Change vs Melb

[Groupie_]

If Lid is ready to go then:

Out: Knights
In: Lids

If he isn't ready to go then

Out: Knights
In: Foley

Or do we roll the dice and debut Corey Ellis or play McDonough ?

 

[SteveRFC]

Foley needs at least 2 full games under the belt.

If Lids isn't upto it then Lennon or McDonna

 

[OhhDeledio]

Bring in Axel I reckon. Give Lids one more week to fully recover

 

[Roachy8]

Team should remain if all fit except for Knights...
So:
Out - Knights
In: - Deledio if fit, otherwise McDonough.

 

[Livonski]

Lennon or Madonna (assuming Lids still out). Leaning towards Madonna for speed, but wouldn't be fussed with either. Curious to see Lennon again, reckon he's got serious ability, but lacks defensive run. Dees will flood our fwd line then charge out which I fear me catch him napping.

 

[Bojangles17]

If Lid is ready to go then:

Out: Knights
In: Lids

If he isn't ready to go then

Out: Knights
In: Foley

Or do we roll the dice and debut Corey Ellis or play McDonough ?

I'd have Lennon before foley

 

[Cevap_Roll]

Out: Knights
In: Lids/Lennon/McDonough or dare I say it Vickery?

I personally dont rate the 3 tall attack but I can see this game as a chance to trial it.

 

[Groupie_]

Lennon or Madonna (assuming Lids still out). Leaning towards Madonna for speed, but wouldn't be fussed with either. Curious to see Lennon again, reckon he's got serious ability, but lacks defensive run. Dees will flood our fwd line then charge out which I fear me catch him napping.

I thought he's slow as treacle

 

[tunksy]

If lids isnt right play lennon i say

But lloyd sub again??

 

[Madtiger2006]

Out Knights, Morris
In Deledio, McDonough

Hope the rain holds off and we play hungry exciting footy

 

[Roachy8]

Don't think Lloyd works as a sub.
Is the sort of guy that needs to be on for the whole game, bobbing up for 2 or 3 goals - not an impact type player + lacks the flexibility needed to be a sub... (To fill in down back or the middle)

Gordon covers heaps of ground and so can perhaps work better.

Your Lennon, McDonough types have more versatility IMO.

 

[Livonski]

I thought he's slow as treacle

Well if he's slow he's got an uphill battle ahead of him.
I have to admit I haven't seen a lot of him, but thought he had a bit of dash. As I say, I hope he has cos there's size against him too.

 

[3rdManUp]

Lennon deserves the call up from what I read in the VFL thread

 

[3rdManUp]

McDonuts for sub??

 

[Gentlemen]

Holy **** I can't wait until they get rid of this stupid sub rule

 

[Deanos]

Out: Knights, Batchelor
In: Lids, Lennon

Want to see McDonough in. But with lids coming back, is going to have to wait for an under performing mid/forward to get his opportunity. McDonough is far from slow just hardly ever uses his dash.

Foley needs more match fitness before he gets a call up. Was struggling big time in second term with fitness.

 

[Tony Harrison]

If no Lids, I'd like to see Lennon.
Where's the drop Newy crew this morning?
And how is Dea travelling?

 

[theflea]

Don't think Lloyd works as a sub.
Is the sort of guy that needs to be on for the whole game, bobbing up for 2 or 3 goals - not an impact type player + lacks the flexibility needed to be a sub... (To fill in down back or the middle)

Gordon covers heaps of ground and so can perhaps work better.

Your Lennon, McDonough types have more versatility IMO.

Lloyd being as a sub made him work harder and compete harder when he came on. Hopefully it teaches him a lesson. However, Gordon for all his fault, still manages to kick a couple of goals per game and maybe that 3rd tall fwd also.

 

[theflea]

Out: Knights, Batchelor
In: Lids, Lennon

Want to see McDonough in. But with lids coming back, is going to have to wait for an under performing mid/forward to get his opportunity. McDonough is far from slow just hardly ever uses his dash.

Foley needs more match fitness before he gets a call up. Was struggling big time in second term with fitness.

Can Lennon defend/compete/run better than Batch?

 

[Calcium Man]

If Lid is ready to go then:

Out: Knights
In: Lids

If he isn't ready to go then

Out: Knights
In: Foley

Or do we roll the dice and debut Corey Ellis or play McDonough ?

Foley is the same problem as last week bringing in Lambert and Petterd for Lids and Edwards. They are not creative enough or break the lines enough for that point of difference.

Needs to be Lennon.

 

[Groupie_]

Foley is the same problem as last week bringing in Lambert and Petterd for Lids and Edwards. They are not creative enough or break the lines enough for that point of difference.

Needs to be Lennon.

Lennon slow as treacle

 

[Livonski]

Can Lennon defend/compete/run better than Batch?

No.

 

[Groupie_]

Lennon shouldn't play anywhere but hf. If we are gonna play him there then Vickery needs to stay the f outta the team

 

[tigerninja]

Batch out??? no bloody way, is best 22 now and has been playing great footy

 

[Groupie_]

There's nobody to replace Batch anyway while Grimes is in Germany getting injected by Dr Hans