charman??

[Bojangles17]

It is simple, if he is so good...he would play in your best 22. He doesn't.

wasn't easy to break into a winning side in 2H of year...first half he was settling back from injury..k

 

[freezer]

Don't want him.

Great player, but he def wouldn't come cheap (there are some dellusional crew in the Tiger room today, Pettifer or Polo and a 3rd rounder?! Comedy genius ). Don't think he'll be the difference in us winning a flag in the next couple of years, and when the kids are ready to go in 3 years he'll be nearing the end of his career.

No topping up until our young guns are ready to have a genuine crack in 3-4 years, and we actually know what we need!!!!! If we keep our picks and keep drafting midfielders, KPP, and rucks, we'll have enough depth to offer something worthwhile for someone like Charman when and if we need them.

 

[_Wang_]

I'm too busy imagining Pettifer and Polo running amok in the same team. And Raines as well!!! Now come on. That's just being totally unreasonable. Imagine all that outside running power!

I will take your 4th rounder and Lionel Proctor. But that's as high as i'm prepared to go.

I mean Charman is only a just-turned-26 year old contracted first ruck. Theys fall of trees theys do.

I like it... Lets do it
That Proctor he is a good thing!!! I tell you what because we like you we will throw Jeremy Humm in as well

 

[Hollow Knight]

You Brisbane supporters are pathetic.

Polo is tougher than any kid you've got.

28 touches and 3 goals on debut? He's got talent. If he steps up he'll play a similar role to a Brett Kirk.

Very tough inside midfielder, not a "soft outside runner" LOL watch some footy

Maybe you should tell that to some of your fellow Richmond supporters who seem eager to bundle such an elite superstar off to another club.

 

[TimeFor11]

Look I dont know what his value is but it would have to be less than Warnock. He has obviously shown more but he is an injury prone bash n crash ruckman at 27 who may have only 3 more years left in him. I wouldnt offer anymore than pick 42 and a fringe and if they dont like it then we can agree that Charman aint coming to our club.

 

[Warwick]

Look I dont know what his value is but it would have to be less than Warnock. He has obviously shown more but he is an injury prone bash n crash ruckman at 27 who may have only 3 more years left in him. I wouldnt offer anymore than pick 42 and a fringe and if they dont like it then we can agree that Charman aint coming to our club.

When did he turn 27?

 

[notting18]

He has obviously shown more but he is an injury prone bash n crash ruckman at 27 who may have only 3 more years left in him.

Old man Charman is JUST 26

 

[peterbuch74]

OK, how about taking Shane Morrison and Luke Weller back then?

All of the talk in this thread is garbage... Voss would not entertain any of the names mentioned in this thread.

 

[Deledio2Conca]

In your opinion which of these trade offers are reasonable for Charman?

Polo

Raines + 3rd rounder

Pettifer + 3rd rounder

Wanna trade Foley for a 3rd rounder + McGrath? Or Thursfield for Corrie?

Of course none of them are reasonable, and anyone with half a brain could tell that that's the case.

It's just funny when the cavalry arrives and get all worked up over either a couple of nuffies or some others who were obviously just joking.

 

[Deledio2Conca]

How does that make us insecure? That's terrible psychology, even by internet standards.

Every offer so far has been ridiculous mate. Charman would be one of our first players picked every week.

Polo, Pettifer and Raines only managed 14 games between them this year. Why would we trade our contracted , premiership winning, number 1 ruckman for one of these guys who can't even make your side.

Geez get stuffed mate, if you couldn't see that they were 'fake' offers then I feel sorry for you.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Geez get stuffed mate, if you couldn't see that they were 'fake' offers then I feel sorry for you.

They clearly weren't fake mate, no need to run damage control.

 

[tony_montana]

no chance,

would cost a premium and like has been mentioned you really think brisbane will give him away? lol

keep going through the draft tiges, we're too far away to be going down this tried and failed pathway

 

[steveycams]

Charman shoulder will fall off in 2 years time with all the injuries

much rather Seaby....

 

[dyl_tigerman]

They clearly weren't fake mate, no need to run damage control.

come on mate do you really think that us tigers think he is worth a 3 rounder and one of our duds... i don't think so....
i reckon charman maybe a 2nd rounder