Coaching dynastys

[dreampolice]

Now this is interesting!
Name the players who played under the follwing coaches and then went on to coach themselves.

Tom Hafey



Alan Jeans



Kevin Sheedy




Ron Barrassi




Who has the most? I reckon Hafey but i dunno!

 

[DaveW]

Who's Sheedy had? Thompson, Daniher, Watson?

 

[CharlieG]

Originally posted by DaveW
Who's Sheedy had? Thompson, Daniher, Watson?

Robert Shaw as well? I'm not entirely sure when he played... but he was an Essendon player and would surely be the right age to have played under Sheedy.

 

[DaveW]

Originally posted by CharlieG
Robert Shaw as well?

Oh yeah. Us Adelaide supporters try our best to forget about him.

 

[TD]

Originally posted by DaveW
Who's Sheedy had? Thompson, Daniher, Watson?

Denis Pagan, Mark Williams, Roger Merrett

 

[Vindaloo Mat]

every coach for Port since 1951 has either been:

a) Fos Williams
b) played with and/or under Fos
c) Fos' son.

Including the PAMFC.

VM

 

[DaveW]

Originally posted by TD
Denis Pagan, Mark Williams

Players not assistant coaches.

 

[pazza]

Tom Hafey has had:

Kevin Sheedy
Francis Bourke
Mick Malthouse
Tony Jewell
Ian Stewart
Paul Sproule
Royce Hart
John Northey
Barry Richardson
Mike Patterson
Kevin Bartlett
Neil Balme
Michael Erwin (all at Richmond)
Tony Shaw (at Collingwood)

Allan Jeans has had:

Ian Stewart
Darrell Baldock (at St. Kilda)
Leigh Matthews
Peter Knights
Gary Ayres
Gary Buckenara
Rodney Eade
Peter Schwab (at Hawthorn)


Kevin Sheedy has had:

Robert Shaw
Roger Merrett
Mark Thompson
Neale Daniher
Tim Watson

Ron Barassi has had:

John Nicholls
Alex Jesaulenko
Robert Walls (at Carlton)
Wayne Schimmelbusch
Malcolm Blight
Barry Cable (at North Melbourne)
Chris Connolly(at Melbourne)


Can't think of anymore than that

 

[Portmanteau]

Terry Wallace was at Hawthorn was he not?

 

[MarkT]

I presume this wasn't a trick question but, I've read the question carefully and the answer is:

No one
No one
No one
Malcom Blight.

Making Barassi the most with 1.

 

[crudbucket]

Originally posted by MarkT
I presume this wasn't a trick question but, I've read the question carefully and the answer is:

No one
No one
No one
Malcom Blight.

Making Barassi the most with 1.

Ha ha very funny But you're wrong anyway - Jezza at Carlton under Barassi and was later C/Coach at both carlton and St. Kilda.

Michael Nunan at Richmond under hafey in 1971, later coached Fitzroy.
Paul Feltham played at North under Barassi, later coached Brisbane.

 

[MarkT]

Not as smart as I thought.

 

[crudbucket]

After a lot of thought I have come up with the following :-

Hafey (17)
Northey, Stewart, Erwin, Shaw, Nunan, Drum, Balme, Williams, Richardson, Jewell, Bartlett, Bourke, Patterson, Sproule, Hart, Davis, Malthouse.
Barassi (14)
Blight, Cornes, Feltham, Walls, Jesaulenko, Jones, Silvagni, Nicholls, Hutchinson, Pagan, Schimmelbusch, Cable, Roos, Alves.
Jeans (11)
Knights, Matthews, Stewart, Ayres, Eade, Buckenara, Smith, Stewart, Malthouse, Wallace, Davis.
Sheedy (4)
Shaw, Merrett, Daniher, Watson.

I'll wager I've STILL missed someone !!!

 

[dreampolice]

Nice stuff crudbucket, i don't know the answer but jesus 17 for hafey, if thats right thats incredible!

 

[Pump]

Originally posted by pazza
Tom Hafey has had:

Kevin Sheedy
Francis Bourke
Mick Malthouse
Tony Jewell
Ian Stewart
Paul Sproule
Royce Hart
John Northey
Barry Richardson
Mike Patterson
Kevin Bartlett
Neil Balme
Michael Erwin (all at Richmond)
Tony Shaw (at Collingwood)

Allan Jeans has had:

Ian Stewart
Darrell Baldock (at St. Kilda)
Leigh Matthews
Peter Knights
Gary Ayres
Gary Buckenara
Rodney Eade
Peter Schwab (at Hawthorn)


Kevin Sheedy has had:

Robert Shaw
Roger Merrett
Mark Thompson
Neale Daniher
Tim Watson

Ron Barassi has had:

John Nicholls
Alex Jesaulenko
Robert Walls (at Carlton)
Wayne Schimmelbusch
Malcolm Blight
Barry Cable (at North Melbourne)
Chris Connolly(at Melbourne)


Can't think of anymore than that

You're a freak

Did Serg Silvagni play under Barassi @ Carlton?
Did Terry Wallace play under Jeans @ Hawthorn?
If C.Connolly played under Barassi @ Melbourne, perhaps Peter Rohde did as well?

 

[Pump]

Originally posted by crudbucket
I'll wager I've STILL missed someone !!! [/B]

How about Ditterich under either Jeans or Barassi?

 

[crudbucket]

Originally posted by crudbucket
After a lot of thought I have come up with the following :-

Hafey (17)
Northey, Stewart, Erwin, Shaw, Nunan, Drum, Balme, Williams, Richardson, Jewell, Bartlett, Bourke, Patterson, Sproule, Hart, Davis, Malthouse.
Barassi (14)
Blight, Cornes, Feltham, Walls, Jesaulenko, Jones, Silvagni, Nicholls, Hutchinson, Pagan, Schimmelbusch, Cable, Roos, Alves.
Jeans (11)
Knights, Matthews, Stewart, Ayres, Eade, Buckenara, Smith, Stewart, Malthouse, Wallace, Davis.
Sheedy (4)
Shaw, Merrett, Daniher, Watson.

I'll wager I've STILL missed someone !!!

#@$%$#%$ !!!!

Add to that the following :-

Hafey (Brett Scott)
Sheedy (Thompson)
Jeans (Ditterich, Schwab, Judge, Baldock)
Barassi (Connolly)

So its :-

Hafey (18)
Barassi & Jeans (15)
Sheedy (5)

Geez !!! And I'll better there's still MORE !!

 

[Becker]

Originally posted by crudbucket
After a lot of thought I have come up with the following :-

Jeans (11)
Knights, Matthews, Stewart, Ayres, Eade, Buckenara, Smith, Stewart, Malthouse, Wallace, Davis.
I'll wager I've STILL missed someone !!!

Carl Ditterich, Peter Schwab, Ken Judge .. just off the top of the head.

 

[kizza]

not really relevant, but sheeds has a few assistant coaches going around at the moment too:

Dean Wallis (St Kilda)
Gary O'Donnel (Brisbane)
Mark Harvey (Essendon)
Terry Daniher (Collingwood - assistant or special coach?)

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Would be interested to hear how many played under Parkin as well.

 

[jj flash]

How many had any success? Haffey's figures are bit inflated due to Richmond's revolving door policy on coaching appointments.

 

[Weaver]

Originally posted by jj flash
How many had any success? Haffey's figures are bit inflated due to Richmond's revolving door policy on coaching appointments.

You'd think that, but it isn't really true.

Only 7 of 18 were Richmond coaches. Of those Jewell (St Kilda), Northey (Swans, Brisbane and Melbourne) and Patterson (St Kilda) would have made the list whether or not Richmond had a revolving door policy.

Only Bourke, Bartlett, Sproule and Richardson are genuinely in this category.

Anyway between 1976 and 1995 (other than 1 year of Jeans) we had these 7 ex-Hafey boys. 8 guys over 20 seasons is not that bad. Saints have had 8 in the last 20, Swans have had 11 in the last 20, Hawks 8 in the last 20.

 

[Weaver]

Looking at the current 16 coaches ....

1st generation Hafey
Malthouse
Williams
Sheedy

2nd generation Hafey - coached by someone he coached
Thomas (Jewell and Patterson)
Thompson (Sheedy)
Laidley (Malthouse
Worsfold (Malthouse)
Daniher (Sheedy)
Frawley (Jewell)
Rhode (Northey + Balme)
Connolly (Northey)
Pagan (Stewart)
Roos (Shaw)

That only leaves the Hawks group of Ayres, Mathews and Schwab.

 

[MarkT]

Originally posted by crudbucket
Ha ha very funny But you're wrong anyway - Jezza at Carlton under Barassi and was later C/Coach at both carlton and St. Kilda.

Actually, did Jezza coach Carlton or did Lotfs coach them in '79? (I know what the records say)

 

[crudbucket]

Maybe, but Jezza DID C/Coach at St. Kilda, and there's also John Nicholls, who played under Barassi and the C/C'd the Blues ..