Chris Judd

[one_twelve112]

Oh almost wrong on every count there mate...but keep up the guesswork.

The weagles are the LAST in LINE,see if you can work out why, there are probably 50-100 threads explaining it if you do some research.

You're right.

 

[parrot]

There looks like being only 4 possible Clubs that Judd would want to go to - Blues, Dees, Dons or Pies. The Tiges by default, may be a 5th because they have the #1 PSD pick, and Judds manager has reluctantly decided to make contact with them, because of their position in the PSD. All 4 Clubs are in with a good chance, as Judd obviously sees positives in each of them, otherwise he would not have shortlisted them. Everyone in the media are putting the Pies down as favourites. Even if the Pies are Judd's first preference, the Pies would have to do something pretty dramatic in terms of trades in order to get on the same page as the baseline offers from the Blues (Picks #3, #20 plus player), Dees (pick #4 plus player), or Dons (pick #5 plus player). So in that scenario, the likelihood of Judd choosing the 2nd Club is extremely high. The Blues and Dees would be the front-runners then. One more point, for arguments sake if Judd wanted to go to the Pies, but knew that there was no way the Weagles would accept their offer, I doubt he would nominate the Pies in the first place, because of all the bad publicity it would create.

 

[Bluebear]

God why cant people read the signs....

Judd has said UNEQUIVOCALLY he will be chosing aclub and west coast will have to deal with THAT CLUB.

Perspective is everything.
here is what he said
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=373069

"“I will sit down with some Melbourne clubs in perhaps the next week or so. I will decide which club I want to go to.”

??? Nothing about WCE having to....or being forced to trade with that club soley........but wait ......there's more

“He’s our captain, he’s been one of the best players, if not the best player in the competition,” Nisbett said. “I think the clubs that Chris will talk to in the next few weeks will understand that.”“We’ll expect the right value [for Judd]. The fortunate thing is Chris knows the game as well as we do.”

Sounds to me like Judd will pick his preferred destination, but will be happy to go to number two if his preferred option doesn't deal fairly.

Do you really think he would say "I want the Pies"......club says "Their deal is crap, the Blues are much better".........and Judd says (holding breath and stamping feet) "BUT I WANT THE PIESSSS!!!!!!"

No, that would be silly.

He will give his number one choice, but he will also give his m=number two - otherwise WCE has no bargaining power at all.

We will be number 2 behind Pies, and we will out bid them significantly, and we will get Judd.

 

[strat]

Oh almost wrong on every count there mate...but keep up the guesswork.

The weagles are the LAST in LINE,see if you can work out why, there are probably 50-100 threads explaining it if you do some research.

Yeh and all those 50-100 threads are guessing as well mate so theres no point researching through rubbish

 

[one_twelve112]

Yeh and all those 50-100 threads are guessing as well mate so theres no point researching through rubbish

I don't believe you actually understand how this is going to unfold. Guessing has nothing to do with it. Judd will chose his prefered club or clubs and allow the Weagles to broker a deal with them, if not he will enter the PSD and the Weagles will get stuff all (worst case scenario for WC). Judd will not end up at a club he has not interest in being part of for the sake of getting the Weagles an extra draft pick.