Brownlow night!

[Ninety4]

Who do you think will get the most votes from the Pies and is Buckley a chance?
My call:
Licuria (13)
Buckley (11)
Clement (10)
gap

bigger gap



THE REST....

 

[tarrant]

i think this might sound stupid..but maybe presti also....against richmond

 

[magpies42]

i dunno who will get the most votes, thats for the blind and stupid to work out but i def think you cant go past jimmy james clement for the best in our club this yr, by far!

 

[Lonie_from_50]

My Armchair Guide - Collingwood

Rnd 2 v Adelaide
2 - Paul Licuria (2)
1 - James Clement (1)

Rnd 3 v Carlton
3 - Paul Licuria (5)
2 - James Clement (3)
1 - Chris Tarrant (1)

Rnd 4 v Kangaroos
1 - Scott Burns (1)

Rnd 5 v Essendon
1 - Rhyce Shaw (1)

Rnd 6 v St Kilda
1 - Jason Cloke (1)

Rnd 8 v Richmond
2 - Simon Prestigiacomo (2)

Rnd 9 v West Coast
3 - Blake Caracella (3)
2 - Paul Licuria (7)

Rnd 10 v Hawthorn
3 - James Clement (6)
1 - Blake Caracella (4)

Rnd 11 v Geelong
3 - James Clement (9)
2 - Brodie Holland (2)
1 - Tarkyn Lockyer (1)

Rnd 13 v Sydney
3 - Nathan Buckley (3)
2 - Dane Swan (2)

Rnd 14 v Port Power
3 - Shane O'Bree (3)
2 - Brodie Holland (4)
1 - Simon Prestigiacomo (3)

Rnd 16 v Essendon
2 - Nathan Buckley (5)

Rnd 18 v Fremantle
3 - Paul Licuria (10)

Rnd 19 v Kangaroos
2 - Nathan Buckley (7)
1 - Jason Cloke (2)

Rnd 20 v Carlton
2 - Nathan Buckley (9)

Rnd 22 v Western Bulldogs
1 - Paul Licuria (11)

Leaderboard - Collingwood
11 - Paul Licuria
9 - Nathan Buckley, James Clement
4 - Blake Caracella, Brodie Holland
3 - Shane O'Bree, Simon Prestigiacomo
2 - Jason Cloke, Dane Swan
1 - Scott Burns, Tarkyn Lockyer, Rhyce Shaw, Chris Tarrant

Total Votes: 51

 

[goalpie]

Clement didnt even get a vote last year.

Wonder if he will this year.

 

[Jabso]

Clement will get more votes this year, the umpires always seem to pay attention to the defenders (or unfashionable taggers) once their reputation gets pumped up (i.e. after Jimmy's 2004 AA selection).
I think Brodie Holland deserves more votes. However I think LF50's count is accurate as Brodie, unfortunatly was always one of the ones standing up in a heavy loss, and when we did play well I don't think he was necessarily one of the best 3 on ground.
FWIW this is what I think it will turn out like:
BROWNLOW
1. Licuria
2. Clement
3. Buckley
4. Holland
5. Wakelin

COPELAND
1. Clement
2. Holland
3. Licuria
4. Wakelin
5. Buckley