Ching - Round 11

[OldSchool]

Should be a good game

 

[SBI]

5 - Cooney, or as Rex calls him George Cooney
4 - Westie
3 - Farren
2 - Morris
1 - Robbins

 

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

5 West
4 Cross
3 Ray
2 Cooney
1 Morris

 

[Derek Zoolander]

5 - West
4 - McMahon
3 - Cross
2 - Cooney
1 - Rawlings

 

[amnesiac]

5 - West
4 - Cross
3 - Guido
2 - Jordy
1 - Robbo

3 - Cross
2 - Jordy
1 - Ray

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

5. West
4. Cross
3. McMahon
2. Cooney
1. Robbo

 

[Leon]

5. West
4. Robbins
3. McMahon
2. Cross
1. Giansiracusa


3. Ray
2. Griffen
1. Cooney

 

[X_box_X]

5) Cross
4) West
3) Cooney
2) Robbins
1) Smith

 

[Dog Town]

5-Cross
4-West
3-Mcmahon
2-Cooney
1-Guido

 

[C.E.Lovett]

5. McMahon
4. Gilbee
3. Shaggy
2. Giansiracusa
1. West


Pups

3. McMahon
2. Ray
1. Cooney

 

[Number 2 1961]

5 - West
4 - McMahon
3 - Cross
2 - Cooney
1 - Street

Pups

Mcmahon
Cooney
Ray & Griffen

 

[birssyboy40]

5- Crossy
4- Westy
3- Morris
2- Jordaman
1- Robbins


PUPS
3- Cross
2- Jordaman
1- Griffen

 

[Aquamarinejewel]

5. West
4. Cross
3. McMahon
2. Robbins
1. Cooney

Pups.

3. Cross
2. McMahon
1. Cooney

 

[bogan4life]

5 west
4 cross
3 morris
2 Street
1 cooney
robbo is unlucky
pups
3 cross
2 cooney
1 ray

 

[Rocco Jones]

5- Cross
4- West
3- Jordy
2- Cooney
1- Gian

 

[whythelongface]

5. McMahon
4. Gilbee
3. Shaggy
2. Giansiracusa
1. West


Pups

3. McMahon
2. Ray
1. Cooney

Just an observation CE but you seem to never give Crossy any votes when he is playing well. Don't you rate Crossy?

 

[flamethrower]

5. Scott West
4. Adam Cooney
3. Jordan McMahon
2. Daniel Cross
1. Ryan Hargrave

Apologies to: Farren Ray, Dale Morris, Robert Murphy, Matthew Robbins,
Peter Street, Daniel Giansiracusa.

After watching the replay on Fox Footy last night, I can't believe I left Westy out of the votes. Order has been restored now.

 

[scooter600x]

5. Cross
4. West
3. McMahon
2. Cooney
1. Hargrave


3. Cross
2. McMahon
1. Cooney

 

[scooter600x]

Just an observation CE but you seem to never give Crossy any votes when he is playing well. Don't you rate Crossy?

He bagged the hell out of him earlier this year and just like Mike Sheehan with Scott West he won't admit what a moron he was (is).

 

[Rocco Jones]

Yeah CE is certainly proving to be very stubborn with Crossy. His view seems to be based on the effectiveness of Cross' disposals. While it not not be flash, he wins alot of his disposals, whether it been hardball gets, clearances or the amout of running he does to get in position to receive uncontested disposals. He doesn't just get easy touches, if ever they are uncontested it's due to a huge amount of running.

I'm sick of West and Crossy being bagged on this board for running the hard yards to make space. Being on your own doesn't necessarily mean you are getting easy touches.

Not giving Cross votes is just a huge sign of Sam Newman like ignorance.

 

[C.E.Lovett]

In my opinion our centres lost today.

We lost the centre bounces and clearances. If the centremen can win the centre clearances they will get more votes from me. Also I rate long runs with bounces very highly and as you know there are no stats for these.

You will note that when our middle players had a lot of possessions last week, we lost. In my opinion high possessions does not equate to votes.

I also do not rate a handball as effective as a kick. For example I rate a long raking goal by Eagleton as say half a dozen handball by other players. I also rate other things such as hits and spoils.

Any centre player must get more possessions than forwards or backmen.

I think that whilst Cross does get a lot of possessions he is a player who does not hurt. He does less hurt than West.

I think that many players on this board over-rate Cross and it annoys me somewhat. Therefore I have to sometimes go to ridiculous extremes to counter what I believe is unwarrented idolatory of this player.

 

[Fossie 32]

5 Robbo - 4 goals and a hand in at least 3 or 4 others
4 Crossy
3 Jordy
2 Cooney
1 Ray

Griffen v good

3 Cross
2 Jordy
1 Cooney

 

[Kennel Master]

One of the tougher games to vote on because there were many contributers but no-one really outstanding.

5. Cooney
4. West
3. Robbins
2. Murphy
1. Ray

Special Mention to Morris, Street, Hargrave, Cross, Gia and McMahon.

Pups
3. Cooney
2. Ray
1. Morris

 

[bogan4life]

One of the tougher games to vote on because there were many contributers but no-one really outstanding.

5. Cooney
4. West
3. Robbins
2. Murphy
1. Ray

Special Mention to Morris, Street, Hargrave, Cross, Gia and McMahon.

Pups
3. Cooney
2. Ray
1. Morris

not a pup

 

[Borgsta]

not a pup

I think he is a pup. He misses out by 3 days, which I think is wrong anyway. It should be born after September 1982, going by footy seasons, not traditional years.