Call our first pick (12)

[Demon 16]

Ok guys we're less than a week away from draft day and given our pick is one of the more interesting/difficult to speculate (given GC's 3 picks directly before us, our needs vs best available dilemna, and of course Jack Darling!) I thought we should gather our thoughts..

This thread isnt a discussion about who we want/need etc (as we have one already) - its to lay it on the line and state who you think the Demons heirarchy will pick (before the 'experts' start releasing their last minute phantoms).

Your allowed 1 player plus a smokey - Ill kick it off..

 

[Demon 16]

Pick 12: Keiran Harper

Smokey: Jed Lamb

(I think Atley, Lynch and Goringe will be gone and we'll pass on Darling).

 

[Dez!]

Shaun Atley, because he must be a Demon.

 

[Deefolt]

who is shaun atley?

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Jack Darling.

Might add a smokey later. Will be best available tall or outside mid, imo.

 

[LITTLE STINGA]

Pick 12: Keiran Harper

I'll go with that.

Smokey: Scott Lycett.

 

[BleasePlease]

Pick 12: Kieran Harper Eastern Ranges

Smokey: Pat Karnezis Oakleigh Chargers

both players provide a little bit of x factor and I dont think will go tall at our first pick.. rekon will be going tall at 33 and target that half forward half back type with our first pick

 

[Lord_Travis]

Pick 12: Ben Jacobs

Smokey: Scott Lycett

 

[Ghost of Grinter]

Isaac Smith..

Smokie - Jack Daniels.

 

[Rudeurrection]

David Swallow

Smokey - Sam Day.

Oh wait, we dont have the first pick this year do we? Sorry, force of habit, my bad.

 

[d33my]

I'm going to say Harper as well.

Not sure about a smokey (the draft isn't really a passion of mine)

 

[cannons]

notsureifserious.jpg on Harper, the guy shouldn't go that high in my opinion, too many question marks.

Pick 12: Smedts

Smokey: Lycett

 

[timmytow]

Pick 12= Darling
Smokey= Smedts (not really a smokey I suppose)

 

[RPetterd15]

Pick 12-Jayden Pitt
Smokey-Scott Lycett

 

[Captain Jack]

Not sure about a smokey (the draft isn't really a passion of mine)

I was so involved in the whole thing last year, but this year is very meh. I wonder why?


I'm going to say Shaun Atley, only because I just read an article about him in The Age and he sounds like a great bloke.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

depends complete on who is available

12: Smith

Smokey = Harper

 

[demonfromupnorth]

Issac Smith - Huge talent, good bloke plus i went to uni with him.

Smokey - Jack Darling

 

[Wise Guy Sam]

Pick 12; Jack Darling

Smokey; Billie Smedts

 

[Gazza_11]

Pick 12- Jack Darling
Smokey- Daniel Gorringe

 

[Tulip]

I was so involved in the whole thing last year, but this year is very meh. I wonder why?

Me too.

Was surprised to hear that it's in 6 days actually

 

[Demon 16]

Not sure about a smokey (the draft isn't really a passion of mine)

Fair enough d33 - I havnt got into as much as the last 2 years either for obvious reasons. Anyway have a look at the draft & trading board - there are some great writeups on most players in the phantom draft threads. If youre not into it now, you should enjoy them after the draft so you can have a read about the players we drafted

notsureifserious.jpg on Harper, the guy shouldn't go that high in my opinion, too many question marks.

Pick 12: Smedts

I like Smedts too - would probably prefer him to Harper as he can play more positions. Harper does have some attacking flair though - could go midfield or half forward. Just needs to play at his best more often.

I chose Harper because I reckon GC will take Smedts at pick 10 or 11.

 

[The Dr]

Would jizz if we get Atley, but also torn cos I want a KPP

 

[d33my]

Fair enough d33 - I havnt got into as much as the last 2 years either for obvious reasons. Anyway have a look at the draft & trading board - there are some great writeups on most players in the phantom draft threads. If youre not into it now, you should enjoy them after the draft so you can have a read about the players we drafted

Thanks for the heads up, and yeh once we do draft a player i'm all over it

 

[Rudeurrection]

Jayden Pitt.

Harper or McCarthy.

 

[stickman11]

Jayden Pitt.

Harper or McCarthy.

Smedts