Brent Guerra

[juzza316]

Delisted by the Saints.............Is he worth drafting in the PSD? He would add some much needed toughness into our side. He is inconsistent though.

Or would Mclaren still be our no.1 choice?

Neither of those two are a very exciting proposition though!

 

[bluebagger]

Delisted by the Saints.............Is he worth drafting in the PSD? He would add some much needed toughness into our side. He is inconsistent though.

Or would Mclaren still be our no.1 choice?

Neither of those two are a very exciting proposition though!

No, neither of them are exactly of the Nick Stevens class, but it's rare you get star players going into the PSD, usually it's just handy players like Knobel last year and McLaren this year. Dylan would still be our most likely choice at No.1 as he's proven that he's a capable ruckman, and seeing as we really only have one in Barney, he would add a lot more to our team balance than Guerra...

I'd be somewhat surprised if no one picked Guerra up though...Hawthorn might be a more likely destination.

 

[king_Brown]

I think that collingwood may be keen on Guerra with there pick 2 in the PSD. He would give them some speed in the midfield and add some hardness to

 

[OZBomb]

Guerra to Collingwood seems about right to me. Fits their needs.

McLaren has the bigger upside out of these players.

 

[Powerstufff]

...Hawthorn might be a more likely destination.

Unlikely. Alistair Clarkson, Damien Hardwick and fitness coach Andrew Russell were at Port when Guerra was traded to the Saints. There will be no illusions for them about Guerra's attitude.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Would say he nominate for the National Draft also
as would many delisted players.

I don't think many of you are taking this into account.

 

[king_Brown]

He may nominate for the draft but will get picked up either way, he can add a lot to some team's such as pace and hardness, but i seem to think that he may wait till the PSD to find a new home. good luck Guerra

 

[HBF]

IMO, McLaren is much more likely than Guerra. McLaren fills a bigger hole in our team than Guerra. Agree with the other posters though, that Guerra should find a new a home in the PSD.

 

[stokesy]

McLaren is what we are in need of.

If Guerra came to Carlton another way, whether its a late pick in the draft or whatever it wouldn't bother me. He would just be another one of those players that will be in and out of the senior side.

 

[Blues_Man]

He's not what we need

 

[Verbeek]

I agree that we should be probably going after McLaren but I think people underestimate Guerra. He has shown signs in the past of being a very good player.

 

[av76]

I'd be interested for a late pick in the national draft or second pick in the PSD. He would provide better depth than the likes of Chambers and Longmuir and his big body might be useful in the middle should the likes of Kouta get injured. Must remember that getting a run in the St Kilda lineup as a midfielder or forward pocket is a pretty hard gig.

 

[irish_setanta]

Like to have him, and get him to clean up hamill, now that would be worth going to see.

 

[Snoozer]

He would add some much needed toughness into our side.

Guerra is not tough. Nothing tough about picking someone off..... we need guys who'll put their head over the ball at all times, there's no guarantee Guerra would do that.