Although I was initially sceptical, Troy Makepeace has turned into a great player. I think if you talk about consitency, he has played at least 4 years of top grade footy coming out of defence.
I would say that Kirk would shade him, but Makepeace would definately rank around Chad Fletcher, as Fletch has only had 1 great season, the rest were just good.
I would say that Kirk would shade him, but Makepeace would definately rank around Chad Fletcher, as Fletch has only had 1 great season, the rest were just good.

