Collingwood 2.0

[2010premiership]

Could be half a dozen season ending injuries now, is the structure of the side better or worse? Faster? Which side for you?

Pre Injury:

FB: Shaw Brown Tarrant
HB: O'Brien Reid Maxwell
C: Thomas Ball Wellingham
HF: Beams Cloke Didak
FF: Blair Dawes Krakouer

Foll: Jolly Pendlebury Swan

Int: Sidebottom Toovey Johnson Fasolo

2.0:

FB: Clarke Brown Tarrant
HB: O'Brien Reid Maxwell
C: Beams Sidebottom Shaw
HF: Thomas Cloke Goldsack
FF: Fasolo Dawes Wellingham

Foll: Jolly Pendlebury Swan

Int: Blair Toovey Williams Sinclair


In: Clarke Goldsack Sinclair Williams

Out: Johnson Didak Krakouer Ball

 

[76woodenspooners]

Shaw stays in the 2.0 squad.

Williams is doing well, but it's too early to judge him.

No team is better for having Ball out of it.

 

[2010premiership]

Shaw stays in the 2.0 squad.

Williams is doing well, but it's too early to judge him.

No team is better for having Ball out of it.

Yeah but do Beams and Sidebottom become top 10 elite midfielders if Ball is still there and they are playing high half forward?

And yep Shaw still there on a wing

 

[Temploar]

IS that a stupid question? Of course i'd rather have the side with NO injuries. It's getting a bit ridiculous.

 

[2010premiership]

IS that a stupid question? Of course i'd rather have the side with NO injuries. It's getting a bit ridiculous.

Of course everyone would, but there are advantages like unearthing players that wouldn't have got a chance, or players like Beams and Sidebottom that step up to an unimaginable level, those things change the composition and structure of a team

2.0 looks faster and harder to me, suits the press

Original Coke is more experienced with genuine X factor