jhong
Old man yelling at clouds
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2011
- Posts
- 11,598
- Reaction score
- 10,123
- Location
- Third rock from the sun .
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Not great from Taylor
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

StK v HAW · CAR v GEE · SYD v RIC · BL v FRE · WB v COL · MEL v GWS · WCE v ESS ·
Weekend Wrap and "Liked, Learned, Hated" right here -- How did tipping go?
Not being helped with no T-Mac to organize the defence .Taylor is a terrible defender, hopefully he can play wing or something. Fitzgerald might make his debut next week if he keeps this up.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
On Taylor I reckon he's not a proper defender, he's an attacking player who happens to attack from the backline. It looks to me like they are forcing him to defend in the VFL - and he's struggling due to lack of size and also inexperience - because he can't just waltz into the AFL team as an attacker who is a liability as a true defender. He's very slight and young, he's got a lot of time up his sleeve to get better.Taylor probably needs some mature bodies around him, but he's shown absolutely nothing to warrant his high draft position so far this year. Looks way off it tbh. I like Fitzgerald. Just looks a player who can find the footy. Could get a debut if our midfield doesn't fire again today.
Agreed. Although I've been disappointed in what he's produced this year so far at a low level in VFL. I was a big advocate for him on draft night but he's not showing much in improvement. Matthews has shown more glimpses. Taylor is an inbetween size, so it will be interesting to see what role the club has in mind for him. Clearly atm needs bigger bodies around him. Hopefully ends up pushing a Salem out of the senior side. With Adams, TMac, now Cooke in the team, hopefully that allows him to run and carry a bit more.On Taylor I reckon he's not a proper defender, he's an attacking player who happens to attack from the backline. It looks to me like they are forcing him to defend in the VFL - and he's struggling due to lack of size and also inexperience - because he can't just waltz into the AFL team as an attacker who is a liability as a true defender. He's very slight and young, he's got a lot of time up his sleeve to get better.
First time I've seen him and he looks a very good player.Fitzgerald carrying the Casey midfield on his back in his first game. He is a beast.
Taylor probably needs some mature bodies around him, but he's shown absolutely nothing to warrant his high draft position so far this year. Looks way off it tbh. I like Fitzgerald. Just looks a player who can find the footy. Could get a debut if our midfield doesn't fire again today.
Taylor will be a gun. Happy to say that this early. Need to think of him as basically a tall Bowey though IMO. Won't be the greatest one on one, but will be good for ground balls, tidying up, and setting up play.Taylor is a terrible defender, hopefully he can play wing or something. Fitzgerald might make his debut next week if he keeps this up.
So who's coming out for him next week?Fitzy already one of my favourite Dees.
No one, get this man to JJ listonSo who's coming out for him next week?![]()

Made the most of his chances, but hasn't dominated. Any excuse though right?Pressure on JVR and Jefferson to deliver today with Kentfield dominating this game.
