Brett Montgomery

[Pivot]

Worth the CFC looking at or not? Has been? Possibly handy across half-back?

He's 32 I think so probably too old for us.

 

[Snoozer]

Offer a one-year deal. Very handy footballer. One year max then assess at the end of season.

 

[Koutou43]

You must be joking!

Average player in a good team.

I think you must be bored Paddy and just thinking up new threads for the sake of it.

 

[btdg]

Why bother. Only going to fill gaps for a year, taking a spot away from a talented youngster. We've spent far too long plugging gaps with guys who will never win us a premiership.

Better to take a punt on someone young who might actually be around for a few years

 

[HBF]

Worth the CFC looking at or not? Has been? Possibly handy across half-back?

He's 32 I think so probably too old for us.

Didn't we just recruit Saddington for this purpose?
I understand what Richmond did last year with Mark Graham, but i would think there is no way he will be at Carlton next year.

 

[Hu$$ey]

Hell no!

When are we going to learn?

 

[Waite_30]

Hell no!

When are we going to learn?

True, i guess that's never, by looking at our recent trade. Seriously id rather draft a youngster even if its a late pick, you never know what can happen. For example: Hird and Buckley.

 

[astro_toby]

True, i guess that's never, by looking at our recent trade. Seriously id rather draft a youngster even if its a late pick, you never know what can happen. For example: Hird and Buckley.

wasnt buckley a number one pick?

 

[Kooley]

lets get justin murphy back as well.

 

[Pivot]

You must be joking!

Average player in a good team.

I think you must be bored Paddy and just thinking up new threads for the sake of it.

Just putting it out there mate. I don't actually think we should draft him, I never even said that!

I just wanted to hear peoples views on him and if he's worth anything to us. In the PSD we will hopefully either go for a Selwood or a good kid like Eddie Betts who missed out on the national draft. With late draft picks I would much prefer a Wayde Mills or James Wall.

Great to have your input though just bagging others out mate!!!

 

[ECHUCABOY]

fair point would be good value but you could buy 2 kids for him. Pagans tried to plug holes before, I wouldnt be suprised if we snaffled him up. 50/50 call for me

 

[WTTF]

No thanks..............not at the expense of our youth. It's time to find out if some of them can actually play consistently at ALF level.

 

[ECHUCABOY]

No thanks..............not at the expense of our youth. It's time to find out if some of them can actually play consistently at ALF level.

U expect our youngsters to play like Aliens with big orange fury faces???

 

[Koutou43]

Just putting it out there mate. I don't actually think we should draft him, I never even said that!

I just wanted to hear peoples views on him and if he's worth anything to us. In the PSD we will hopefully either go for a Selwood or a good kid like Eddie Betts who missed out on the national draft. With late draft picks I would much prefer a Wayde Mills or James Wall.

Great to have your input though just bagging others out mate!!!

I hope bigfooty.com pays your wage

 

[Pivot]

I hope bigfooty.com pays your wage

Whatever ya reckon mate, BTW ever played footy before??

 

[douls]

he is a very good player and always has been. Would be great to see him playing again next year, but definitely won't be at carlton due to age, our re-building etc.

 

[pumped]

I believe he can play but is one of the last guys we need at Carlton. IMO he is another bad attitude player. We have enough of these on the list as it is and we havent got a good record with them. The present list needs some good solid minds to influence the others to be hard,fair and consistent.

 

[Kooley]

i can't believe that any carlton supporter would even consider picking up a player who is 32.

when will we ever learn?

 

[Pivot]

i can't believe that any carlton supporter would even consider picking up a player who is 32.

when will we ever learn?

Difference being Montgomery can actually play and is still playing very good footy. He again took plenty of marks, 160 thi s year. I don't think we need him but you can't compare him to recent players!