Caracella V Mcgough

[Doggies05']

Seems like an easy question to answer...
Who is more worth to hav at your club?

Keep in mind Caracella is 28 this year and Mcgough is 21.
Caracella would be worth a fortune of money and Mcgough would be dirt cheap...

Would you rather a 3 time premiership player, very decent and is 28 years old.

OR

Would you rather a tough inside player, shocker of a kick, dirt cheap, young, has alot of potential and can be very handy for his price...

Now i'll ask the question again..

Who is more worth it to have at your club?

 

[Johnson#26]

Caracella. Just. At Collingwood anyway. We ahve a fair few McGough's, although I would like to have kept him, Caracella will tilt it towards us.

 

[lukafini]

Caracella.

I think he's pretty limp and a crap choice, but I'd definitely have him over McGough.

It's kind of like walking into an adult novelty store and deciding which will be the least painful dildo.

 

[lukafini]

not that i'd do that.

 

[lukafini]

just a metaphor.

 

[Snickers]

mcgough because he can get the footy himself

 

[tara!!]

Seems like an easy question to answer...
Who is more worth to hav at your club?

Keep in mind Caracella is 28 this year and Mcgough is 21.
Caracella would be worth a fortune of money and Mcgough would be dirt cheap...

Would you rather a 3 time premiership player, very decent and is 28 years old.

OR

Would you rather a tough inside player, shocker of a kick, dirt cheap, young, has alot of potential and can be very handy for his price...

Now i'll ask the question again..

Who is more worth it to have at your club?

Caracella's only a two time premiership player

 

[celtic_pride]

Caracella.

I think he's pretty limp and a crap choice, but I'd definitely have him over McGough.

It's kind of like walking into an adult novelty store and deciding which will be the least painful dildo.

Classic !
BTW I would have neither, as both players are officially duds in my book and would not help Carlton one iota.
Give me a tall key defender or an ruckman anyday over those duds.

 

[BrainOfMorbius]

just a metaphor.

A simile, actually.

 

[leonmagic]

A simile, actually.

Correct.