Changes v Collingwood

[raman]

Perversely, it looks like our AFL season now rests on whether one of Butcher or Shaw can pull out a 4 goal + performance at Alberton next weekend.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Out Cassisi, Stewart, Impey
In Logan, Butcher, Carlile
Polec sub

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Out: Cassisi, impey
In: Logan, whoever plays well for the Maggie's... Moore?

 

[tangolikelama]

Out: Cassisi, Stewart (MRP)
In: Logan, Moore

 

[BrockBlitz]

Oshea please. Disposal was horrid today!

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Oshea please. Disposal was horrid today!

By far our best key defender right now

 

[BrockBlitz]

By far our best key defender right now

Bob is back after the split round.

 

[PJ Power]

Butcher now is a non-negotiable must. You can't keep playing to that forward line with Wingard in particular so out of form, and Weshoff required so much in defence.

 

[Jdawgz]

seriously...geelong who struggled against gws beat melbourne by 66 points last week? we made them look good (again) hopefully the win gives them some confidence again..

changes idk cos I couldn't watch the game.

 

[Lewy69]

Out: Cassisi (ret), O'Shea (omitted), Stewart (MRP)
In: Logan, Carlile, Butcher

O'Shea disposal was pretty horrid at times. Would love to see Stewart in our best 22 and looked dangerous at times - if it wernt for our bad luck at the MRP (assuming 1 week) I would keep him in the side. Impey stays because I preume he will run with Elliot.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

Bob is back after the split round.

Has been better than Jonas and Hombsch IMO.

 

[tangolikelama]

PAFC
Hinkley: We looked alright without a 3rd tall fwd early with Stewart kicking two goals. #AFLPowerDees
20/07/2014 4:39 pm

 

[vonno]

Outs: Cassisi, O'Shea, Newts, P.Stew (if susp)
Ins: Carlile, Gus, Butch, Moore (for stew)

What will happen
Out: Cassisi
In: Carlile

 

[tangolikelama]

Has been better than Jonas and Hombsch IMO.

no shit Carlile was in AA form

 

[vonno]

PAFC
Hinkley: We looked alright without a 3rd tall fwd early with Stewart kicking two goals. #AFLPowerDees
20/07/2014 4:39 pm

How did we look in the second half kern :/

 

[PowerKidd]

In: Bobby, Moore, Monfries
Out: OShea, Cassisi, P.Stew

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

P Stew as tall #2 only worked in the first half because he kicked two goals.

Otherwise he didn't offer anything else for structure. He's better than Sam Gray at being our second tall but it would make more sense to play Butcher who happens to be gifted at creating something out of a dead ball situation.

 

[PJ Power]

How did we look in the second half kern :/

Kern worries me with his reluctance to acknowledge our structural problems. Stewart barely saw it after quarter time.

 

[Dalfino]

Out: D. Cassisi (retired), P. Stewart (omit), J. Impey (omit)
In: A. Monfries, A. Carlile, T. Logan
Sub: White/Polec

Cassisi is the obvious out because he is retiring. Think he deserved a better send off game myself but oh well.
Stewart I don't really mind staying in or out, he just didn't have much of an impact as say Monfries would have.
I think Impey needs a rest. He has been in the side far too long and really needs a break. I feel as if he is like Jake Neade, as he started out fantastic but then started to dip towards the end of the season.

 

[PAFC66]

Out - Polak，Stewart，Oshea，Dom
In - Carlile ，Butcher，Monfries，Moore

Carlile will help our situation but only half of it. We are still struggling in the middle. Ebert was still terrible and does not look fit at all. We actually look cooked.

 

[RossFC]

OUT: Cassisi (retired)
IN: Carlile

If Stewart is suspended then Logan comes in. Don't think Monfries will play.

Polec, White or Wingard for the sub.

Stewart staying forward was great he kicked 2 goals and Schulz kicked 2 and Westhoff had a great game.

 

[PJ Power]

I don't think Impey's playing poorly. He's just looked a bit shaky in the setting of our mids getting beaten and with no tall forwards to kick to when he charges from defence.

 

[PJ Power]

Calls for O'Shea to be dropped are looking for some laughs aren't they?
Comfortably in our best five today.

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

no shit Carlile was in AA form

I was talking about O'Shea

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

PORTADELAIDEFC.COM.AU'S BEST

R. Gray, Wines, Hartlett, Westhoff, Cornes, Lobbe