Collingwood List of the Decade - #5 & #6

[Lensen]

As many have pointed out, only one man has worn the #5 guernsey throughout the last decade - Nathan Buckley. Therefore, he gets an automatic spot into this list. I'm sure no one will begrudge him that...

The List so far:

#1 - Damian Monkhorst
#2 - Tony Francis
#3 - Ryan Lonie
#4 - Alan Didak
#5 - Nathan Buckley

We're on to #6. There are two options this time. Just so everyone's aware, the "decade" is the last 10 years - ie, not just the 90s.

Stephen "Patto" Patterson (1995-2000, 96 games, 88 goals)
Brodie "Dutchy" Holland (2001-2004, 72 games, 75 goals)

Vote away!

 

[leonmagic]

Dutch.

 

[Lensen]

Holland quite easily here. Whilst I think Patto was quite handy, he was nowhere near as good in his six years as Holland has been in his four. Patterson was underrated, but not enough to put him ahead of Holland.

 

[The Scarecrow]

Holland.

 

[Pedro]

Holland. I've never seen a guy tackled so often as Patterson.

 

[grayza]

i had to go for dutchy as well, couldnt bring myself to vote for patterson even though his record seems superior

 

[tomaraya]

might as well go to the next #. this one's as good as over.
will be suprised if patto gets a single legitimate vote.
and he was far from being underrated. probably the best of our duds at that stage, but a dud none the less.

 

[Nardz]

might as well go to the next #. this one's as good as over.
will be suprised if patto gets a single legitimate vote.
and he was far from being underrated. probably the best of our duds at that stage, but a dud none the less.

couldnt agree more.

 

[MACDAICOS]

Holland by a mile, patto drove me crazy

 

[hotpie]

Patto unfortunately was categorised with Raso, Tuddenham, Liddell, Wild and many many others, but he was better than that. He was very underrated.

Holland's better though.

 

[you idiot sheehan]

Dutchy. Let's go to Number 7.

 

[Johnson#26]

Dutchy. I always had a soft spot for Patto.