Ching round 1

[dancingdoggie17]

It is 5 isn't it?

5. Rob Murphy
4. Mark Alvey
3. Danny Bandy
2. Johnno
1. Robbo

Young guns:
3. Murph (does he qualify?)
2. Hahn
1. Guido

 

[Captain Sensible]

5. Bandy
4. Eagleton
3. Murphy
2. Alvey
1. Kritter


Young 'uns

3. Hahn
2. Guido
1. Hargrave(?)


Can we have a list of who is eligible for the kids?

 

[The Doctor]

Gee this is a hard one - an open field

5. Alvey
4. Murphy
3. Smith
2. Bandy
1. Grant

Apologies to many others.

Pups

3. Murphy
2. Hahn
1. Hargrave

 

[Doggiesrule1020]

my votes go to

5.Murphy
4.Alvey
3.Westy
2.Granty
1.Bandy


young guns

3.Murph
2.Hahn
1.Guido
apologies to eages and Kritter and guido

 

[OldSchool]

Pups ?

Regarding the Pups, why is Murph and Guido still classed as Pups ?

 

[jim440]

Re: Pups ?

Originally posted by OldSchool
Regarding the Pups, why is Murph and Guido still classed as Pups ?

Offically, because they are from the 99 draft, but don't forget they were born in 82 which makes them younger than Gilbee, Hahn, Wiggins, Hargrave and Bruton.

 

[jim440]

5. Johnson
4. West
3. Smith
2. Alvey
1. Giansiracusa



3. Giansiracusa
2. Murphy
1. Hargrave

 

[jim440]

You guys are hard. What does Scooter have to do to get a vote?

He must have got it 40 times today.

 

[OldSchool]

Re: Re: Pups ?

Originally posted by jim440
Offically, because they are from the 99 draft, but don't forget they were born in 82 which makes them younger than Gilbee, Hahn, Wiggins, Hargrave and Bruton.

So if you are under 21 before the season you qualify ?

 

[Doggiesrule1020]

Just changed my eagle vote to westy i forgot about him.I didnt even realise he had 35 possesions untill i read the stats on the afl site.

 

[Curly5]

I'm confused, I'm not giving pups' votes, they aren't now. They've gotta be men from now on.

5. Bandy
4. Alvey - loved his Brett Lee pumps.
3. West
2. Johnno
1. Hahn

Special mention to backline: they all did well.

Chris hope we aren't without him for too long.

 

[Doggiesrule1020]

Hey curly alves was getting pretty pumped up wasnt he hehe.

 

[Chops]

Its hard voting because for me it was impossible to find order the best 5.

maybe I'm being too harsh.
Murphy was the only one never made a mistake all day but man Chapman got away from a bit at end. Hahn was the most dynamic but was off the ground a bit. Robbins put Baby Jesus in a manger just few disposal errors. Bassett where have you been, the exact type backman we need. Hargrave recovered from some unlucky spoils. West made a few errors for 35 possies. Smith missed a couple of tackles early. Dimma started badly then ran hard and strong. Grant was great before the injured. Bandy would have to be up there (misses a mark or two). Alvey some nice goals but cost us 1. Johno quiet 1st half. Brown missed too many goals. Guido was great early. Kritter tough all day.

OK
5 Murphy
4. Bandy
3. Smith
2. West
1. Hahn

Pups
3. Murf
2. Hahn
1. Guido

 

[Chops]

Forgot to mention that Eagleton played one of his best games for the club. In and under/confident!

 

[stefoid]

1) Murph
2) West
3) Johno
4) Alvey
5) Bandy

pups:
1) Murph
2) Guido
3) Hahn

 

[X_box_X]

5. Smith
4. Murphy
3. West
2. Alvey
1. Eagleton

Pups:

3. Murphy
2. Hahn
1. Giansiracusa

 

[mel 40]

Originally posted by Chops
Murphy was the only one never made a mistake all day

He did so. He watched the ball cause he thought it was going to go over the line(2nd quater i think it was) and the geelong player chased the ball, got it, kicked it away, and ended up being a geelong goal.

 

[mel 40]

5- Mark alvey
4-Mitch hahn
3- Scott west
2- Daniel giansiracusa
1- Brad johson


Pups
3- Mitch
2-Murph
1-Gia

 

[K9-54]

5. Murphy
4. West
3. Kritter
2. Johnno
1. Robbins

Apologies to Alvey, Smithy, Guido, Hahn and Bandy. Plenty of good players today but I thought the backline was great.

3. Murph
2. Hahn
1. Guido

 

[Chops]

Originally posted by mel 40
He did so. He watched the ball cause he thought it was going to go over the line(2nd quater i think it was) and the geelong player chased the ball, got it, kicked it away, and ended up being a geelong goal.

Sorry didn't see that as I was on lvl 3 and it was below me. Everyone stood up

 

[Bulldog1954]

5) Alvey - best game he]s played? Love the celebrations
4) West - must have got at least 30
3) Bandyman
2) Guido
1) Johnno

Pups
3) Guido
2) Smurf
1) Mitch

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

5. West
4. Alvey
3. Bandyman
2. Johnno
1. Murphy

Apologies to Bubba and Guidopolous

 

[SCRAY72]

5. MURPHY
4. WEST
3. KRETIUK
2. ALVEY
1. JOHNSON

Young Guns

3. MURPHY
2. HAHN
1. HARGRAVE

Encouragement award : Nathan Eagleton

 

[Chops]

Originally posted by Bulldog1954
5) Alvey - best game he]s played? Love the celebrations

What's with this Brett Lee start the lawn mower celebration?

 

[Templeton31]

5 - West
4 - Kretiuk
3 - Alvey
2- Murph
1- Grant (coz he played well an it will be my only chance to vote for him this season )

Young guns:

3 - Murph
2 - Guido
1 - Wiggy (coz he set up 3 goals and coz I'm getty 'wiggy with it' in 2003)