Birchall or Kennely?

[dicleo]

Guys i gotta trade Bowden whats the better option. get Birchall or Kennelly ? let me know what u think. thanks in advance. I know that Kennely will leave more spare cash but i think Birchall is more consistant

 

[KouDogg]

I think this didn't need a new thread, when there is already a trade thread......

Go Kennelly.

 

[dicleo]

sorry didnt even think of the other thread, y do u think kennely?

 

[KouDogg]

sorry didnt even think of the other thread, y do u think kennely?

Well Kennelly is a great running backmen, who racks up kicks and marks. He is pretty consistent and he is at a very nice prise.

Maybe some sydney players can expand on this...(dont no much about him).

 

[lfctorres9]

neither go waters

 

[banana_bus]

1) Dont trade Bowden
2) Dont trade Bowden!!!
3) Take it to the trade thread.

 

[Bollox]

I wouldnt trade Bowden but if you're committed to doing it then bear in mind that if it wasnt for Williams deciding to put kane Cornes on Kennelly in rnd 2 then he and Birchall would be roughly the same price right now.

I've got Kennelly but only coz he was at a good price at the start and was always likely to hit 330-350K for a single trade upgrade at some pt...he has never been a genuinely good DT must have. Neither is Birchall tho IMO.

Unless u think Kennelly is what u want as a permanent 5th-6th best back u may as well go straight to a premium now and save the potential for needing another trade. Kennelly cops the odd injury too. IMO Birchall is a little overrated but does get lots of nice cheap ball.

So to sum this junk ...dont do anything. Reassess next week coz neither will go thru the roof this week (Kennelly up maybe 10K) and your circumstances will be similar anyway...and if Bowden is named u'll thank yaself for doing absolutely nuthin.

 

[Tippaz]

Guys i gotta trade Bowden whats the better option. get Birchall or Kennelly ? let me know what u think. thanks in advance. I know that Kennely will leave more spare cash but i think Birchall is more consistant

i'd keep Bowden (even if it meant playing 1 short)

but... if you must... i suppose Birchall gets the nod for me.

Kennelly is rumoured to be under some sort of injury cloud.
i would stay away from anybody playing hurt at this stage.

 

[lifelike_]

I'm starting to think that Kennelly might be a good buy. In the first month of last season he averaged 99, and apart from the Port game this year he's averaging 94.

IMO he's way underpriced, but there's something stopping me from bringing him in.