Changes

[jefffff34]

In: Buckley, McKee, McGough, KINNEAR
Out: Cole

The extended bench is unknown by myself at the moment.

 

[FIGJAM]

Originally posted by Hoggy
In: Buckley, McKee, McGough, KINNEAR
Out: Cole

The extended bench is unknown by myself at the moment.

We play Sunday and don't have to give final selections until tomorrow night; hence the 25 man line-up.

Buckley in place of Cole is an obvious one.

I'd play McGough in place of Molloy.

McKee & Kinnear should go away.

 

[Lockyer24]

Last chance Jarrod.

 

[Nic]

Go Benny! Go Benny! C'mon, I have a feeling Kinnear could actually do something this week! Something good!!

Anyway, hope McGough gets a go.

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Go Benny, it's your birthday.

And it will be your last friggen birthday party you VFL champion.

Hey Hoggy, where's RUPE?!

 

[Perty4]

Backs: B. Johnson S. Prestigiacomo J. Clement
Half Backs: R. Shaw S. Wakelin S. Woewodin
Centre: P. Licuria N. Buckley A. Williams
Half Forwards: A. Didak A. Rocca J. Cloke
Forwards: B. Holland C. Tarrant L. Davis
Followers: J. Fraser, S. O'Bree, S. Burns
Interchange: B. Kinnear, M. Lokan, R. Lonie, M. McGough, S. McKee, J. Molloy, H. Scotland

In: Bucks, MCG, BK, Stunner
Out: Cole

 

[Perty4]

i suspect the make up of the side was done prior to Rupe getting let off at the tribunal. Poor excuse but thats all i can think off. Plus McGough and Kinnear both played better than him last week anyway.

 

[bucksisbest]

**** off Kinnear!!!!!

 

[Murray]

I'm not so sure Bucks will be risked with the weeks break coming up.
Maybe the only change will be McG for Cole.
Can't understand why Johnson is still there.
Why name Kinnear as a possible? Hopeless at Senior level - unless he is being used as trade bait!!!

 

[MarkT]

Hopefully the match Committee will realise that Ben Kinnear has had enough chances and demostrated catagorically that he is not good enough to play senior AFL football with Collingwood. I suspect they want to get a trade value on his head though.

Bucks back is an obvious one if fit and Cole out is fair enough. McGough deserves a chance and I'd like to see Rupe back. Who to leave out is the difficult question. Williams was good early and fair to ineffective since. BJ hasn't set the world on fire and Molloy has done some great work but too infrequently.

I can't see any point playing McKee. Big heart, good at fighting for the ball but not a ruckman's bum hole. Time to concentrate on who can win us a premiership not who can stop us getting thrashed. I still want to Cameron Cloke get a game whether he is ready or not. Give him a taste and give him a crack at the big time. He may just take his one chance. At worst he gets beaten like McKee would and until very recently Fraser has been and then goes back to Williamstown. AT best he does ok in te ruck and has a spell up forward and kicks a goal and therefore gets another game. To say he isn't ready is irrelevant when MM played Cole, Fraser and L.Davis well before they were ready.

 

[Whisky_McKay]

Kinnear - What the F.uc.k is he even being named for. Get the biggest Bus you can find MarkT if this DUD plays.
McGough will probably come in if it looks like being wet, he will get heaps of it.
BJ hmmm???
Molloy not showing much, maybe time for a Willi moment. C-Clo to to replace him.
As for the team this week Cole out, Bucks in if fit, otherwise McGough, no other change

 

[hotpie]

Originally posted by MarkT
Hopefully the match Committee will realise that Ben Kinnear has had enough chances and demostrated catagorically that he is not good enough to play senior AFL football with Collingwood. .

He's better than Molloy and his form at Willy warrants another chance. He's also just as good a choice as second ruck as McKee (which I admit isnt saying much!!)