maccioli for MGS very tall and has become massive from a big season of rowing. played in year 11 and i think year 10
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Carn the Dons
Rookie
pierre seale CBGS ???
tommyboy101
Rookie
the rotating forward
Senior List
Having rowed throughout the summer, Macciolli has come back an absolute unit. He can run all day and will completely physically demolish any opposition player he comes up against.
Only slight probs is his skills at times, however with the number of running back options weve got this year I'm sure Jack's handballing skills will be up to scratch
Only slight probs is his skills at times, however with the number of running back options weve got this year I'm sure Jack's handballing skills will be up to scratch
BlackMagic99
Rookie
noonan was the stand out defender as a yr 11 last yr so should humiliate all the CHF's this year again.
hateitorlovett13
Senior List
Only saw him once last year, but admittedly he carved up Lynch in this game, and that's no mean feat. Judging from the Hailebury Xavier game, in which Xavier, notably, were thrashed, Noonan stood up tall and this was the best performance I saw all year from any backman.
TouchOfASurgeon
Draftee
good on you for giving him his dues. when noonan was moved off lynch into the ruck in the second half the tide turned. noonan isnt the highest profile defender in the aps by any means but he's hands down the best.
Ablettttttt!
Senior List
Are you kidding me? Noonan is constantly being talked up on Bigfooty.
TouchOfASurgeon
Draftee
where there's smoke there's fire champ. he's a general at chb, ask lynch.
Ablettttttt!
Senior List
I'm not saying he's not good, just that he is in no way underrated.
- Banned
- #15
Louka Taffin from Wesley. Genuine CHB fast, tall, great skills. Absolutely killed Jack Watts last year even popped out his shoulder it was beautiful. Plays for Oakleigh
Will Cushen is the best full back in the APS. He is as strong as they come with pace to burn and an innate knowledge for the game and the position...he gets to see plenty of the ball been full back for carey and deals with the pressure in a superb fashion!
aintplayin03
Senior List
Judging by the amount of goals Carey concede he cannot be very good at all. Everyone is over you douches talking Carey up, you are not good.
Longkick03
Rookie
How can all the Xavier guys claim that Noonan is the best defender when he doesn't even play there for Sandy?
Surely if he was that good theyd play him there.
Surely if he was that good theyd play him there.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
why dont you head on down to a game and watch
he does play there for sandy, however also has a bit of a run up at chf. clearly a huge talent if hes able to play both forward and back
screw all ur big named players, that people only talk about cause of their reputation, if u actually know something about football all of you, u will know that James Woods (XC) is and will be for the rest of the year one of the best backman in the league. the fact that his name has not even been brought up or talked about seriously, is a disgrace
yep. spot on
i think people are forgetting the versatile geelong college big man llewyn butler who among many big name scalps last year towled up cyril "junior" rioli at scotch, a player now proving he has what it takes to make it at AFL level
butler, certainly one to watch this year
butler, certainly one to watch this year